SHORT: Trying My Best to Love You (comedy/romance/psychedelic)

RyanEsta

Member
Hello everyone! I've been on this site for years now and after reading, studying, experimenting and learning as much as possible, I put out my 1st short film a few months ago called Trying My Best to Love You. Of course, it being my 1st short film, I learned A LOT of things the hard way...the extremely hard way. The hard way that makes you spend 1 1/2 years on completing a 10 minutes short.

For the tech heads, I should mention that I used a Panasonic HVX200 to film with, trying to use mostly natural available light. We had two small clamp lights that were 150 watts each I believe and that was pretty much it. I did not use any sort of 35mm adapters, it was all straight from the camera (color corrected, of course).

But I wanted to share it with you all. Here is the film and below, I will post more information on the conception of this film and the hard lessons I learned.


Here are some notes regarding the creation of this film:

“What did I do wrong?” How many times have you asked yourself that question? More importantly, how many times have you asked this question when a certain male/female went from being completely engaged with you to ice cold, unable to even speak with you? I’ve definitely experienced this several times before and it’s quite common in the dating world I imagine. The first initial thought is whether you ****ed up, whether you said something wrong and you start tracking back in your mind “was it this, was it that” until you realize that most of the time, it has nothing to do with you, it was more than likely a change on their part. The hard part is being unable to confirm this; the person won’t return your calls/messages or they keep making excuses. Or maybe they pretend that everything is fine…except for a gigantic change in their body language. They no longer go in for the kiss and instead settle for a polite hug. This initial idea is what kick started this film project for me.

Robert represents, to me, your classic lover: wanting to please the other person, wanting to know what his weaknesses may be so he can fix them. As with many people, he wants straight answers for his questions. He wants to go through a checklist on what to do right and what not to do at all. He wants a plan. Of course, the problem is, love isn’t quite so simple. Many people can’t explain why they feel attraction for another person; why they fell in and, subsequently, out of love; why the fire is no longer there. Robert may be a bit naive about this or simply doesn’t care, he just wants answers. He wants to know what works. And what better way than to ask a girl herself, right?

The next topic is of course the friend zone, which can always be a tricky thing to maneuver through. There can be a fine line between a lover and a friend, both typically encompassing some sort of intimacy in one way or another. How one side bleeds over to the other definitely interests me along with that unspoken tension. It always seems to be a guessing game with one of the persons typically having strong feelings or emotions that they cannot control. Does the other person feel the same way? And if they do, would they be brave (or some would say, stupid) enough to take a chance? Is it ever easy to go back to being friends after an attempt at love has failed?

The production of this film goes back to November of 2009 when I wrote a first draft of the script. At the time, production had already started on our web series (Random Acts of Randomness) but this series consists mostly of comedy skits; I wanted to create something that had more of a self contained story, that was a bit more serious in subject matter. Having all of those above thoughts/questions in my mind, I wrote a few drafts and after reading through them I immediately pictured Caitlin Corbitt playing the role (who had been an actress friend of mine for several years). I found the proper location and next thing I know, we were off and shooting.

And of course, there is the musical climax of the film set to a song I wrote called “Something There”. I originally wrote it as a duet with the two of them, cutting between them at various outdoor parks. It was going to be a more folky, acoustic version of the song with simply a guitar and their two voices. After shooting the narrative part of the film, however, I thought that it would work better as a full expression of his love for her, a way for him (and him only) to go out on a limb and show exactly how much he really cares about her. After brainstorming, the idea came to me of using painting as another medium of the arts to express this in a more experimental way.

I went out and gathered tons and tons of art supplies; paints, watercolors, tapes, stencils, a million different brushes, sponges, sprays, you name it. I wanted to have no limits when it came to creating these pieces, a complete stream of consciousness, flow of thought. Over the course of 3 months, myself along with Josh Beekman, Stephen Landry and Darele Ray, created roughly 700 paintings to be used for this sequence. The living room in my apartment had been converted into a mini-art studio with newspaper covering all areas of the tables and floors; every waking moment was spent creating these works until it was all finally wrapped up.

Overall, my goal was to create something unique, funny, relateable and above all, entertaining. I really hope you enjoy it and play it over and over and over again. Take lots of drugs for the music sequence, that seems to help.
 
And here are 5 lessons I learned mostly while making this short film and a few other shorts:

1.) Always white balance frequently


When you white balance, you are telling your camera what exactly "white" is in your scene so that it is able to make your colors appear more realistic. It is designed to remove color casts that our eyes may be used to and may not pick up immediately. If you do not white balance, you may shoot your film only to take it home and realize that it is too red/orange/blue/green. When that happens, you have to spend more time correcting this with color correcting software and sucks up precious hours you could be spending on something else. This is especially true when shooting outdoors or using natural light.


