Would like your opinions for short film idea please

mikcheck

Active member
Hello guys.

I was thinking about this and i'd like to know your opinions please, if it's worth writing/directing or simply it just doesnt work, i'm in the wrong way.
I dont have the whole story, so i'll tell what i have.

It's a guy that buys an handheld cam online. When the product arrives by mail, he does a quick test to see if everything is ok and sees that there's a video already recorded in the camera. He then connects the cam (or just an SD card) to the computer and starts to see the video. It is a video of a girl (and i dont know yet the reasons) telling that she'll kill herself, unless the man to whom she sold the cam convince her that live worth living.

Don't know where it goes from here, that's what i have for now.

The other version would be that the video in that camera is himself being murdered and he have very short time to prevent that from happen.

Your opinions and help are more than welcome.
Thanks.
 
Well since you asked - I would say - don't ask anyone's opinion as far as a story goes. I would think it has to be something you really want to tell. What two people think alike? Everyone has an opinion.
I would say write it. Direct it. Then move onto the next one. Anyway....
 
Expanding on your idea, the angle I'd take is:

he buys a second-hand cam (or smart phone?) via some Ebay-style web site. It's suspiciously cheap, but the seller is in the same city and insists on selling it in person (instead of mailing it), therefore he thinks he can check it and hopefully avoid being scammed. He meets the female buyer in public, she seems gloomy but legit, he briefly tests the cam and it works fine, he pays for it and says goodbye, never expecting to see her again (she won't exchange full names or contact details).

He's playing with the cam on the way home and sees there's already a recorded video on it: her talking to the unknown buyer (whom she hadn't met at the time she recorded it) and asking for a reason not to kill herself, and giving him some anonymous way to get that reason to her by a deadline (e.g. he must record his answer on the cam and upload his footage to the internet with a hashtag she'll monitor, perhaps?). It seems a genuine cry for help, and he's the sort of guy who cares about people (and just maybe he's a bit smitten by her too).

as a set up, I like it, but:
- why doesn't he do the sensible thing and contact the police or suicide counselling services etc, who'd surely do a far better job of finding and helping her?
- or try to identify her via Facebook etc (without giving away why he needs to identify her)
of course, maybe she's thought of that, and so claims she'll definitely kill herself if there's any publicity or anyone comes looking for her. A close deadline would also help, e.g. "Give me a reason, by noon" and it's already 10 am.
You need to make it believable that this particular guy would spend the next couple of hours desperately making a video of 'reasons not to kill yourself' - not only plot-wise but character-wise (he's the only character we'll really get to know).

I'd now switch to the cam's POV, showing his funny/sad/pathetic/inept/terrible/moving attempts to record something inspiring, possibly involving his friends, relations, pets, babies, complete strangers, some of them trying to help, some not. (He won't tell anyone what he's really doing, beyond some vague "what's the best thing about your life?" question.) And make things unpredictably difficult for him by e.g. having editing/uploading/battery problems too. Or really hard - just as he thinks he's getting somewhere, a stranger steals the phone.

Your biggest problem is the ending. Unless you want a total downer ending, he needs to succeed, preferably not in a way the audience would have predicted. I don't think a trick ending (e.g. she was lying, and this is all some psychology experiment or she's his crazy ex-ex-ex-girlfriend in disguise) would work. An open/ambiguous ending (e.g. he apparently successfully uploads his footage at a minute before the deadline) then you cut to credits, might work. Just possibly she follows him around to see his life and is inspired by that? - but that could be difficult to make believable, e.g. is he really that easy to follow around?

But if you can think up an emotionally satisfying ending, then work backwards to join it to your set up, I think this would be an interesting film.
 
Well since you asked - I would say - don't ask anyone's opinion as far as a story goes. I would think it has to be something you really want to tell. What two people think alike? Everyone has an opinion.
I would say write it. Direct it. Then move onto the next one. Anyway....

Thanks for your reply!
I understand what you're saying.
Yes, i'll write it and direct it! :smile:
Appreciate your input.

