60p reslolution hit?

I think you may be looking at the 60i frame rates. 1080 60p is not available on-camera as far as I am aware. It is only available through the 3g dual HD SDI outputs. Got that bit by watching the sony presentation on vimeo. So no - no resolution hit but you will need one of the expensive and rare recorders that can handle the 60p Full HD signal.

Cinedeck is such a device plus sony's own imminent recorder. Or tethered to a blackmagic design card which is affordable.
 
Last edited:
I think you should check out the Sony product page. Click on the "specifications" tab. Then look at recording frame rates. If you look closely you'll see that 59.94p is recorded using 1440 x 1080. I hope I'm reading it wrong. Also, on the original page featuring the highlights it clearly states that 60p comes standard through dual link.

http://pro.sony.com/bbsc/ssr/product-PMWF3L/
 
I think you should check out the Sony product page. Click on the "specifications" tab. Then look at recording frame rates. If you look closely you'll see that 59.94p is recorded using 1440 x 1080.

That would appear to be a typo. I own a production run F3. Just checked the menus. The HQ 1440x1080 is 59.94i, not p. This matches everything we've been told to date.

But regardless... what you're refering to are recording specifications, which have nothing to do with the camera's capability to feed out a dual link HD-SDI 1080 60p (59.94p) video signal. Sony's recording specs are tied to the SxS recording media, and it's XDCAM-EX compression. The camera outputs however, bypass that compression. And by the nature of the signal specification, a dual link 1080p signal is going to be full raster 1920x1080 (Barry Green strike me down if I'm wrong).

The specs you're reading have nothing to do with the dual link capabilites.
 
Thank you Henry E. but no one is debating whether or not you can record 1080 60p in camera or not. It's well known that you can't. I simply noticed one of the specs on the Sony product page that states 60p is recorded using 1440 x 1080. James thinks it's a typo. I hope he's right as I've already pre-ordered an F3.
 
Andy Shipsides answers your question on the other forum... Looks like its not a typo!

http://www.dvinfo.net/forum/sony-xdcam-f3-cinealta/492349-60p-resolution-hit.html#post1622730

He states...

"The camera can already output 1080 60p over dual link with no firmware needed. It just cannot record that in full raster on the cards. It seems like the 35mbps cap is hard set in the Xdcam Ex world.. So Sony fit the 60p in by reducing resolution. The F800 does something similar with a reduced vertical resolution. Now if only their was an affordable 1080 60p external recorder.

Andy"

H
 
Thank you Henry E. but no one is debating whether or not you can record 1080 60p in camera or not. It's well known that you can't. I simply noticed one of the specs on the Sony product page that states 60p is recorded using 1440 x 1080. James thinks it's a typo. I hope he's right as I've already pre-ordered an F3.

You've missed my point - which is that you're conflating "recording" to be the same as "output," which is simply not the case. The camera sensor receives a vast amount of data. To record this data to the XDCAM-EX codec on the internal SxS card media slots, the camera must choose which data is important, and which to discard. White balance, picture profile settings, gammas, gain - these are all processes applied to the sensor data, helping choose which data is important to retain, and which to discard.

The camera offers you a number of compression choices - including options to record at 1440x1080 59.94 interlaced - not progressive. Yes, you found a Sony document with a typo. Not only does my camera menu say 1440x1080i (and can prove it in FCP), but the Sony manual, at the bottom of page 37 confirms, once again, that it's interlace: http://ws.sel.sony.com/PIPWebServic...L-asset-250124/original/PMW-F3 Ops Manual.pdf

But... those compression choices have very little to do with the camera output signals. The camera output signals - dual link HD-SDI, and regular HD-SDI, bypass the XDCAM-EX compression. The data comes from the camera sensor, and is either processed into an S-Log gamma curve (with April update, and mode S-Log mode selected), or is processed with camcorder picture profiles, white balance, etc - then sent to your selected camera output. Recording compression never comes into the mix. What does matter is that for the respective output (HD-SDI, Dual Link HD-SDI, HDMI, Composite), the camera must conform the processed (but *not* compressed) sensor data into a legal video signal. Otherwise, external video equipment wouldn't understand the data, and couldn't record or display a picture.

When it comes the HD-SDI, and Dual Link HD-SDI, the options are:

  • The nominal 1.5 Gbit/s interfaces support most high definition formats. Supported formats include 1080/60i, 1080/59.94i, 1080/50i, 1080/30p, 1080/29.97p, 1080/25p, 1080/24p, 1080/23.98p, 720/60p, 720/59.94p, and 720/50p. In addition, there are several 1035i formats (an obsolete Japanese television standard), half-bandwidth 720p standards such as 720/24p (used in some film conversion applications, and unusual because it has an odd number of samples per line[citation needed]), and various 1080psf (progressive, segmented frame) formats. Progressive Segmented frames formats appear as interlace video but contain video which is progressively scanned. This is done to support analog monitors and televisions, many of which are incapable of locking to low field rates such as 30 Hz and 24 Hz.

  • The dual link HD interface supports 1080/60p, 1080/59.94p, and 1080/50p, as well as 4:4:4 encoding, greater color depth, RGB encoding, alpha channels, and nonstandard resolutions (often encountered in computer graphics or digital cinema).
Anycase. The only way you get 1080 59.94p out of the camera is through the Dual Link HD-SDI port, and when enabled, this port will send a 1920x1080 59.94p signal, that has never been compressed by the XDCAM-EX codec. Refer to page 124 and 125 of the manual to see the camera output limitations.

Furthermore, read the supplement - http://ws.sel.sony.com/PIPWebServic...-asset-250125/original/PMW-F3 Supp Manual.pdf

Page 10 will show you output limits for the SDI port, and page 20 has the limits for the Dual Link port. Page 21 has a summation of output limitations by the (internal) recording mode selected.
 
Thanks James,

Wow. That was quite a post. However, I did not miss your point. I fully understand the difference between recording in camera with compression versus the output (via SDI) of an uncompressed signal. The supplement you provided did answer my question though and now I may rest assured. Much appreciated.
 
Back
Top