The Singh Ray Vari ND is expensive. And worth it!

puredrifting

Major Contributor
Hi all:

Not sure how many of you have ponied up the bucks for the Singh Ray Vari ND filter? http://www.singh-ray.com/varind.html
I did and used it for the first time today. I must say that this filter is a revelation and I am wondering why I have not heard more about people raving about it with the 5D. I shot in bright late afternoon sun with the 5D MKII and a Nikon 50mm 1.4 AI lens. I used a 52mm to 77mm step up ring to attach the Vari ND to the lens.

I will go so far as to say that having this filter ALMOST negates the need to have manual controls. Put the filter on the 5D MKII, point the camera at whatever you are going to shoot. What's that, it is giving me a crazy 1/1500th of a second shutter speed? No problem, just dial down the Vari ND until I got what I wanted which was 1/60th and ISO 100. Begin to shoot. I am following a subject that goes from nuclear daylight to a patio that drops the light levels way down.

This is the kicker, as I track the subject, the Vari ND is functioning like a manual iris control. It is smooth, it is repeatable and I don't even need to mess with the clicky exposure compensation dial on the back of the camera. Brilliant! Genius! It is right on the lens barrel next to the focus ring, just like on a real broadcast lens. This is even better than my HPX170 as far as tracking and quickly tweaking exposure. The only thing I am missing are zebras but with the Z-Finder, so far judging exposure is right on. WYSIWYG.

I am officially blown away, this works great. I can get the exposure I need in any situation in about 5 seconds. Of course, the Vari ND is not needed for interiors but for exteriors or super bright windows as BGs on interiors, this thing is magic.

Most expensive filter I have ever bought at close to U.S. $400.00 but well worth it. This will make my 5D life so much easier. Looking forward to a firmware update but if it never comes, this still makes the camera VERY usable for my needs. So count me as a fan of this filter. All you people pissing and moaning about a firmware update, buy this, it puts you 90% of the way there.

Dan
 
Been using them for years. Their in the same league of the high end line of B&W....


Michael Pappas
Main Web Site
http://www.pbase.com/Arrfilms

Anamorphic DSLR Lens Test Images... links:
http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showpost.php?p=1638289&postcount=97
http://www.dvxuser.com/V6/showpost.php?p=1637705&postcount=84

Facebook:
http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael-Pappas/573417404
http://www.Myspace.com/PappasArts
Arrfilms@hotmail.com
http://www.PappasArts.com
CONTACT VIA AOL INSTANT MESSENGER
AT { PAPPASARTS2 }
 
Last edited:
Haven't tried it yet, but doesn't it pretty much guarantee that you're losing a minimum of two stops when you put it on?

How about image effects when you pan outdoors -- does it handle just like a regular polarizer, so you have to watch the direction you're aiming? Or do the dual polarizers somehow neutralize that effect?
 
Hi Barry:

Yes, you will be losing a minimum of 2 stops. Fortunately with the extreme sensitivity of the 5D MKII imager, that is usually not an issue. Of course, for interiors, you wouldn't use it. I only use it for exteriors. I don't see much, if any polarizing effect, it seems to mainly just be an ND effect that doesn't seem to be affected by angle to the sun seeing as I was shooting right before golden hour. A regular pola wouldn't have much if any effect that late in the day and the ND function worked the same as it did midday. It seems like a great tool for better controlling the 5D MKII.

Dan
 
Resurrection of a thread...

I would guess the need for IR blocking filters would be similar as that for any non-variable ND filter.

I haven't tried the Tiffen T1 or any such filter, but I would think that you could create a grading issue if you shoot the same scene in which you've changed your ND (either by swapping out different NDs or by varying the variable one), in which your blacks could look different from shot to shot, because you have no way of varying the IR blocking effect. You either have the IR blocker on your stack, or off. Does that make sense? Can anyone comment on their experience with this?
 
how about a vari-ND vs ND fader - shoot out

i have both; the singh ray was over 3x the price, and not one iota better. for my money, and for my other cameras, i bought Fader ND's. no need to overpay; besides all they are is a circular polarizer and a linear polarizer filter; nothing really special.
 
Back
Top