Expanding on your idea, the angle I'd take is:

he buys a second-hand cam (or smart phone?) via some Ebay-style web site. It's suspiciously cheap, but the seller is in the same city and insists on selling it in person (instead of mailing it), therefore he thinks he can check it and hopefully avoid being scammed. He meets the female buyer in public, she seems gloomy but legit, he briefly tests the cam and it works fine, he pays for it and says goodbye, never expecting to see her again (she won't exchange full names or contact details).

He's playing with the cam on the way home and sees there's already a recorded video on it: her talking to the unknown buyer (whom she hadn't met at the time she recorded it) and asking for a reason not to kill herself, and giving him some anonymous way to get that reason to her by a deadline (e.g. he must record his answer on the cam and upload his footage to the internet with a hashtag she'll monitor, perhaps?). It seems a genuine cry for help, and he's the sort of guy who cares about people (and just maybe he's a bit smitten by her too).

as a set up, I like it, but:
- why doesn't he do the sensible thing and contact the police or suicide counselling services etc, who'd surely do a far better job of finding and helping her?
- or try to identify her via Facebook etc (without giving away why he needs to identify her)
of course, maybe she's thought of that, and so claims she'll definitely kill herself if there's any publicity or anyone comes looking for her. A close deadline would also help, e.g. "Give me a reason, by noon" and it's already 10 am.
You need to make it believable that this particular guy would spend the next couple of hours desperately making a video of 'reasons not to kill yourself' - not only plot-wise but character-wise (he's the only character we'll really get to know).

I'd now switch to the cam's POV, showing his funny/sad/pathetic/inept/terrible/moving attempts to record something inspiring, possibly involving his friends, relations, pets, babies, complete strangers, some of them trying to help, some not. (He won't tell anyone what he's really doing, beyond some vague "what's the best thing about your life?" question.) And make things unpredictably difficult for him by e.g. having editing/uploading/battery problems too. Or really hard - just as he thinks he's getting somewhere, a stranger steals the phone.

Your biggest problem is the ending. Unless you want a total downer ending, he needs to succeed, preferably not in a way the audience would have predicted. I don't think a trick ending (e.g. she was lying, and this is all some psychology experiment or she's his crazy ex-ex-ex-girlfriend in disguise) would work. An open/ambiguous ending (e.g. he apparently successfully uploads his footage at a minute before the deadline) then you cut to credits, might work. Just possibly she follows him around to see his life and is inspired by that? - but that could be difficult to make believable, e.g. is he really that easy to follow around?

But if you can think up an emotionally satisfying ending, then work backwards to join it to your set up, I think this would be an interesting film.

Thanks for your reply!
Do you came up with all that just by reading my post?
I like that story direction, i really do. Some things had already occurred to me: the fact that they'd met in person for the delivery and the deadline to "save" her. I really like the fact that he tries to solve it by trying to film something meaningful with that camera, while at the same time he's having a bad time.

To make it believable the fact that the guy is willing to spend the time and effort to do it, maybe he finds the girl's cute and "funny". Dont know if that's enough, but could be a way.

I also agree about the ending. The "i'm your crazy ex girlfriend" or "surprise! this is a joke/lie!" stuff may be wouldn't work. But i don't dislike the idea of her to be following him around. It needs to be something well thought.

I really appreciate your help here, you gave me more inspiration to do it, i admit i was a little blocked.
 
Read some beat sheets. Your story needs structure whether it's a full length movie or a short film.
https://timstout.wordpress.com/story-structure/blake-snyders-beat-sheet/

Good structure takes your short film from a cute idea that never quite connects with the audience, to a tightly told story that holds your audiences attention and delivers the right pay off in the end.

To break it down very simply you need:
1. A protagonist (the guy that finds the camera).
2. A goal for your protagonist that he or she CANNOT walk away from. If they can walk away from some tough problem, but they don't, the audience will wonder why. Why doesn't he just erase the video, and move on with his life? Your audience will ask that question and you need a good answer.
3. Conflict, conflict, conflict! There are forces in the way of your protagonist completing their goal. These forces are not there just to create conflict, or just to give the protagonist something to do, they have their own goal or reason for existing, and it is the opposite of the protagonist, so it naturally leads to a conflict. Remember the conflict can be internal, but it has to be there for the audience to root for your protagonist to succeed (or fail). If there is no conflict, you have no story. You are just retelling events that happened.
4. If it is a comedy, your protagonist succeeds. If it is a drama, your protagonist fails. The reason your protogonist succeeds or fails, either way, is that they either changed something about themselves during the story, OR, they refused to change something about themselves during the story.

