Was it me or the sound guy? - Distorted audio

iggy097

Well-known member
Hey all, just looking at some footage I wrapped up at a local event, I had the sound guy run me a line into my C100 from the board, and everything seemed good during testing, but now listening to it, it seems a bit distorted at the max volume.
My levels on the camera were never at 0 - mostly around -12 and on my NLE it shows as well.
Did he have my input too high and I just couldn't tell because the music was so loud in the venue?
They were pretty experienced sound guys , and it was the first time I've run a line to my C100.
I'm pretty sure I had it set to line as well.
I'm new to patching into their board, I thought that if the levels on my camera were good that the audio would be good? What would cause the distortion? I've attached a clip

 
I thought that if the levels on my camera were good that the audio would be good?

Headphones, headphones, headphones. The meters don't tell you much of anything except where the nominal recorded level is. If the feed from the house sound board was too hot, it could have clipped in the camera's inputs. You'll never see that reflected in the meters; the only way to detect that kind of problem is to monitor with headphones while you record. And without listening, you have no idea where the distortion occurred, and never had a chance to address it (i.e. fix it) before you recorded the show.

If you are working alone and relying on the house sound crew of a live venue to give you a feed, it becomes your responsibility to monitor and maintain all things audio inside the camera. Never leave it just to an eye on the meters.
 
Last edited:
You need to monitor your audio (if you weren't). That being said...
-The signal coming out of the board could have been distorting the outputs if it was too hot
-The signal coming into your camera could have distorted your inputs

Those are the only two things I can think of.

That being said...it isn't absolutely terrible. I've heard LOTS worse.
 
In Iggy's defense and having shot in those environments, you can't always hear the distortion over the house sound even with decent isolating headphones. You check that you're getting the audio you want and check the levels, but it can be hard to hear that kind of distortion. It sounds like the distortion was somewhere in the sound guy's domain as the announcer is still coming in clean over the clipped music track.
 
I agree with Mr. Simutis that the problem sounds like it was happening before the audio got to you. The announcer did not sound distorted to me.
However I disagree that one can simply dismiss responsibility because it is difficult to hear. Especially in a new situation, one must be hyper-vigilant.
My philosophy is summarized in my signature line below....
 
I believe a DP I was working with was telling me the headphone levels on the C100 are exceptionally low, even when maxed. So that's an issue too. . .probably okay for a talking head interview in a quiet office, not so much for monitoring loud environment. What could you do to amplify headphone levels outside of using a mixer?
 
In my experience often when you sound check the level is a lot lower than when the event starts. Always check so any stage isn't over loaded. Bad video is bad but bad audio is a disaster.
 
I do have decent headphones and it still didn't sound clipped like that, but it was hard to tell. Thanks all for the feedback, I was trying to isolate the problem so it didn't happen next time. Hard thing solo like that is even if I had noticed an issue mid way it would have been very hard to let the sound guy know at the time.
 
Next question:

What are you going to do about the flicker?

Nothing. The people that put on the event told me that previous videographers always complain about their light setup. I doubt they will notice any flicker at all ( it's going to parents of the kids on DVD ).
I'm not even sure what I would do if I wanted to honestly.
 
"What could you do to amplify headphone levels outside of using a mixer?"
> A headphone amp. That will only let one hear more clearly there is, or is not a problem..
Most house mixer-to-camera audio problems discussed here are level mismatches.. most commonly, feeding line level (+4dB or -10dB) into a mic level camera input. (-50dB)
 
It is probably in the signal you got. In these kinds of events there is always a ton of other noise going on and the speakers themselves may be masking the distortion. It is also very hard to really hear your signal. About the only way to really monitor would be with those super isolating headphones built in to ear protectors. All the bleed will tend to mask the distortion. And if it's coming from the board that way then the room is also getting distortion so there is not a lot you can do.

As to cranking up the headphone level. There are a couple of issues. First a lot of the built in headphone amps distort easily so you really have to know your gear. They also do not monitor the recorded signal but the incoming signal so you could still possibly get some distortion that you don't hear till later. Not super likely with the way digital recorders work now but...

Your options are to pull off the headphone, or line out of the camera ad feed a headphone amp, or put a headphone amp on the incoming signal before it gets to the camera. The former is generally the better choice since it will let you hear if the input stage of the camera is craping out on you. The plus for the later is you can adjust the level of the signal coming into the camera and "fix" a too hot signal.

I suspect that in this case both would have told you the same thing, the feed was distorting the music. This is a gain staging issue with the house mixer. He/she was pumping up the music at the channel trim instead of later and the channel was distorting.

From your perspective I would have recorded a "room" version also because if it's for the parents they would probably love to have some of the audience sound reaction also and that would help mask the music. You can probably slap the de-clipper from iZotope's Rx on this and make that top end grit go away.
 
While true only the music is distorted. The announcer is clean which leans me to distorted at the mixer not coming into the camera.
 
If this is really important to someone...dump the live audio (ex camera) and lay in the music from whatever the source was.

BTW - does the camera have variable audio level input (before the level pots).

My Pannys do. IIRC -50, -60db and soemthing else. Same with my field mixer. I never mess with them or understand them. The recordist does that.
 
There is nothing about it that suggests an "impedance mismatch". At least to my ear.
And padding and "impedance matching" are two completely different things.
A pad would NOT have helped this problem. Lets not get sloppy here.

This is clearly a mixing error as the announcer is clean.

And although not the problem here, Shooter brings up an important point.
In some cases you DO need a pad because you are going right into the first stage BEFORE any kind of record level.
So you could be clipping the input stage of the recorder/camera even with the record control nearly at zero.
But that is not the problem with the example here.
 
You need to know your equipment, what you trust is your experience, knowledge and ears.

It's a lot more likely to sound worse in the headphones than better.
But "You know, You never know, you know"

Or maybe more to your point "Life sucks and then you die,... If you're lucky."
 
Don't know if it's an option but replace the audio track. Use the same songs they used and get the original announcer or someone new to MC.
 
Back
Top