FS7: Sigma MC-11, not looking so good

Title sums it up pretty well. My mc-11 came in today and while this nicely priced adapter looked really promising, I know a lot of people had many unanswered questions.

I bought this adapter to use on my FS7. I have 3 sigma lenses (35 A, 50 A, 150-600 C) and a bunch of Canon lenses everything from the nifty fifty to L series lenses.

The Sigma lenses seem to communicate fine. Aperture control and focus distance readouts work as expected. I read that autofocus for video would not work. When pressing autofocus button the fs7, the lenses simply searches for focus but it never finds it. When the fs7 is switched to autofocus, focus seems to lock on slowly but eventually gets there. I cant really compare properly since i never used the fs7 with a proper emount lens. Perhaps it works like it's supposed too but Either way autofocus on the fs7 with the mc-11 is not worth it.

The other part of the adapter I was excited about was the distortion correction. Again, this was hard to test. I navigated to the menu to turn it on, however, all I saw was "off" or "auto" when set to auto, the camera turns off the preview LUT. As far as distortion correction, I can only assume its working without testing it properly against a brick wall. The sigma art lenses have very little distortion to begin with anyway, I'd really want it for a lens like my Tokina 11-16.

Now the question everyone is wondering, does the adapter work with Canon lenses? In short no at least not with the ones I tested (50 1.8, 24 1.4 and 24-70 2.8 I) while you can mount these lenses, the aperture control is not compatible. The 50 would switch between f2 and 2.2, the 24-70 wouldn't change aperture at all and the 24 1.4 would close down fine but when opening up it would flash to wide open before it went to the next apeture value. I could test other lenses but thought it was pointless. Perhaps Sigma will add support for Canon lenses in the future.

The adapter is still on pre-order at most retailers so it seems I'm lucky to be one of the early recipients. I plan on returning the adapter so if anyone has any questions let me know and I can try to test it before I send it back.

Update: I tested it with a few more lenses. Tokina 11-16 II, Canon 100mm Macro 2.8 (Non-l), Canon 135 f2, Canon 40mm 2.8 Pancake. The only lens that I was able to adjust the aperture with was the 40mm Pancake, however, it did the same thing as the 24 1.4 where (when opening up the aperture) it would quickly open up all the way before moving to the next aperture value. This would be fine for certain types of shoots but wouldn't work for documentary or event style projects.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the feedback. Hopefully Sigma works out any issues as people are super excited for these. Especially for the Sony mirrorless cameras.
 
feedback from still photography side. A7RII + MC-11 + Sigma 150-600mm C

TAKING IMAGES:

AF-S Works fine. Seems to focus quickly enough for my tastes.

AF-C Pretty much is not usable, struggles a lot. I tried all the focus point options and all produce inconsistent, mostly unusable results. One final note: at 150-400mm AF-C works better but not perfect. 400mm-600mm is pretty much useless.

AF-A Never had this option with the Metabones. It continuously focuses and works reasonably well.

DMF - It autofocuses with focus peeking turned on. I like this mode for verifying that what I'm shooting IS in focus.

THOUGHTS ON TAKING IMAGES: I'm really disappointed that AF-C is pretty much useless. I expected this to work and it just doesn't. Really Sigma?

SHOOTING VIDEO:

Holy crap! This is the best feature of this adapter. The metabones IV doesn't autofocus at all whereas the Sigma MC-11 does a really good job. I can swing the A7RII with the Sigma 150-600mm to different subjects and it pretty much locks on to focus at all distances. The only real negative is hearing the lens "chatter" as it constantly is checking focus.

Here's some sample footage. You can see how well it focuses and you can also hear the constant "chatter." The noise is not a huge deal for me considering I rarely record audio with the footage and when I do I usually use directional microphones away from the camera. Yes, I did have image stabilization turned on during this clip, but the chatter occurs w/o IS on as well

if i'm not wrong, this adapter target the still photography camera, not the video side.
 
Last edited:
Hey Bubble, do you have a link to the original post? I'd be curious to check out the sample footage refrenced. After sleeping on it, I am leaning towards keeping the adapter and using it with my sigma lenses. I trust the IS compatibility and internal flocking over some cheaper adapters. Also I'm hopefull that Canon lenses will eventually be supported. If they are then great, otherwise, I still have my metabones speedbooster for everything else.
 
Isn't that Sigma clearly stated that this adapter is (and will be) strictly only for Sigma lenses with Canon mount? As far as I remember they don't even guarantee compatibility with other Sigma lenses that they haven't listed.
 
Isn't that Sigma clearly stated that this adapter is (and will be) strictly only for Sigma lenses with Canon mount? As far as I remember they don't even guarantee compatibility with other Sigma lenses that they haven't listed.

I know they have stated that it's currently only compatible with Sigma's new line of lenses. I think people were hoping that the omission of lenses didn't necessarily equate to incompatibly. I haven't read anywhere that Sigma said it will never support other lenses, if you find where you read that I would be interested in seeing it.
 
I think the strength of this adapter won't really show in the FS7. It was mostly made for the A7RII, A7SII, and A6300. Those have really nice built in AF modules that really benefit from the reverse engineering Sigma has done with this adapter to get them to act like native E Mount glass from Sony. I currently shoot with the FS7 but also have the A7RII for all of my photography work. I purchased one to adapt some Sigma lenses, like my favorite 24-105 lens I own. Also looking to build a fast f/1.8 kit using the 18-35 and 50-100 on the FS7 + MC11. I had problems in the past with Metabones and Sigma lenses, so this new adapter will make me feel at ease when I am on shoots with adapted Sigma glass.
 
I've noticed the same behavior with my Sigma 150-600 with Metabones EF adapter. Push Auto hunts for focus and misses. There is no auto focus functionality that I can confirm.
 
I purchased one to adapt some Sigma lenses, like my favorite 24-105 lens I own. Also looking to build a fast f/1.8 kit using the 18-35 and 50-100 on the FS7 + MC11.

Those are the lenses I was looking at getting to use with the adapter, especially the 24-105. I'm curious how those work together, as I'm currently debating between the Canon 24-105 and the Sigma 24-105. Any thoughts on those 2?
 
Sigma released a firmware update for hte MC-11. I tested it out with my Canon lenses and it appears that we now have aperture control with a catch. When opening up the aperture (not closing) the adapter opens the lens to wide and then closing down really quickly, so you get a flash of bright exposure. This will matter to some people and not matter to others.

It also works in a similiar fashion with my Tokina 11-16 which I'm very happy about.
 
Last edited:
check: Push Auto hunts for focus and misses.
check: after touching manual focus ring autofocus stops completely untill rebooting FS&
check: aperture control doesn't always work

The commlite does give some information about aperture, and thats all.
 
My Sigma MC-11 arrived.

Its a shame about the aperture flicker on Canon lenses but the adapter controls flare extremely well.
 
Yes but the Sigma said that the adapter works flawlessly with Sigma a,s,c lenses... And it works with them.
They never mentioned, it'll work with the canon lenses...
 
Also looking to build a fast f/1.8 kit using the 18-35 and 50-100 on the FS7 + MC11. I had problems in the past with Metabones and Sigma lenses, so this new adapter will make me feel at ease when I am on shoots with adapted Sigma glass.
But does anybody know by now, if the Sigma 18-35 works fine with the FS7 and the MC11?
 
Back
Top