If you leave out any of these elements you'll leave your audience going, kinda cool idea, but meh.
 
Hello guys.

I was thinking about this and i'd like to know your opinions please, if it's worth writing/directing or simply it just doesnt work, i'm in the wrong way.
I dont have the whole story, so i'll tell what i have.

It's a guy that buys an handheld cam online. When the product arrives by mail, he does a quick test to see if everything is ok and sees that there's a video already recorded in the camera. He then connects the cam (or just an SD card) to the computer and starts to see the video. It is a video of a girl (and i dont know yet the reasons) telling that she'll kill herself, unless the man to whom she sold the cam convince her that live worth living.

Don't know where it goes from here, that's what i have for now.

The other version would be that the video in that camera is himself being murdered and he have very short time to prevent that from happen.

Your opinions and help are more than welcome.
Thanks.

This 'sounds' like an idea for Radio. Film is a visual medium, and as such, talkytalk, especially for 'short films', is its death.

Sure TV shows have a lot of dialog... my personal theory, beyond the fact that dialog is cheaper than action, and allows for the easy insertion of 'filler', is that many TV writers at the birth of TV were in fact Radio writers, and so, that legacy continued.

The 'genre' that you are using has been called 'found footage', and as such, I think you could do more visuals with the 'found footage'. Take a plain girl, or even an ugly girl, because having a 'beautiful' girl contemplate suicide is 1) a so frequently used trope, and 2) what red blooded heterosexual guy wouldn't like to 'save' some attractive babe...

You could also have the person contemplating suicide a homosexual 'pretty boy'... with visuals showing a number of events which show him that death is better than life, and further, show the guy who found the footage, take on the ethical question of 'saving' the pretty boy, for the sake of saving human life rather than 'rescuing a hot babe'.
 
Read some beat sheets. Your story needs structure whether it's a full length movie or a short film.
https://timstout.wordpress.com/story-structure/blake-snyders-beat-sheet/

Good structure takes your short film from a cute idea that never quite connects with the audience, to a tightly told story that holds your audiences attention and delivers the right pay off in the end.

To break it down very simply you need:
1. A protagonist (the guy that finds the camera).
2. A goal for your protagonist that he or she CANNOT walk away from. If they can walk away from some tough problem, but they don't, the audience will wonder why. Why doesn't he just erase the video, and move on with his life? Your audience will ask that question and you need a good answer.
3. Conflict, conflict, conflict! There are forces in the way of your protagonist completing their goal. These forces are not there just to create conflict, or just to give the protagonist something to do, they have their own goal or reason for existing, and it is the opposite of the protagonist, so it naturally leads to a conflict. Remember the conflict can be internal, but it has to be there for the audience to root for your protagonist to succeed (or fail). If there is no conflict, you have no story. You are just retelling events that happened.
4. If it is a comedy, your protagonist succeeds. If it is a drama, your protagonist fails. The reason your protogonist succeeds or fails, either way, is that they either changed something about themselves during the story, OR, they refused to change something about themselves during the story.

If you leave out any of these elements you'll leave your audience going, kinda cool idea, but meh.

Thank you for your input. Appreciate that!

This 'sounds' like an idea for Radio. Film is a visual medium, and as such, talkytalk, especially for 'short films', is its death.

Sure TV shows have a lot of dialog... my personal theory, beyond the fact that dialog is cheaper than action, and allows for the easy insertion of 'filler', is that many TV writers at the birth of TV were in fact Radio writers, and so, that legacy continued.

The 'genre' that you are using has been called 'found footage', and as such, I think you could do more visuals with the 'found footage'. Take a plain girl, or even an ugly girl, because having a 'beautiful' girl contemplate suicide is 1) a so frequently used trope, and 2) what red blooded heterosexual guy wouldn't like to 'save' some attractive babe...