For example, for one of my short films, I decided to have a go at shooting it only with natural light. We were shooting the film in a living room that had a giant wall-sized window with lots of light shining through. "Perfect! I won't have to use as many lights!" was my initial thought. This would save time and allow us to do more straight shooting.


But here's the problem: when the sun is shining brightly, it gives off a color temperature of 5000-6500 degrees Kelvin, or a very blue-ish color. As the sun sets, the temperature changes and it goes towards a temperature of 3000-4000 degrees Kelvin, or a very golden/yellow-ish color. So what happened was we set up our camera rigs, did one single initial white balance and left it at that for the entire day. Granted, it was a rushed shoot but when I got all of my footage home at my editing bay, I was a little taken aback to see the first half of my shoot in full, bright, popping colors and the second half covered in a murky, golden color. It was as if I had shot two different films with a different tone to each.


So how did I remedy it? By spending hours upon hours in Apple Color (a color correcting software) that were wasted it away. I'm talking DAYS here, people! Entire days were wasted on something that would have only take a few minutes, tops, to set while shooting. And simply put, time really is money.


I would recommend getting a White Balance card. Instead of using your camera to Automatic White Balance (which is good but not great), you put this card in front of your camera, hit your White Balance button and it is corrected almost perfect. I personally recommend using the WhiBal card from Michael Tapes Design:

It's the best $30 you will spend. Get one at http://michaeltapesdesign.com/whibal.html


2.) You can never have too many lights


Now I'm not saying you have to bust out $10,000 for a deluxe professional lighting rig (although if you can afford it, it doesn't hurt!) but you will quickly find that having a plethora of lights on hand is never a bad thing. Even if you're using all natural lighting, it still doesn't hurt. If you can't afford decent lights, you can pillage Home Depot or Lowes for their work lights and lamps.


The trick is to find the biggest, brightest halogen bulbs you can that have a color temperature of around 5000 degrees Kelvin. Most lights have this information on the back but if it does not, ask one of the workers because someone there should know. Personally, I'm a fan of the clamp lights because they're cheap as hell so I can afford 20 of them and I can clamp them anywhere on set.


​

Typically, the actual clamp reflectors are on a separate aisle from the lights. I would also recommend grabbing a couple of extension cords for your lights, those will come in handy too.
 
3.) Be nice and reasonable


This may seem like common sense but I have seen people doing this without them even knowing it. Let's start with the reality of the situation: most short films are made with no money. Some are made with a little bit of money. A teeny tiny portion have budgets that actually go into thousands of dollars. Most likely, you will fall into the first category and odds are, you will probably use several non-actors or amateur actors...and you won't have any money to pay them.


Now this in and of itself is no big deal. When we're all starting out, we all kind of rough it together and do these projects not for monetary reward, but as a way to gain experience and add something to the resume. And it should be fun! But since we are all not professional actors/writers/directors yet, life frequently gets in the way of things. Most of us hold down full-time or part-time jobs in addition to going to school or doing local theater or a myriad of other things as we try and make the most of life. As the director of a short film, you can never forget this fact.


Actors will sometimes cancel and have to reschedule. That guy who was going to help you with the lighting may have to go to his grandma's house for their family reunion and can't make it. You may have to quit shooting early because someone has to go work at Office Depot the next morning. And those are all perfectly okay things. But you cannot be too demanding!


Yes, for you, the director, this next film is your life. It's all you think about, it's all you want to do and you stress out incessantly until it is finished...and stress out some more when you submit it to 10 film festivals and none of them accept it. It's stressful. Trust me, I know. When someone cancels on you or keeps delaying their availability to shoot, it is easy to take it personally but more often than not, life is simply getting in the way for that person and they do not have a choice in it. The last thing you want to do is call them 3 times a day and keep pestering them. If they are extremely irritated, they may decide to drop out altogether. Granted, if they keep putting you off for 6 months or longer, you may want to simply hire someone else. But give them a chance first!


If you attack them personally, try to guilt them into shooting or even yell at them, you can almost guarantee they will tell you "Adios". This also applies to being on set. BE NICE! Thank everyone for being there! When you ask someone to grab the microphone from the other room or help bring in your big bulky lights from the trunk of your Mazda, say "Please" beforehand and "Thank you!" afterward. Be TOO nice! It will make a difference and morale will skyrocket. Everyone simply wants to know that they are appreciated in life and this is no exception.


