GH1 firmware research volunteers required

Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 512, 352, 220, 200
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

SCENE 1:

Overall bit rate : 79.5 Mbps
Bit rate : 79.0 Mbps
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 2.857
Frame rate : 30.000 fps

download link:
http://www.nikolicnemanja.com/scene1.rar

When comparing the MJPEG file to the AVCHD files from the SCENE 1 download link, the MJPEG video has crushed black levels and a noisier image than the AVCHD videos even at that super high bitrate (79 Mbps) for the MJPEG file. The AVCHD videos were at 14 Mbps.

Add to that the disadvantage of 30p video, when most people want 24p, and 16K instead of 48K audio.

Update:

Using the VLC Player and Splash Lite Player the black levels were crushed playing the MJPEG video. Using QuickTime or Windows Media Player the black levels looked fine and comparable to the AVCHD videos. Not as noticeable noise difference either when using QuickTime Player of Windows Media Player.

Actually looking at it again with Windows Media Player, the MJPEG video is slightly darker when compared to the AVCHD video but not as drastic when I use the VLC or Splash players.

Randy
 
Last edited:
Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 720, 412, 352, 300
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

Overall bit rate : 80.7 Mbps
Bit rate : 80.2 Mbps
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 2.901
 
Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 720, 512, 428, 400
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

Overall bit rate : 101 Mbps
Bit rate : 100 Mbps
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 3.630

Camera stops recording after 5 sec due to Card speed...
 
Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 720, 512, 428, 350
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

Overall bit rate : 90.8 Mbps
Bit rate : 90.3 Mbps
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 3.266

CAMERa stops recording after 10sec...
 
When comparing the MJPEG file to the AVCHD files from the SCENE 1 download link, the MJPEG video has crushed black levels and a noisier image than the AVCHD videos even at that super high bitrate (79 Mbps) for the MJPEG file. The AVCHD videos were at 14 Mbps.

Add to that the disadvantage of 30p video, when most people want 24p, and 16K instead of 48K audio.

Update:

Using the VLC Player and Splash Lite Player the black levels were crushed playing the MJPEG video. Using QuickTime or Windows Media Player the black levels looked fine and comparable to the AVCHD videos. Not as noticeable noise difference either when using QuickTime Player of Windows Media Player.

Actually looking at it again with Windows Media Player, the MJPEG video is slightly darker when compared to the AVCHD video but not as drastic when I use the VLC or Splash players.

Randy

In AE looks the same...
I applied Sharpness at 50 % and mpjeg do not show artefacts ( beside horrible picture with 50% sharpness)
 
In AE looks the same...
I applied Sharpness at 50 % and mpjeg do not show artefacts ( beside horrible picture with 50% sharpness)

Ya, I figured that might be the case but there are going to be people playing the files using a video player like I did and just wanted it to be known that this might happen.

Update:

I just dropped the files into Edius Neo Booster and the MJPEG and AVCHD files both have the same black and comparable noise levels when viewing them in the timeline.

One thing I noticed in the timeline is the audio waveform on the MJPEG file has no gap at the beginning of the video, the AVCHD files have a 1/2 second delay before the audio waveform starts. This was both on the 720P and 1080P AVCHD files.

Also, there is much more detail in the MJPEG file compared to the AVCHD file. There is a cement walkway in this video and I can see the detail and texture of the cement in the MJPEG file whereas the AVCHD file this is blurred/smoothed out more.

Randy
 
Last edited:
Also, there is much more detail in the MJPEG file compared to the AVCHD file. There is a cement walkway in this video and I can see the detail and texture of the cement in the MJPEG file whereas the AVCHD file this is blurred/smoothed out more.

Yeees.... MJPEG rules. Also, MJPEG is easier to edit.
I hope tester13 will achieve 24 o 25 fps. :Drogar-Happy(DBG):
And at these insane bitrates, plus after lastest tests, we can even dream on 1080p MJPEG (just dreaming, right now...)
 
i get the feeling we are about to reach Warp speed with these MJPEG developments .. a major breakthrough is almost here?? quite exciting :)
 
After looking at NURBS, I couldn't help it. I had to apply hacked patch with the same setting he used in order to see for myself. AND I SEE A LOT MORE DETAILS IN MPEG HD MODE COMPARED TO AVCHD SH MODE.

Setting I used is below.

Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 352, 220, 200, 184
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

* NOTE: I USE TOSHIBA SDHC 16G CLASS 4

MPEG result - around 43 Mbps


Here is AVCHD SH result


From Mov 30fps to MP4 24fps test
 
Last edited:
One thing I noticed in the timeline is the audio waveform on the MJPEG file has no gap at the beginning of the video, the AVCHD files have a 1/2 second delay before the audio waveform starts. This was both on the 720P and 1080P AVCHD files.

Randy[/quote]

The audio gap may have been caused by pressing the "Record" button a bit too long. The manual warns about this.
Don't remember if it only affects AVCHD recordings.
 
Any 1080p mjpeg options working?

Any 1080p mjpeg options working?

To be honest I'd be happy with 1080p30 or 25p, mud free at 30Mb/s.
 
There is always an audio gap in GH1 AVCHD recordings (I mean, in the "stock" camera).

Yep, but it looks like MJPEG files with the GH1 don't have that "gap" problem, which is a good thing, if that's what you want to record with instead of AVCHD.

Randy
 
After looking at NURBS, I couldn't help it. I had to apply hacked patch with the same setting he used in order to see for myself. AND I SEE A LOT MORE DETAILS IN MPEG HD MODE COMPARED TO AVCHD SH MODE.

Setting I used is below.

Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 352, 220, 200, 184
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

* NOTE: I USE TOSHIBA SDHC 16G CLASS 4

MPEG result - around 43 Mbps


Here is AVCHD SH result


From Mov 30fps to MP4 24fps test
Yep leavs in trees look better, but still see artifacting on the fence as well as the lamp post, I'm pretty sure it's the sprinklers messing w/ the codec. And in the Mov 30fps to MP4 24fps test-- it looks like some chromatic aberration on the wet parts of grass.

getting there:smile:
 
My test for this settings:

Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 720, 512, 428, 400
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24


Bit rate : 77 Mbps <- Nice result
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 3.000
Duration: 10.00 sec.

Camera don't freezing for all record time. (Sandisk, Class-4, 9MB/s)
 
My test for this settings:

Quality settings (E1 to E4) - 720, 512, 428, 400
Table settings (E1 to E4) - 24, 24, 24, 24

Bit rate : 77 Mbps <- Nice result
Bits/(Pixel*Frame) : 3.000
Duration: 10.00 sec.

Camera don't freezing for all record time. (Sandisk, Class-4, 9MB/s)

Wow!

How long of recording time do you get with this setting, NURBS?
 
Back
Top