Well at the time midi was new. But they saw it like everyone else did, a tremendous tool for composition and arranging, and creating certain performances. They liked it more than non-pianists to be honest, especially as real sampling came in to play.
You know there used to be a lot of decent studio gigs for local cats. I'm not talking Nashville or LA stuff, but local stuff, jingles for car dealerships, radio promos, etc. Even when I was in high school I used to get royalty checks from jingle work (or a decent one time pay off). Once "keyboardist composers" were able to duplicate other instruments through sampling (even when it was not very good) media buyers realized that they could pay one guy instead of six or eight....
I also used to make some nice coin doing transcription work for composition majors and broadway houses. This was when you only had two options, have your music typeset or have someone spend an hour a page handdrawing the manuscript. Then Apple came out with their notation software and it was over. Guys with an apple computer would charge loose change to input the score and print it out. I use a program called Sibelius (some guys prefer Finale). The power of this program is amazing...
Anyway, back to pianists. As I said, the guys I know are amazed at the level of reality contained in a good sample library. A guy living in a studio apartment in the City and lay down a recording that sounds like it was recorded on priceless concert grand in prince albert hall... The only instruments that I've heard that are really poor are certain woodwinds. Strings are harder, that percusive instruments but if you're willing to spend several thousand dollars and you have a really good midi orchestrator working for you, you'll be amazed at what you can get out of them. Most people will never know the difference. Will a concert violist know? Sure, but sometimes they get fooled in the short term too.
Again are these representations perfect? No, but sometimes they sound like they are. I have to ask, have you heard some of the high-end sample libraries when they're used to their fullest?
I've heard some, but I can't guarantee anything about "to their fullest." But my clients are folks who can't stand listening to playback on a Disklavier because the dynamics are so lacking in range and detail. I myself wouldn't mistake a classical performance on a piano for either a sample library or a Disklavier, but I don't reject the sampled/MIDI approach. I think it has plenty of uses in all facets of music production, and there are many styles of music for which it works great and sounds great. I'm basically just saying here that a) it's not a perfect replacement for a real piano, and b) it's not so difficult to get good sound out of a real piano that people should just give up off the bat.
Being here in L.A., I know plenty of pianists and other musicians who also bring in some bucks orchestrating (some are parts of Oscar-winning scoring teams) who live in both the MIDI and acoustic worlds... and it's these folks who would never consider using a sampled piano for anything important. Again, these are classical folks, who have very different standards than folks working in other genres...
Very true. I wouldn't either for a classical performance. Nor would I for a world class jazz performance. I agree with every point you've made, but let's be fair/clear about what we're talking about. For a piano part in a pop tune or even for a piece of "classical music" that is only going to exist as a bed played under dialog? Or a piano in a short film score (that's NOT about a concert pianist)? Nah, I'll save the time and hassle and go midi.
I'm all for fair and clear! I don't disagree with what you're saying either. And I hope I don't come off as anti-MIDI. As I said way back, I think ultimately only samrwamr can determine in the end what best suits his needs. I just want to make sure he's not discouraged from trying to record the piano - and to counteract some statements (not yours) that indicate that sequencing will yield better results...
Anyway, it's good that we have lots of choices and possibilities. Try 'em all, I say!