If you aren't paying them, don't give them a reason to say "Why am I even doing this?". And even if you are paying them, don't be a dick unless you want them to give you less than 100%. Even if you truly believe they are being unreasonable or putting other priorities ahead of your precious film, just smile, work something out, and go home so you can chug vodka and punch the wall until your hand bleeds while listening to your mix CD of Slipknot and Tool.


Be mature. Be a leader. That's what directing is all about.

4.) Storyboarding is your best friend


Now I can already hear the indie kids or art house aficionados say "Pfff, storyboarding? I can just make it up on set, it will feel more real and fresh". And you know what? That's fine if you want to do that but it will not hurt one bit to have something as a backup, something on hand to give you inspiration.


When you are first starting out and especially when you aren't paying anyone, it helps when you at least appear to be professional. One way to appear professional is to seem like you actually know what you are doing (even if you don't). Why is this so important? If one of your actors or technicians do not have complete faith in you, they may not give it their all or may even start having regrets about joining your project. Or even worse, they may not see you as a voice of authority and may disregard your suggestions, opting to instead do what they want to do because they feel that you are a total amateur. I have heard of scenarios were secondary technicians have tried to take over the shoot because they felt they knew more than the director did.


One simple way to appear to know what you are doing is to storyboard before hand. When the actors ask you "What's next?" the last think you want to say is "I have no idea and I wouldn't even know where to start". You want to be able to point to a shot list and a page of storyboards that you can show them, that they can actually look at and prepare for.


But even more than that, it will typically benefit you the most! Why? Well, for obvious reasons, storyboarding helps you work out your shots before you spend a single minute on set. When you spend hours and hours over-thinking how you might want to frame a certain shot or how a scene will play out visually with exquisite camera angles, that is all time that you will be saving yourself on set. Because if you didn't know it already, every second on set is precious. PRECIOUS! It flies by and you NEVER have enough time to get everything you want. So why waste hours on set thinking about how to shoot your bicycle explosion when you can think about it by yourself at your house without wasting everyone's time?


Am I saying you have to slavishly follow your storyboards when you're filming? Absolutely not! But it will give you a rock solid foundation, the sand on the playground that you can confidently play in. It will free your mind and allow it to be in the moment, which will inspire you. When you're on set, it's easier to have some sort of idea of how you want to shoot it and go off of that instead of starting completely from scratch.


Do your homework! Think think think, cross check as much as you can before you shoot. You already have enough things to do on set, no need to overload your plate. You will thank yourself and your crew will thank you as well. And you may save yourself from an ulcer, heart attack, or both. (ulcer attack?)


If you've never looked at a storyboard in your life, I personally recommend picking up Film Directing Shot by Shot: Visualizing from Concept to Screenby Steven D. Katz as a solid primer on the subject.


5.) Have someone to operate the boom mic
Good sound, no, GREAT sound makes up 50% of your film. It's one of those weird things that may not be noticeable unless it's really bad. So if you do a good job on it, the general audience won't even notice that you did a good job. But at least they won't be trash talking your film after!


So, if at all possible, have someone handle the microphone with a boom stand. Make sure they aim it down at your actors and follow them so the voices don't get distant if they walk away or anything of that nature. In previous films I've done, I didn't have the luxury of having a boom operator so I had to use a mic stand the best I could. Although this is better than nothing I suppose, there were moments when my actors moved around and it didn't pick it up clearly 100%. So I had to edit it a bit in post and polish it up but the simple fact is, if I would have had someone there in the first place, I would have saved a couple of hours and it would have sounded better overall.
 
I'm commenting while watching

"what did I do wrong", make it 0,5sec longer (the sound track), or start the next track (in sound, the clip so) 0,5 earlier so you don't have a hole/gap.

the shot-change at 00:14 is strange, it's weird, it gives a weird feeling, it's like..héé, what's that ??? So now I'm thinkig about that weird shot and
lost in the story for few seconds...

the panning from down to up face was not needed... it's not someone who we may not know or suspicious or...

the framing is not bad, it's good you don't have 4846486434 miles of space above the heads.

00:47 when he turns his head you can hear him "coming in the mic". in that shot the mic is right from him, so when he speaks in front he sounds a little
more "roomy", when he turns his head, he speaks more into the mic. Have you used a rode NT2 or so ?

And here the framing (angled up) gives me a "he feels big, he feels the boss" feeling.

