Should I upgrade?

DavidBeier

Veteran
Currently I have the following:

AMD Athlon 64 3200+
1 gig of RAM
GeForce 6600GT 256 mg

I've been able to upload MXF files from the HVX200 into Avid and play them without any trouble, meaning I could edit HD footage fine. However, when trying to play extracted Raylight AVI files from MXF's, my computer chugs like crazy. This doesn't bug me too much as I won't really need to use Raylight since I have Avid but it worries me about trying to view other HD outputs.

I've already decided that I'm going to by at least one more gig of RAM. The other thing I'm considering is getting a processor upgrade. I have a Gigabyte GA-k8nf-9 motherboard. The people who made my computer told me that even though it currently has only a Athlon 64 3200 chip in it, I could replace that easily with a Athlon 64 X2 4400 chip. While the processor speed isn't that much higher, the X2 is a dual core which I've heard makes a big difference. My question is do you guys think it's worth the $460 it'll cost to go from the Athlon 64 3200 to the Athlon X2 64 4400? The 3200 to 4400 difference isn't enough for me but will the dual processor's make a big difference.

For the record, I don't want to switch to Intel even though i've been told it's better (it would mean getting a new motherboard and I HATE Intel). Also, is it true that AMD is about to come out with a new set of CPUs and the X2 prices will soon drop?

Finally, is there much to be gained by getting a better video card since it seems that the programs I tend to use (Avid, Combustion, After Effects, and Nuendo) don't seem to make much use of the video card. Thanks.
 
If you have the cash to do it, then YES! I actually had the exact same setup, video card and all, as you have now. I was unable to play back 720p smoothly enough to be easily usable, and 1080i was totally worthless. I then upgraded to the 4400+ X2 CPU, and 4gb of Ram. Now 720p plays back and edits in real-time. I haven't tested 1080i yet, but from what I've read of others experiences, one can expect about 19-22fps playback speed (which is close enough for me).

I have no regrets about my choice. The dual-core makes a huge difference in rendering times, even when working with DV.
 
Back
Top