What Software Should I learn?

egproductions

egproductions

Veteran
I want to start learning 3d animation but am having a little trouble deciding between maya or 3d studio max. which one is better to learn and whihc one is more widley used for video animation. In specific I want to create an intro for my company that looks much like this still image below (really bad scan sorry)

EG%20Logo.jpg
 
You can use any Package really, this is something I did in Max, needs some tweaking but you get the Idea:

Egg Logo:

Egg_preview.jpg


And In Case you wondering what the wireframe looks like:

WireFrame:

Egg_preview_w.jpg



Anhar
 
thats very sexy. I would normally ask someone to do this for me but I think its time i learn to do it for myslef. What is more commonly used in the industry. What is max better at doing than maya lets say.
 
Either app can do the job you want.
Try the demos out. Which ever one "feels" better/easier/more comfortable to you is probably the best place to start.
 
I have heard the Maya is more film industry related while 3ds Max is more video game related. I am planning on playing around with Maya at some point, but another alternative is Cinema 4d. I've heard lots of good stuff about it.
 
Man, they are just tools, it does'nt matter thats the truth really, whatever your comfortable with, and the film industry does not use any one app exlusively, what happens is that they use a bit of this a bit of that and some in house stuff as well.

Anyway come join the fun/madness welcome to a world of 3 dimensional pain :)

Anhar
 
Cryogenic Filmworks said:
I have heard the Maya is more film industry related while 3ds Max is more video game related. I am planning on playing around with Maya at some point, but another alternative is Cinema 4d. I've heard lots of good stuff about it.
Click to expand...


Cinema 4d is great, as is Lightwave. I would say both are some of the easier 3d apps to learn on.
 
I think I am going to choose maya from what I have seen from tuturiol results is that maya has some of the more realistic renderings whihc is what I am more interested in generally. Thanks for al your help.
 
Neither, Maya is great but useless if you don't have a gigantic render farm, and as far as I am concerned 3ds max is crap, which is probably why autodesk felt they had to buy Maya. Go cinema 4d, best 3d pkg for the money, great modeler and very photorealistic.
 
Oh dear this is going to turn into another, my X is better than your X, its not the case as I've already said almost all modern 3d apps are just as capable as each other, how good each one is depends on the user now in terms of features, I think Maya is tops with Max a close behind (infact they say Maya is just Max with all the plugins)

C4D from what I hear has a simple learning curve (i.e. its a simple app to pick up) where as some dislike Max due to the harder learning curve (and would probably hate Maya which is even harder).

Anyway pick your tools and get good at it, then when you feel you have "outgrown" you tool move on to another..

Anhar
 
I use Maya. I haven't used any other 3D apps, so it isn't really fair to compare, I guess. I do know that Maya has a strong standing in the 3D community, which is a really nice benefit. Also, Maya has some great learning resources like The Gnomon Workshop and Digital Tutor DVD sets. I've been using Maya since version 4.0, and I've never felt compelled to look for another 3D alternative.
 
I'm new to 3d and have been using max 8 for 3 months. My impression was Maya was more animation based and more user-friendly while max is tech-based and while harder has more tech-ability if user inputs it. Another analogy is Visual Basic->C++? If I'm wrong, I'll be glad to look at maya.??? -thanks.
 
Maya is much more tech based....not to say max isn't

I've used lightwave professionally for years, and have gotten into maya the past 3 years....and also have dabbled with max and houdini.

If I were in the market I would probably go with cinema4d or XSI foundation.
XSI probably being a little harder to learn but more powerful.

As far as renderers XSI MAYA and MAX all use mental ray, as there built in quality renderer...(before Maya got mental ray...it's default renderer was the worst.) C4D and lightwave each have there own renderer's which are very good quality.Any one of these apps can do photo realistic rendering,though I belive C4d is the fastest (it does matter...I've had to wait over a week for 60 seconds of animation...all depends on the size/quality)

Maya is esteemed in 3d because of it's customisable....everything, most production houses write there own tools and shaders and maya is very friendly in that environment. It's character animation is also some of the best...but to be realistic...developing and rigging a production quality character...just to make it animation ready could take a pro months. So you have to look at what you want to do with it and how deep you want to go.

I own Maya and lightwave....I love maya because I like to dig deep into the program....(and trust me 3d programs are 10 times deeper than any video editing app)....but when I need something quick...I go to Lightwave.

So for basic 3d capabilities go for XSI foundation ($499) C4d (dependes on the modules ($700-$2500) or Lightwave($800)
If you see yourself spending months on end perfecting a 3d project the jump to Maya($2000-$7000) XSI Advanced($2000-$7000) or Houdini($17,500)

Just my opinions of course
 
3d

3d

I use 3DS Max for non-organics and Maya for organic objects. Depending on the project I decide which dynamics and or particle effects system I will use. A great place for learning material is:

http://www.3DBuzz.com

They fundamental DVD courses for Max and Maya and they are TRUELY AWSOME. The best instructional content I have ever seen.

Good luck
 
Here is my take on it...

I think there are a few thing to consider when buying a 3d software. At work, we use Maya, and I think it's the best software out there, however all the hi-end features and the cool rendering engines need a rendering farm. You won't be able to use it at home unless you are willing to wait 6 month for a 1 sec. ani. There are, of course a lot of thing you will be able to do with it without a rendering farm, but you won't be able to use many of the very cool shaders and plug-ins.

Lightwave is very good as well, but I have never liked the fact that the Modeler isn't integrated with the animation part.

Softimage XSI is great, but not as popular as it was once...

3D StudioMax: I never understood why this software is popular... It is easy to learn I guess but I think it's crap, in my opinion the worst 3d software outhere... Just to be more specific, I don't like the animation features, I think they are weak, also I don't like the rendering engine that comes with it. Also I don't find it very flexibe.

Cinema 4D is sort of the new kid on the block, the basics are very easy to learn so you can start doing cool stuff fairly quickly. Also the modeler is non destructive which I think is very cool. The rendering engines are very impressive. I think the best for the money.


PS: The following comments are based on over 15 years experience working in Post Production houses and VFX companies producing mainly hi-end commercials, feature films and music videos.
 
modo is good to learn on... maya is real good once you learn it. But once you learn one program, you should be able to pick up the rest pretty fast
 
Who makes the best ground up training for Cinema 4d? Something multi DVD, starting with basics and working up to the more intricate stuff. I've downloaded some of the demos off Lynda.com (?) but would like to know what everyone else likes. My 3d experience... Poser, Daz|Studio, Bryce. Nothing much.
 
Cryogenic Filmworks said:
Who makes the best ground up training for Cinema 4d? Something multi DVD, starting with basics and working up to the more intricate stuff.
Click to expand...

I'm interested in this, also... SOOO... BUMP!
 
I have access to the Lynda.com Cinema 4d Tutorials and I plan on watching them. I will report back if they are good or not.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top