There's also a fridge or heater or cooler or something turning and being noisy... But that can be fixed with some good noisreduction and maybe even EQ.
With some EQ you can make the dialogue also sound a bit better.

03:18, like here the space above the head is to much, it's strange. You know those pictures where a small kid is trying to have his head above the table ?

It's good you didn't fill it up with music 100% to "hide" mistakes (which most people do...even they say it's artistic choise but.. I know better :-p)

I can see you color corrected some shots, I think in some you have to much green in it.. I'm not a color corrector so I'm not sure...but I think....

In general it's not bad, the sound is good enough, maybe some little EQ, noisereduction to remove the sound of the fridge or heater or..., but you don't have
"big isues" in sound.

The story itself, well I'm not so a big "love story fan".... But I can see there are some "ups and downs" (not as in good or bad but as in "suspense" and "rest" )
 
Well, I didn't really watch the whole thing. I had to jump ahead, and then was no longer interested.

It's whiny talking heads in a neon green room, for the most part. It looked like overlit Mexican soap opera from the 90s. Other han that, it's not telling a story visually.

Why can't these people be outside at all? Why does the wall need to look like a green screen two feet behind them? What else can be going on on another level to show something between them?

If the boy and girl are supposed to get together, it could be structured much better. What's keeping them apart? They seem very familiar already, so there's no meeting, no introduction or learning about one another. There's none of the stuff of relationships, just an endless complaining conversation.

The end seemed to have some music video that was completely irrelevant and should have been a different project altogether.
 
Hello everyone! I've been on this site for years now and after reading, studying, experimenting and learning as much as possible, I put out my 1st short film a few months ago called Trying My Best to Love You. Of course, it being my 1st short film, I learned A LOT of things the hard way...the extremely hard way. The hard way that makes you spend 1 1/2 years on completing a 10 minutes short.

For the tech heads, I should mention that I used a Panasonic HVX200 to film with, trying to use mostly natural available light. We had two small clamp lights that were 150 watts each I believe and that was pretty much it. I did not use any sort of 35mm adapters, it was all straight from the camera (color corrected, of course).

I'll just make one comment on the green walls... ugh...

So, on that note... other stuff...

1) when the girl is talking she frequently 'bounces'. I don't know if that is her 'natural' behavior when talking or whether it is a 'on camera, acting' behavior. In any case, while in the master shots of the room it is not so noticeable, when you frame her in a closeup, the bounce becomes distracting, like she's over acting.

2) The guy, while he didn't bounce, seemed pretty stoic, and his hair sort of hid his eyes, which bother me in the shots where he's in closeup.

3) For me, for the most part, way too long...

One idea that occurred to me is if the guy is 'reevaluating' his love life, then perhaps some extreme closeups would work. She's talking, but she has to hold her head pretty steady, but the framing crops down to her eyes... the guy likes her eyes. Then her lips... that sort of thing. He's whining bout 'the other girl' but her he's checking out his best 'gal' friend...

There were a few technical issues, shadows on the 'green walls', etc. despite the apparent 'light' coming from the windows.

Another sort of 'subtle' effect was in the front door scene, at about 5:45 or so. The apparent camera angle when you are shooting from the grass to the girl and guy in the 2-shot setup, you are 'looking over the guy's left shoulder'. From inside the house to the guy outside, you are on the same 180 deg. side. However, on a number of the shots of the girl in a single, she's looking to 'camera left', or her right, which suggests you have crossed over the back of the guy, so her eye-line is looking to what would be 'empty space' from the other two shots.
 
What's keeping them apart? They seem very familiar already, so there's no meeting, no introduction or learning about one another. There's none of the stuff of relationships, just an endless complaining conversation.


I guess you've never been confronted with the 'we are such good friends why screw it up' line from some young woman... perhaps that has fallen out of fashion in the last 30 years or so since I heard these sorts of 'reasons' why a change in the relationship to a more 'intimate' one wouldn't work.
 
Wow, lots of great feedback! Thanks to everyone who checked it out!

dre83: Thanks for the in depth commentary! Yes, I actually used a Rode NT-2 throughout the whole shoot. Like I mentioned in one of the posts above, we didn't have the luxury this time of having a boom operator, which ultimately hurt the sound as some of the dialogue sounds roomy and some sound clear when they're speaking directly into the microphone.

maranfilms: I bought some 5000 Kelvin rated halogens at Home Depot, believe it or not. I actually talked to one of the workers there and he was able to point it out. It's very well hidden in their wall of lights so you may need to ask around. Although they obviously do not compare to professional lights, they're better than nothing and are fairly cheap.
 
Back
Top