kampfpudel
Active member
"Sorry to travle offtopic but:
After making the last 2 Starwars (children) flicks - how can anyone say that George Lucas is about image quality?
Good enough for George Lucas doesn't mean anything after what he did to the original flicks.."
I do not think it is offtopic when we talking about picture quality. As for Mr Lucas qualities as a director...well that is a diffrent story. And offtopic.
I was thinking more of FX when I mentioned George Lucas. He could easily have shoot in 35mm (or 65mm for that matter), money is no objective in his case. But he chose to make the films digitally. A brave choise in my point of view. 99.99% seems to been have shoot against green screen...a LOT of keying that is. The first two (of the new ones) were shoot with the F900 in HDCAM, i.e 3:1:1, the last one (ROTS), was shoot with the F950 HDCAM SR, i.e 4:4:4. The first two looks like crap but the FX in ROTS looks MUCH better. At least imho.
So yes, I also wants the 4:4:4 option before only available to Hollywood and Lucas Films LTD.
BTW the only SW film that I like is "The Empire Strikes Back" because Irwin Kershner has directed it. Also beautiful lit and shoot.
And for what George Lucas did to the original movies...(*insert foul languages here*)!
Regards
Hans
After making the last 2 Starwars (children) flicks - how can anyone say that George Lucas is about image quality?
Good enough for George Lucas doesn't mean anything after what he did to the original flicks.."
I do not think it is offtopic when we talking about picture quality. As for Mr Lucas qualities as a director...well that is a diffrent story. And offtopic.
I was thinking more of FX when I mentioned George Lucas. He could easily have shoot in 35mm (or 65mm for that matter), money is no objective in his case. But he chose to make the films digitally. A brave choise in my point of view. 99.99% seems to been have shoot against green screen...a LOT of keying that is. The first two (of the new ones) were shoot with the F900 in HDCAM, i.e 3:1:1, the last one (ROTS), was shoot with the F950 HDCAM SR, i.e 4:4:4. The first two looks like crap but the FX in ROTS looks MUCH better. At least imho.
So yes, I also wants the 4:4:4 option before only available to Hollywood and Lucas Films LTD.
BTW the only SW film that I like is "The Empire Strikes Back" because Irwin Kershner has directed it. Also beautiful lit and shoot.
And for what George Lucas did to the original movies...(*insert foul languages here*)!
Regards
Hans