You could also have the person contemplating suicide a homosexual 'pretty boy'... with visuals showing a number of events which show him that death is better than life, and further, show the guy who found the footage, take on the ethical question of 'saving' the pretty boy, for the sake of saving human life rather than 'rescuing a hot babe'.

Thank you for your reply!

"This 'sounds' like an idea for Radio. Film is a visual medium, and as such, talkytalk, especially for 'short films', is its death." - You mean specifically the part where the boy/girl contemplating suicide is talking in the found footage? I agree with that, that's too much talking for something as a short film. Show, dont tell. But somehow, that part would have to be done with a little talking.

The idea of him being a homesexual pretty boy and showing those events is interesting. The thing i'm having a little difficulty is to find a believeble reason for the character to connect with it and embrace that "challenge". For example, if that happened to me, maybe i wouldn't do it just for the sake of it, i'd need to have a strong reason to do it.

Thanks a lot for your input.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure it works the way you're headed.

How can she set a deadline for him to respond? She has no way of knowing when, or if, he will discover her recording on the camera. It just doesn't seem logical.

To me, a deadline would actually make the story LESS tense, because the guy -- and the audience -- know that, at least for the moment, the girl is alive, and will stay that way until the deadline. I would think it would be far more tense if all he knows is she's going to kill herself after she delivers the camcorder to the buyer. The message she leaves on the cam isn't a challenge -- it's simply a suicide note. Now the pressure is on the guy to figure out where she is and, hopefully, get to her in time to stop her from dying. He doesn't know how she means to do it, or exactly when, so there's not a single second to waste. The conflict (which Gillvane mentioned) -- or rather, the roadblock -- stems from him having no idea what her name is, where she lives, or how to reach her.

But then you're going to have to figure out how he overcomes that rather huge obstacle. How DOES he find her in time? That's going to be the trick.

I think it's simple enough to establish that he's a lonely guy, she's a reasonably appealing girl (although she has very low self-esteem), and that he has a compassionate nature. Those factors are enough to motivate him to try and save her life if he can.

Maybe he does call the police. Maybe they're going to be too slow, too inept, or his will just be one of many, many calls they have to deal with. In which case he quickly realizes that he is the girl's only real hope.

It would do no good to call a suicide prevention hotline. They would have no more idea how to find her than he would, although the hotline counselor could team up with him to find the girl -- making it more than just a 2-person story.

The guy definitely needs to meet the girl in person to buy the cam, so he can establish some sort of connection and empathy for her. She insists on cash -- no checks. So it would have to be a local Craigslist kind of a site. He would probably contact her by email, and they would arrange a time and place to meet. So he literally knows nothing about her. The website where she posted her ad would be no help -- not even a contact phone number for them, just an email address, and a promise to respond to inquiries within 2 business days. That's not going to help him at all! The email address she used would be a freebie account, like a Yahoo or Gmail account. Good luck finding her that way.

Now I'm thinking about it, it seems like the only way to make it possible for him to find her is if her contact info isn't an email address -- it's her cell phone number. Or else he initially contacts her via email and then she gives him her cell number to setup the meeting. That cell number is his only hope of finding her. But again, trying to get the cops or anyone else involved is going to take too long. So he keeps calling her until she finally answers -- already sounding groggy from the overdose of sleeping pills (or whatever) she has taken.

Maybe she has an iPhone and they communicate using FaceTime. He can't get her to tell him where she is. He can't convince her that life is worth living. At some point she goes unconscious, and all he has is what he sees via the webcam on her phone. But something he sees enables him to find her.

Just spitballing ideas here. The story has potential, and could be very tense. Give it a shot!
 
Just had another thought...

He finally finds the girl, only to discover that she's perfectly fine -- it wasn't so much a 'joke' as some kind of sick social experiment. He's been put through an emotional wringer, and feels violated. And she's standing there all but LAUGHING at him.

Cut to a bit later. Still at the girl's apartment. Cops and paramedics are there. And the girl is dead, hanging from a noose. Poor thing! The guy shows them her 'suicide note'. How sad that he wasn't able to find her in time...........!

