First lighting kit?

My experience with the 1000W: I haven't turned it on. I bought this kit because the price was the same as getting the 150+300+650 and then the dimmers, so I got the 1K for free. I don't need it, and I'm already worried about the heat in the 650W unit (I think it can create some serious burns if anybody touches it with bare hands). I thought about selling the 1K, but since it was basically free and shipping from Spain is so expensive, I've just put it in store in case I ever need more punch.

On the other hand, the 150 doesn't throw a lot of light. For me the best kit would be 300+300+650. But my needs are very personal: YMMV.
 
I'm already worried about the heat in the 650W unit (I think it can create some serious burns if anybody touches it with bare hands).

Yes, it reaches its operating temperature after just minutes. Gloves or a towel are needed just handle the barndoors. The gels are up to the task, not sure the longest I've had the 650W on but it's at least two hours. Don't use theatre gels with them and obviously keep the lights away from curtains.


On the other hand, the 150 doesn't throw a lot of light. For me the best kit would be 300+300+650. But my needs are very personal: YMMV.

Yeah, when I say they're useful I don't mean one, I mean several. Four lights draw the same power and produce the same heat as one 650W. Great for shaping backgrounds, filling against a 300 or bounced 650 key or a subtle hairlight if you want to lift the subject without blasting them from behind. They are pretty ineffective off a bounce if they are too far. To put some numbers on it I measure the 650W at 2m to be 840 lux while the 150W at the same distance is 170 lux.
 
Junct, if you're in New Zealand, could you get Selecon Acclaim lights at a reasonable price? The Acclaims are 650w fresnels, and I think they're made in NZ.

Kevin
 
Look into used theatre fresnels too - dirt cheap compared to Arri/Mole units, and with just a TVMP adapter, they're usually ready to go.
 
Sonofaresiii: I'm a student. My weekly paycheck covers my rent and expenses with enough for a couple of pints left over - so saving up much more than I've budgeted isn't a hugely realistic option. I have done some experimenting with clamp and work lights, and have done ok with them, but I want to try something which I can control a little better. As for making my own - that is an option, though I am terrible with any sort of diy work, and my only work space is my small bedroom.

I totally understand that, and I wasn't trying to be a dick or dismissive. I may not have been clear, but my point wasn't "Augh you don't deserve lights you hack!" it was more "Don't waste your money on this stuff."

I know what it's like to be tight with money, but the fact is professional equipment costs a lot. There's no "secret deal" out there where you get great lights for cheap... they just don't exist. If they did, we'd all be using them. So I was trying to let you know that cheap good lights are an oxymoron, and anything claiming they're both cheap and good is lying to you. I've seen tons of people show up with these kits, telling me they've got lighting gear under control... I just laugh, turn that junk off and tell them we're better off shooting ambient.

Clamp lights, work lights, used stage lights aren't going to be professional equipment, but they're not trying to be, and that's why you can get decent quality for cheap. You're going to have to fiddle with it, it's not going to be great, but I really, really think trying to buy a "kit" on extremely limited funds is as good as throwing your money down the toilet.

Actually, it's worse, because once you get the lights you're going to try and use them and wreck your video.

Anyway, that's my opinion, best of luck though.
 
Look into used theatre fresnels too - dirt cheap compared to Arri/Mole units, and with just a TVMP adapter, they're usually ready to go.
Rightio, will do. Is there anything one needs to know about converting them?

Junct, if you're in New Zealand, could you get Selecon Acclaim lights at a reasonable price? The Acclaims are 650w fresnels, and I think they're made in NZ.

Kevin
Thanks for the tip, I've flicked them an email.

My experience with the 1000W: I haven't turned it on. I bought this kit because the price was the same as getting the 150+300+650 and then the dimmers, so I got the 1K for free. I don't need it, and I'm already worried about the heat in the 650W unit (I think it can create some serious burns if anybody touches it with bare hands). I thought about selling the 1K, but since it was basically free and shipping from Spain is so expensive, I've just put it in store in case I ever need more punch.

On the other hand, the 150 doesn't throw a lot of light. For me the best kit would be 300+300+650. But my needs are very personal: YMMV.
Ahk, the heat is an interesting issue. As a general question, how do people deal with the heat issue with 2ks and the like?

Also, what are your personal uses? :)

I totally understand that, and I wasn't trying to be a dick or dismissive. I may not have been clear, but my point wasn't "Augh you don't deserve lights you hack!" it was more "Don't waste your money on this stuff."

