Barry_Green
Moderator
I am certain that that's exactly how it used to work, yes. Sony in particular would dream up something, and then throw it out in the marketplace, and tell us to buy it. And for decades, we did.just show up sometimes? Where not the market, but the maker/designer dictate what they think you'll need?
Now, not so much. Now, especially in the days of instant feedback like we have with the internet, you just can't do things like that anymore and expect success. More and more, consumer electronics are starting to resemble feature film launches -- you get one shot at an opening weekend. If you get a hit review (i.e., Vincent Laforet does a short film with your camera and the internet goes ga-ga) then you've got a solid product launch. If you don't, you better regroup quickly and come up with something else.
I know that these companies actively go and ask people what they want. Problem is, while a few people know exactly what they want, large numbers of folks may not have any idea. They may *think* they know what they want, but then Apple comes along with an iPod and turns the world upside down.
Everyone told Panasonic they were nuts to introduce solid-state memory recording, but they ended up becoming the dominant industry player with it. You just never know.
If there was a magic formula, everyone would do it and everyone would be successful...