Apple probably needs to do some damage control, Now.

PRO users are bad consumers in Apples mind. Its a small market

What Apple has done in my opinion is used the brand power of FCP slapped it on the next gen iMovie and will cash out as hobby editors upgrade to what they think is "pro software" Just imagine how sexy it is if you are an iMovie editor without the means to go Pro and suddenly the pro market is 300 bucks.

I agree that Apple has gone "all in" on the prosumer market. Once they've exhausted the prosumer market they'll lower the price again and go after the much larger consumer market. How about FCP XI for your iPad or iPhone at $100 ?
 
To people that haven't been editing for years and years on other platforms, iMovie feels intiuitive, like the way video *should* be edited, if such a thing were a natural occurence.

The problem is that it works for little videos that don't use any kind of "finessing." Once you really have to go in there and do the crazy things that professional editors have to do in order to achieve results, then the process starts to break down.

FCP X does too much thinking for you, and then you have to fight it when it's wrong, ultimately to the detriment of the project.
 
Meh. You guys have to remember Apple's identity, their whole business has changed with the popularity of iproducts. It's all about profits and feeding the cash cow, not supporting an industry.

That being said, I'll recommend this nice article http://blog.nicedissolve.com/2011/06/pro-missing-features/

"consider that we’re talking about the same company that, in 2007, shipped a new smartphone platform that didn’t support third-party apps, copy and paste, and other features that people thought should be taken for granted, without so much as a word about future plans to fill in those gaps. People freaked out. But things turned out pretty well for the iPhone in the long run."
 
DChang, that would just make me buy a different phone at the time (I didn't get the iphone until the 3Gs came out). That's fine for a phone. It takes me an hour to learn how to use a different phone, tops. The different phone in this situation would be Premiere or Avid. That's a much pricier "phone" with a much longer/steeper learning curve.

This would also be like Apple releasing the iPhone 5 only on Cricket wireless, and without a home button. "One of the new features of the iPhone 5 is that we really want you to think about which apps to open. So once you're in that app, you have to shut your phone off to get to another app. We want people to think more. We've also streamlined the volume controls. There are none! I makes the phone sleeker, and more user friendly."
 
To respond to the original thread post, I agree. The tight-lipped-ness is a real mistake at this hour...

Larry Jordan's comments about 'dot-zero' releases (which he later rescinded after "speaking to Apple") seem to have held true. I also find interesting the quotes Larry shared with us from Apple PR saying 'if this was iMovie on steroids, we wouldn't have chosen this audience':
http://www.fcp.co/final-cut-pro/new...t-be-ready-for-professional-useq-larry-jordan

Larry Jordan: "I need an on-the-record quote of why this is not iMovie on steroids"
Richard Townhill (Director of Pro-Apps Product Marketing): "We would not roll this program out to this audience, at this time, in this way, if all we wanted to do was present a new version of iMovie"

I run a small post department. I am not opposed to re-learning anything in the way of media management, or workflow, and was actually looking forward to this release. However, the FCPX delivered can not be used by my industry. We require interfacing with colorists and sound mixers. We need to watch our edits in broadcast quality on high-end monitors.

A very well-known television network released a (I'm not sure if it's a public) statement today saying they could not accept projects edited on the new FCPX software, as it is not adequate for their delivery requirements. While they left it open that this may be amended in the future, FCPX in its current form will not suffice.

Apple, at the WWDC event, and through many quotes shared with us by NDA-bound preview participants, led our industry to believe they were producing a Professional product.

Unless they explain their targeting to the Professional market, we're left feeling like this was a cheap marketing tactic to get us all to buy it up front.
 
Last edited:
Hawk, Apple's money comes from customers who didn't want to buy another phone, they just HAD to have every new version of the iproduct, regardless of faults. If Apple can get those types of people to believe they can use FCP then they could care less about the professional users. They will make their money from the largest source of profits for the last few years, and professional FCP users are not it. The writing really was on the wall, hopefully Adobe can take advantage, they've been making good progress in premiere.
 
From my post over at Creative Cow:

Apple probably needs to do some damage control, Now.

by Clayton Burkhart on Jun 22, 2011 at 2:49:53 am


Ok, given the near universal negative response to this release across a broad spectrum of forums out there, I really think that Apple needs to do some damage control, NOW.

This post really isn't about me or my satisfaction at all. I can go on using what I always have. I have nowhere near the talent and expertise of so many seasoned pros here, but I have seen one or two situations like this before in my time and this is what I see: If Apple was a Hollywood star, their PR firm would definitely be all over this, trying to formulate a damage control plan.

It really would be wise for them to make some kind of semi-official announcement basically saying, we know that we kinda blew it, BUT, we are listening to YOU the professionals.

I can understand the silence leading up to the release, but now that it is out there, continued silence probably wouldn't be the right move.

They likely need to say to the professional, we recognize the shortcomings you have pointed out, you matter to us and we will try to move this forward in a more transparent way. We are listening, we still believe in the quality of our new product, and we will provide you with a product that fulfills your needs.

Real damage control always acknowledges the reality and the mistake. Everyone, including corporations make mistakes, but respect is always actually gained when the party involved takes immediate and open responsibility for it.

And then, LISTENING. They definitely need to show that they are listening.

Hold another town meeting, make a questionaire, convene a panel of experts, whatever. The point is ASK people what they really want.

It is the only way I think they can turn this around, otherwise I am seeing a serious migration away from Apple. The signs of open disdain and heading for the exits were already there, but I am not witnessing a slow shuffle away this evening, I am watching a virtual stampede.

very well said!
 
According to Philip Schiller, Apple's senior vice president of worldwide product marketing, many of the world's best Pro editors had their jaws drop when shown Final Cut Pro X. "I’m blown away by what Apple has done with Final Cut Pro,” Apple quoted Academy Award-winning film editor Angus Wall as saying.

My jaw dropped as well:cry::cry::cry::cry::cry:
 
Back
Top