I know what it's like to be tight with money, but the fact is professional equipment costs a lot. There's no "secret deal" out there where you get great lights for cheap... they just don't exist. If they did, we'd all be using them. So I was trying to let you know that cheap good lights are an oxymoron, and anything claiming they're both cheap and good is lying to you. I've seen tons of people show up with these kits, telling me they've got lighting gear under control... I just laugh, turn that junk off and tell them we're better off shooting ambient.

Clamp lights, work lights, used stage lights aren't going to be professional equipment, but they're not trying to be, and that's why you can get decent quality for cheap. You're going to have to fiddle with it, it's not going to be great, but I really, really think trying to buy a "kit" on extremely limited funds is as good as throwing your money down the toilet.

Actually, it's worse, because once you get the lights you're going to try and use them and wreck your video.

Anyway, that's my opinion, best of luck though.
Noted and take into consideration. I didn't think you were trying to be a dick btw, and I do actually agree with you on this for the most part.
 
For what it's worth, what I'd do if it was me... hell, what I *did* do, was skip the "kit" for now and think more long-term. If you want to keep doing this and make money, you've got to think about where you're gonna be in a year, not right now. So what I did was, every month or so scrape together whatever extra money I had lying around and buy one decent light. It took a while, and it's an eclectic mess, but it's my eclectic mess and it works. You go out, you get a light and you shoot with it. Your videos are slightly better and you get more work, you get a little more money and you buy a light. Your videos get slightly better, you get a little more work, more money, and another light...

it's like a video game. You start out small, level up from level one with basic leather armor, then level up some more, get the chain mail, level up some more, get the steel armor.

I know there's a huge desire to get something you can shoot with RIGHT NOW, but if you get a POS kit, a year from now you're gonna have a bag of unreliable wiring, broken screws, housing held together with tape and stands with two legs. And you're gonna have to pony up the money for real lights anyway, but you'll be a year behind.
 
For what it's worth, what I'd do if it was me... hell, what I *did* do, was skip the "kit" for now and think more long-term. If you want to keep doing this and make money, you've got to think about where you're gonna be in a year, not right now. So what I did was, every month or so scrape together whatever extra money I had lying around and buy one decent light. It took a while, and it's an eclectic mess, but it's my eclectic mess and it works. You go out, you get a light and you shoot with it. Your videos are slightly better and you get more work, you get a little more money and you buy a light. Your videos get slightly better, you get a little more work, more money, and another light...

it's like a video game. You start out small, level up from level one with basic leather armor, then level up some more, get the chain mail, level up some more, get the steel armor.

I know there's a huge desire to get something you can shoot with RIGHT NOW, but if you get a POS kit, a year from now you're gonna have a bag of unreliable wiring, broken screws, housing held together with tape and stands with two legs. And you're gonna have to pony up the money for real lights anyway, but you'll be a year behind.
You provide a good argument, but I will re-iterate that I am not doing this with the intention of becoming a DoP - focussing too much on it will be taking away from the other work I want to be focussing on (primarily writing/directing/editing - and maybe eventually just editing) and so I don't know if I will be doing enough with higher end gear, learning enough about proper theory, etc to justify the cost.

But I'm still taking into consideration what you've said. If I did go the more DIY route, what sort of guidance would you give to begin this? Or if you know any tutorials, starting points, etc on assembling a kit from work and clamp lights, etc.
 
I know there's a huge desire to get something you can shoot with RIGHT NOW, but if you get a POS kit, a year from now you're gonna have a bag of unreliable wiring, broken screws, housing held together with tape and stands with two legs. And you're gonna have to pony up the money for real lights anyway, but you'll be a year behind.

A year behind in money but a year ahead in practical application. I don't disagree with your position in principle and I'm not trying to advocate against buying pro gear or against applying the 'buy once cry once' mantra. I just get sick of seeing the blind zealotry from some of those do advocate that philosophy, unable to envisage circumstances/end-goals other than their own. There is a place for cheap gear so long as it is chosen with due consideration of one's needs and requirements. I bought a $2000 car, it does the job. It will last me at least two years, maybe many more. Should I have spent $60,000? And there is cheap gear and cheap gear. The gear responsible for your bad experience may not be replicated in another's choices.In general, pro gear is more likely to lead to a positive experience is a more accurate assessment.

From junct's statement of intentions he won't be subjecting his kit to much more abuse than I have mine. After two years of home studio use, other than a couple of scratches and a few bulbs reaching the end of their life, everything is as functional as the day I unboxed it. By my assessment, if there is one area you can save a few bucks it's tungsten lighting. I'd rather not skimp on glass or camera support. That directly impacts on quality of image and security of your most expensive assets respectively. A cheap tungsten light puts out exactly the same quality of light as the most expensive one. The same cannot be said of other technologies but tungsten yes. The technology is ancient and well understood. The bulbs are the same. The light can be controlled just as effectively so long as it has the same features. The areas you sacrifice is ergonomics, warranty/repair, durability and longetivity of the unit; and the only reason I recommend the ones is they are ahead of the curve on durability and repair.

