Poll of 2 Trailers

[Douglas Villalba]

I have to submit to the Producers of a Feature I just finished a trailer to used for advertising.

I did two grading versions and will like your opinion on the one you like best.


https://vimeo.com/46202637
https://vimeo.com/46203584

 

[MPB]

neither. somewhere in between. the first one looks a little too bland, it needs to be dressed up a little. the second goes too far.

 

[Douglas Villalba]

There are only this two choices. The answer has to be one or the other.
I know what I like, so it is more about what different people around the world like.
Taste in Grading is one of those things that changes according to the viewers geographic & climatic location.

 

[Teodor Miljevic]

Number one. The first looked ok. The second was plain bad it looked very cheap and amateurish. I hope you don't feel I'm rude I just tell it as I see it. Some of the dark night scenes looked better in version two. maybe you could cut the last clips from version2 and add it to version one .

 

[Chris Adler]

Number two is cheesy. One is pretty flat, but at least its not cheesy.

 

[starcentral]

I like #2 better, but that is personal opinion.

#2 is far more punchier and has a more contrast-look to it. #1 is very flat looking, looks like soap-opera to me and way less cinematic than #2.

That is my honest opinion.

 

[gaffney film]

Tough call. #2 seems to hide some of the lighting problems better than #1. I guess I'd go with 2.

 

[starcentral]

Doug, the damn suspense is killing me... which version are you leaning towards?

 

[Douglas Villalba]

Doug, the damn suspense is killing me... which version are you leaning towards?

Hehehe, It goes along the comments that I made about geography and climatic zones.