I’ll try to make this less of a rant and more of a conversation starter. Maybe we can try and get an insightful discussion going here.
I’ve been “playing” the festival “game” with my most recent short film “Incoherent” and it hasn’t picked up any awards so far – in fact the selections are becoming rather slim now (when we started off it had 3 selections on top of each other). Anyway, I keep a close eye on the festivals I enter, as well as the films that pick up the awards, and I’ve realized three things (this is obviously my own opinion):
1. Selections and winnings seem to be incredibly subjective. It really does feel similar to gambling when entering your film into these festivals.
2. The short films that are winning usually have a very high production value that’s put in place through extensive (and often ridiculous) budgets and professional crew and cast members with no guerrilla filmmaking techniques being made use of. Since I’m not a film student, in an official manner at least, I have to compete with these “professionals”. To be quite honest, I find this rather unfair – then again, no one said life was fair.
3. The films that are winning don’t usually seem original. In fact, to me, they seem rather mainstream. Have the judges of these festivals watched enough original or indie film to actually qualify? It does seem like these small to medium sized festivals have a preconceived idea of what indie film should be and what kind of storyline it should typically follow (Mostly overdone human drama).
Have these small-medium sized festivals (4 to 8 years in the running) gone commercial under the true indie filmmakers spot light? Do they look for “generic” art house films with a great budget (with that production value that guerrillas can’t reach)?
Don’t get me wrong – I’m proud that my film has been officially selected by a few U.S. festivals so far. I’m just worried about the state and direction that film is taking at the moment. Commercial cinema is enough to worry about, but now we need to start worrying about the film festivals - where the real progress in story and original content should be made.
I’ll leave you with a quote that so many filmmakers (and even festivals for that matter) should take to heart, from the legend himself, Alfred Hitchcock…
“Eventually everything becomes avoiding the cliché. Your own cliché as well as everyone else’s. It’s not just what you’ve done. It’s what everyone else has done and done and done. I pity the poor people in the future.”
I’ve been “playing” the festival “game” with my most recent short film “Incoherent” and it hasn’t picked up any awards so far – in fact the selections are becoming rather slim now (when we started off it had 3 selections on top of each other). Anyway, I keep a close eye on the festivals I enter, as well as the films that pick up the awards, and I’ve realized three things (this is obviously my own opinion):
1. Selections and winnings seem to be incredibly subjective. It really does feel similar to gambling when entering your film into these festivals.
2. The short films that are winning usually have a very high production value that’s put in place through extensive (and often ridiculous) budgets and professional crew and cast members with no guerrilla filmmaking techniques being made use of. Since I’m not a film student, in an official manner at least, I have to compete with these “professionals”. To be quite honest, I find this rather unfair – then again, no one said life was fair.
3. The films that are winning don’t usually seem original. In fact, to me, they seem rather mainstream. Have the judges of these festivals watched enough original or indie film to actually qualify? It does seem like these small to medium sized festivals have a preconceived idea of what indie film should be and what kind of storyline it should typically follow (Mostly overdone human drama).
Have these small-medium sized festivals (4 to 8 years in the running) gone commercial under the true indie filmmakers spot light? Do they look for “generic” art house films with a great budget (with that production value that guerrillas can’t reach)?
Don’t get me wrong – I’m proud that my film has been officially selected by a few U.S. festivals so far. I’m just worried about the state and direction that film is taking at the moment. Commercial cinema is enough to worry about, but now we need to start worrying about the film festivals - where the real progress in story and original content should be made.
I’ll leave you with a quote that so many filmmakers (and even festivals for that matter) should take to heart, from the legend himself, Alfred Hitchcock…
“Eventually everything becomes avoiding the cliché. Your own cliché as well as everyone else’s. It’s not just what you’ve done. It’s what everyone else has done and done and done. I pity the poor people in the future.”