For the record in spite of championing these lights (as long as you get them checked by an electrician) my own next ones will be genuine Arris. I'm ready for them now financially and in the meantime I'm further ahead in lighting application than I would have been. I had 3 lights from the get go and have been playing with a 10 light kit for over 6 months. I am glad I took the risk on these, I don't warrant them but the risk certainly paid off for me. I'm not browbeating anyone into buying them. Knowledge is power, junct is now well aware of the good and the bad. That allows for an informed choice rather than a non-specific and dismissive 'anything cheap is bad'.
 
EGS has given some pretty useful advice, and I'm really thankful for it. It has given me a good understanding of the "no budget" options and the risks involved. It is nice to hear a voice that doesn't condemn prosumer and below grade stuff with complete aggression (something that seems to happen a lot in film gear talk, particularly around lighting and audio I've noted).

I don't disagree with the sentiment of these messages, and they're useful for bringing to light the limitations of the equipment - but at the same time they are a better option for some. Sonofaresiii has provided a good argument, and it is one I am still considering. I am interested in hearing his thoughts on the DIY route (which is a more likely path for me than buying a *good* light when I can and slowly building my collection).

Both sides are useful, and I thank all the posters in this thread for the lengths they've gone to provide such invaluable information. It's all stuff available online, but it's nice to hear it mediated in this way. Often advice falls between the "buy once" mantra, and the blind and at times somewhat ignorant faith in the low budget options - something I've noted from a lot of youtube reviewers when talking about sound who clearly little knowledge (I would assume this is also applicable to lighting). The discussion here has made navigating these viewpoints a lot simpler, so thanks again to all. And if anyone else has anything to add, I'm interested in hearing that too.
 
Also, what are your personal uses? :)

* I'm not a pro, for me this is just a (very expensive) hobby.
* 90% of what I shoot are just-for-fun pieces: no budget, no crew (just me), only available lighting (examples here here and here).
* I want to shoot more scripted stuff, with a crew, careful production, etc. I've already shot some of this but it's not public yet (CGI gurus taking their time, this is a hobby for me but a big bet for them). A DP from this forum has seen the work-in-progress and just couldn't believe how we actually shot it (he doesn't like the camera we used, he would never light like we did, and still he liked the final result). We have to shoot another scene for that piece, and that's why I bought the fresnels (at least part of the reason; wanting to learn how to light properly is the bigger part).

This weekend I'm shooting a relatively elaborate two-minutes piece with a script but no dialogue. Again, no budget, no crew. And again, mostly available lighting: we'll be shooting at a park so I'll just bring a couple of big 5-in-1 reflectors (the most useful pieces of lighting kit I own, by a mile). No CGI gurus to worry about every little detail this time, so that one will hopefully be public in about a month (and wont' be 1% as good as the bigger one, of course).

As you see, it makes absolutely no sense for me to buy a super-expensive ARRI kit. That's why I always have to say that YMMV.
 
Last edited:
A year behind in money but a year ahead in practical application. I don't disagree with your position in principle and I'm not trying to advocate against buying pro gear or against applying the 'buy once cry once' mantra. I just get sick of seeing the blind zealotry from some of those do advocate that philosophy, unable to envisage circumstances/end-goals other than their own. There is a place for cheap gear so long as it is chosen with due consideration of one's needs and requirements. I bought a $2000 car, it does the job. It will last me at least two years, maybe many more. Should I have spent $60,000? And there is cheap gear and cheap gear. The gear responsible for your bad experience may not be replicated in another's choices.In general, pro gear is more likely to lead to a positive experience is a more accurate assessment.

From junct's statement of intentions he won't be subjecting his kit to much more abuse than I have mine. After two years of home studio use, other than a couple of scratches and a few bulbs reaching the end of their life, everything is as functional as the day I unboxed it. By my assessment, if there is one area you can save a few bucks it's tungsten lighting. I'd rather not skimp on glass or camera support. That directly impacts on quality of image and security of your most expensive assets respectively. A cheap tungsten light puts out exactly the same quality of light as the most expensive one. The same cannot be said of other technologies but tungsten yes. The technology is ancient and well understood. The bulbs are the same. The light can be controlled just as effectively so long as it has the same features. The areas you sacrifice is ergonomics, warranty/repair, durability and longetivity of the unit; and the only reason I recommend the ones is they are ahead of the curve on durability and repair.

