Should FCPX have it's own section separate to "Final Cut Studio".

Status
Not open for further replies.
Searcher

Searcher

Well-known member
It is a completely new program that cannot even import FCP7 files.

Many people might end up switching away from FCP so wouldn't it be better for them that they didn't have to trawl through all the FCPX threads while they continue to use earlier versions?

Does that make sense?

Surely in an operating system forum you wouldn't bunch OS9 together with OSX?

Perhaps they need to be together because of the common use of "Motion" etc?
 
Searcher said:
It is a completely new program that cannot even import FCP7 files.

Many people might end up switching away from FCP so wouldn't it be better for them that they didn't have to trawl through all the FCPX threads while they continue to use earlier versions?

Does that make sense?

Surely in an operating system forum you wouldn't bunch OS9 together with OSX?

Perhaps they need to be together because of the common use of "Motion" etc?
Click to expand...
It may very well be too early for that kind of move. FCPX is much more capable than many here have realized and it is NOT iMovie Pro, though it edits very similarly. But, iMovie isn't represented here on the forums and it may make sense to put the two Apple programs that are from the same foundation and editing environment in the same sub-forum.

IMO, give it more time.
 
TheReverend said:
It may very well be too early for that kind of move. FCPX is much more capable than many here have realized and it is NOT iMovie Pro, though it edits very similarly. But, iMovie isn't represented here on the forums and it may make sense to put the two Apple programs that are from the same foundation and editing environment in the same sub-forum.

IMO, give it more time.
Click to expand...

I was not trying to diss FCPX compared to FCP but just pointing out that it's different. I downloaded FCPX after reading all the reviews yesterday and I love it so far. But I understand the frustrations of others.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top