:-)
 
I like David's idea that she has another smartphone (e.g. she's just upgraded from the old phone she's selling to him, which he and the audience would find believable), as it gives them some way (and no other way) to communicate - but you need to put some huge limit on it, e.g. she refuses to answer voice calls but will reluctantly text, to respond when he claims (rightly or wrongly) that he's found some life reasons to 'show' her.

Yes, she needs to have thought of some guaranteed way for him to see her intended suicide note video. Given there's an app for everything else in the universe :), it doesn't seem unreasonable for her to have found some way to autoplay the video at a prearranged time, much to his surprise.

Interesting the idea of removing the deadline - I agree that could add more tension if handled right. Nevertheless saving her still needs to seem urgent to him.

Subverting the audience's expectations re an apparent romance could be interesting too.
 
I'm not sure it works the way you're headed.

How can she set a deadline for him to respond? She has no way of knowing when, or if, he will discover her recording on the camera. It just doesn't seem logical.

To me, a deadline would actually make the story LESS tense, because the guy -- and the audience -- know that, at least for the moment, the girl is alive, and will stay that way until the deadline. I would think it would be far more tense if all he knows is she's going to kill herself after she delivers the camcorder to the buyer. The message she leaves on the cam isn't a challenge -- it's simply a suicide note. Now the pressure is on the guy to figure out where she is and, hopefully, get to her in time to stop her from dying. He doesn't know how she means to do it, or exactly when, so there's not a single second to waste. The conflict (which Gillvane mentioned) -- or rather, the roadblock -- stems from him having no idea what her name is, where she lives, or how to reach her.

But then you're going to have to figure out how he overcomes that rather huge obstacle. How DOES he find her in time? That's going to be the trick.

I think it's simple enough to establish that he's a lonely guy, she's a reasonably appealing girl (although she has very low self-esteem), and that he has a compassionate nature. Those factors are enough to motivate him to try and save her life if he can.

Maybe he does call the police. Maybe they're going to be too slow, too inept, or his will just be one of many, many calls they have to deal with. In which case he quickly realizes that he is the girl's only real hope.

It would do no good to call a suicide prevention hotline. They would have no more idea how to find her than he would, although the hotline counselor could team up with him to find the girl -- making it more than just a 2-person story.

The guy definitely needs to meet the girl in person to buy the cam, so he can establish some sort of connection and empathy for her. She insists on cash -- no checks. So it would have to be a local Craigslist kind of a site. He would probably contact her by email, and they would arrange a time and place to meet. So he literally knows nothing about her. The website where she posted her ad would be no help -- not even a contact phone number for them, just an email address, and a promise to respond to inquiries within 2 business days. That's not going to help him at all! The email address she used would be a freebie account, like a Yahoo or Gmail account. Good luck finding her that way.

Now I'm thinking about it, it seems like the only way to make it possible for him to find her is if her contact info isn't an email address -- it's her cell phone number. Or else he initially contacts her via email and then she gives him her cell number to setup the meeting. That cell number is his only hope of finding her. But again, trying to get the cops or anyone else involved is going to take too long. So he keeps calling her until she finally answers -- already sounding groggy from the overdose of sleeping pills (or whatever) she has taken.

Maybe she has an iPhone and they communicate using FaceTime. He can't get her to tell him where she is. He can't convince her that life is worth living. At some point she goes unconscious, and all he has is what he sees via the webcam on her phone. But something he sees enables him to find her.

Just spitballing ideas here. The story has potential, and could be very tense. Give it a shot!

Hello David, thanks a lot for your reply!
Some really great ideas you've got there, appreciate that. You opinion about the deadline makes total sense and adds much more tension. Still need to think alot about it but with the help i've been receiving from you guys, others doors open and the possibility to make this better.
Since i plan to shoot it with no or very low budget, i'll try to write it with minimal cast. If could be better to have the police in, my brother in law is police, so maybe he could help me with that. I'll also try to write this as short as possible.
Thank you David.
 