For the record in spite of championing these lights (as long as you get them checked by an electrician) my own next ones will be genuine Arris. I'm ready for them now financially and in the meantime I'm further ahead in lighting application than I would have been. I had 3 lights from the get go and have been playing with a 10 light kit for over 6 months. I am glad I took the risk on these, I don't warrant them but the risk certainly paid off for me. I'm not browbeating anyone into buying them. Knowledge is power, junct is now well aware of the good and the bad. That allows for an informed choice rather than a non-specific and dismissive 'anything cheap is bad'.


You're not wrong, but the simple fact that all tungsten light IS the same is why I'd recommend getting cheap clamp lights/used stage lights instead of a "kit."

I know there's a lot of people out there that say don't buy anything until you've got your $4k saved up and can buy a "real" kit. I'm not advocating that, I know everyone has different circumstances. I'm just saying if you're going to buy a kit, it should be one of the professional ones, and if you can't afford one of the more professional ones, don't buy a kit-- because it's all the same light anyway, and I think the cheap "kits" are ripping you off.

Seriously. Go to ebay, do a search for colortran. Every month or so something good comes up. They're cheap, used old stage lights. They work, they last, they're weird and non-standard and they're not a kit. They're just bulbs in metal housing.

Anyway, that's my opinion. I think you're wasting your money if you go get a brand new "kit" online that's only a couple hundred bucks. I'm really not one of those guys that thinks you need to buy the highest-end professional equipment, or else you should quit cinematography forever and go be an accountant. I just think you either need to go to one extreme or the other, driving to the middle isn't a compromise, it's the worst of both worlds.
 
You provide a good argument, but I will re-iterate that I am not doing this with the intention of becoming a DoP - focussing too much on it will be taking away from the other work I want to be focussing on (primarily writing/directing/editing - and maybe eventually just editing) and so I don't know if I will be doing enough with higher end gear, learning enough about proper theory, etc to justify the cost.

But I'm still taking into consideration what you've said. If I did go the more DIY route, what sort of guidance would you give to begin this? Or if you know any tutorials, starting points, etc on assembling a kit from work and clamp lights, etc.


Sure, let me get back to you when I have some time.
 
Sure, let me get back to you when I have some time.
Cheers

Seriously. Go to ebay, do a search for colortran. Every month or so something good comes up. They're cheap, used old stage lights. They work, they last, they're weird and non-standard and they're not a kit. They're just bulbs in metal housing.
Seems like a good option. What do you do for stands/barn doors/gels/etc?
 
Rightio, will do. Is there anything one needs to know about converting them?

Nope, the TVMP adapter just let's you mount them easily on a lightstand (most theatre lights have yokes designed for hanging from an overhead lighting grid). Once you've got the light, a stand and the TVMP adapter in your hands it will all seem pretty self-explanatory.
 
Nope, the TVMP adapter just let's you mount them easily on a lightstand (most theatre lights have yokes designed for hanging from an overhead lighting grid). Once you've got the light, a stand and the TVMP adapter in your hands it will all seem pretty self-explanatory.
Thanks for the tip. Given the advantage of going this route is likely durability, do you have any recommendations on c-stands and the like? They can be pretty expensive I've noticed. What sort of things (brands?) to look for?
 
Thanks for the tip. Given the advantage of going this route is likely durability, do you have any recommendations on c-stands and the like? They can be pretty expensive I've noticed. What sort of things (brands?) to look for?

Well I'm afraid I can't really offer any advice on cheaper c-stands. I bought a couple of Matthews C-stands to save money over going with the Avenger units I was used to - and ended up returning them and paying the extra for Avenger versions instead. There was nothing inherently wrong with the Matthews stands, but the construction isn't on the same level as the Avengers - and for stands that I expect to last me the next 15-20 years, having total confidence in the strength of their construction mattered more to me than the extra few hundred dollars I had to spend.
 
Cheers

Seems like a good option. What do you do for stands/barn doors/gels/etc?

it depends on the light. seriously, even just within colortran, i've found they're all different. one may take scrims perfectly, but have a non-standard mount. i just go to b&h and look until I find an adapter that fits (or make up a franken-rig out of whatever parts I can find). Another had a standard 5/8" opening for a stand, and came with barndoors screwed on, but it was rectangular so no scrims. I'd just clip gels, or netting to the barndoors, or use frames on c-stands.

in other words, don't worry about it. just get the lights, and if you find you need something specific, there'll be an adapter or workaround out there. like i said, they're not professional lights, but they're not trying to be. besides, a lot of your light control won't happen on the light itself anyway.
 
Alrighty. I'm comfortable enough taking the light controlling accesories on a light-by-light basis. But as expressed before, if you have any thoughts specifically around stands, that'd be useful. There is quite a price variance, so the stands could quite easily make this an expensive option.
 
Back
Top