I like David's idea that she has another smartphone (e.g. she's just upgraded from the old phone she's selling to him, which he and the audience would find believable), as it gives them some way (and no other way) to communicate - but you need to put some huge limit on it, e.g. she refuses to answer voice calls but will reluctantly text, to respond when he claims (rightly or wrongly) that he's found some life reasons to 'show' her.

Yes, she needs to have thought of some guaranteed way for him to see her intended suicide note video. Given there's an app for everything else in the universe :), it doesn't seem unreasonable for her to have found some way to autoplay the video at a prearranged time, much to his surprise.

Interesting the idea of removing the deadline - I agree that could add more tension if handled right. Nevertheless saving her still needs to seem urgent to him.

Subverting the audience's expectations re an apparent romance could be interesting too.

Once again, thanks a lot clang.
 
Yes, she needs to have thought of some guaranteed way for him to see her intended suicide note video. Given there's an app for everything else in the universe :), it doesn't seem unreasonable for her to have found some way to autoplay the video at a prearranged time, much to his surprise.

That's a thought, although just because the video runs, that's no guarantee that he saw it. But I suppose there is no guarantee of that anyway.

Maybe she has an app that sends her a message when the video is played? Then she can say in the video that as soon as she receives that message, she will take a poison to end her life. She just wants to know that her 'suicide note' was seen by someone before she kills herself. That way not only does he know the time she took the poison, he also may have some sense of guilt -- "If I hadn't watched that video..." It's a misguided sense, of course, but still something plausible.
 
Hello David, thanks a lot for your reply!
Some really great ideas you've got there, appreciate that. You opinion about the deadline makes total sense and adds much more tension. Still need to think alot about it but with the help i've been receiving from you guys, others doors open and the possibility to make this better.
Since i plan to shoot it with no or very low budget, i'll try to write it with minimal cast. If could be better to have the police in, my brother in law is police, so maybe he could help me with that. I'll also try to write this as short as possible.
Thank you David.

First off, is your brother-in-law an actor? If not, don't just include him to have a cop in your story. Besides, if he's a uniformed cop then the department he works for likely wouldn't allow their badge, patch, or other insignia to be used in your film. And if he's not a uniformed cop, then there's no point in using him over using a real actor.

As has been mentioned, there can be plausible reasons why the cops are not involved. Personally, I would find it much more interesting if a suicide prevention counselor was helping the guy -- especially if that counselor was a woman. But if you want to try the twist ending I described before, or something similar, then this guy needs to be going it alone.

Back to clang's idea -- it could be that the video autoplays. As clang suggested, it would need to be set to play at a specific time. I had thought it might play when the phone was turned on, but surely this guy would turn the phone on and make sure it works before he hands the girl his money. So it would have to be set to play at a specific time.

Another possibility -- it plays only minutes after the girl has left the guy. Maybe he was a little bit late for their meeting, so she'd intended to be long gone when the video played. But now his urgent search begins in the immediate area, as he's frantically looking around for the girl. Just a thought.
 
You're right. He's not an actor, so not much of a help. Even if he was, i agree that would be difficult to get a permition to film with uniform.

I dont dislike the fact that it is a handycam. But i guess either ways could work. When i buy a new cam, i always test it right away and see the footage.

Thank you!
 
Or consider hiring someone else to write it, if you're not a skilled screenwriter. What is your experience and skill, mikcheck?

Well my skill and experience as a writer is close to zero, for my misfortune.
I took a directing course for 2 years between 2008 and 2010 and the only short film i ever wrote and direct was the final project of that same course in 2010. Even though the final result was nothing special, i've managed to have the best grade in the course with that final project.
Since that time i've never wrote or even direct anything more, that's why it's always difficult to me to develop an idea that sometimes i have.
 
Last edited:
Well my skill and experience as a writer is close to zero, for my misfortune.
I took a directing course for 2 years between 2008 and 2010 and the only short film i ever wrote and direct was the final project of that same course in 2010. Even though the final result was nothing special, i've managed to have the best grade in the course with that final project.
Since that time i've never wrote or even direct anything more, that's why it's always difficult to me to develop an idea that sometimes i have.

Then best advice is get a writer and a director, and learn from them as you make this film. The idea is a good one -- it needs to be executed well.

Good luck!
 
Back
Top