Lighting setup used in this scene from "The Covenant"

starcentral

Veteran
Anyone want to guess the lighting setup used for this scene from "The Covenant"?
DOP: Pierre Gill

Scene "A":
Covenant-Scene-A-001.jpg


Scene "A":
Covenant-Scene-A-002.jpg


Scene "A":
Covenant-Scene-A-003.jpg
 
Last edited:
My guess would be some large HMIs coming through the 'windows' for daylight, possibly shooting through a little diffusion to soften the light a little. A fog machine used a little overzealously for haze and added diffusion, and some sort of large, fairly soft toplight source hanging above the set.
 
there seems to be a floor light or a bounce in this. I'm not seeing the top light except on the man seated which may be more a kicker.
 
^ agree no top light.

The light definitely looks pretty hard judging from the shadows.

I'm thinking the two actors are lit separately, and possibly 2-3 light setups for wide, and single shots.

On the wide shot look at the young guys shirt collar on his neck and nose shadow, they are going "upwards" and his pant leg is pretty bright. His torso is flagged or something too since it goes back to darkness. On his close up his jacket is lit up, like the flag was removed.

On the older guy in the wide shot his head is lit pretty evenly, and the shadow behind his ear tells us the light is just off camera, probably the same height even as the camera or actor. On his close up though, I can't figure it out. Look at that globe in the lower left corner, it is very dark on one side but his face isn't... some kind of fill, bounce, or additional light even?

Looking at the wide shot again only the bottom half of the walls look lit.. perhaps a large curtain or something to flag off the top half of the walls in the room?

In general they avoided a lot of spill on the walls in what looks to be like a pretty small area. But what ever lights were used, they are well controlled and I want to know how and with what! :cool:
 
Nothing too complicated here. Mostly what Dennis said. The hot edge coming from the camera right side on the seated actor is bouncing off the desk top back up to the actor's face--probably helped by a small bounce on the desk. To me, it's a little over-filled. Each actor has a soft backlight, the one on the standing gent is a bit cooler. His key is indeed below eye level and is top-chopped with a net and possibly some light diffusion.
 
I was just guessing, but whenever I use any lights they spill all over the place. How can you light up just a face or certain part of the frame without spilling anywhere? I doubt snoots were used here, but those backgrounds walls seem hardly lit.
 
I was just guessing, but whenever I use any lights they spill all over the place. How can you light up just a face or certain part of the frame without spilling anywhere? I doubt snoots were used here, but those backgrounds walls seem hardly lit.


Thats where the Dedolights come in :)
 
Do you think that was used here? ie. super flat high quality beam like you get from a leko? Or was it perhaps some other light source heavily gridded and flagged?
 
I'd have to see the whole scene to get a sense of the geography, i.e. whether it was lit through windows or from inside the room etc. No specific clues as to whether it was daylight or tungsten instruments. The most tell-tale sign of a leko is the color fringe you get on the edges, but light diffusion like Hampshire can knock that out. At a certain point it becomes a little bit of folly to guess the instruments, because a number of instruments can do a similar job with this kind of look. It's more about placement, intensity, color, hard vs softness etc.

I once keyed a large stage with a 9 light through 8x8 gridcloth, and we flagged it heavily due to spill onto the surrounding walls. By the time it was done, from the actor's perspective it had narrowed down to essentially a 4x4 source. When I needed to cheat it around, I had a Parabeam with grid already in place and it delivered a virtually identical light with no grip gear needed.
 
there seems to be a floor light or a bounce in this. I'm not seeing the top light except on the man seated which may be more a kicker.

I'm seeing the top light in the fairly even illumination across the top of the standing guy's hair and the sitting guy's head. The shadows from their collars and noses, suggest the key light is coming in fairly side-on, so I don't think the light on top of their heads is coming from spill from the key.
 
There's definitely a soft backlight, either Kino or Chimera, playing on the standing chap's hair. I'd call it a backlight more than a toplight, it's definitely behind him, probably against the back wall. The reflection in the sitting guy's forehead would likely be this unit, although I feel like it's more of a reflection than anything else. Neither of them show evidence of high top or frontal sources on their features. Toplight usually manifests as a hot stripe down the nose, plus highlights above the brow. They aren't showing this. The fill on the seated gent is definitely from below--note the shadows under eye pockets, underneath of brow etc.

That wide shot is very interesting. It's quite a small space. There was definitely a relight for the turnaround on the standing guy, as the direction of the light would be nearly flat-on if it was left as is from that master shot (the camera is positioned fairly close to the window seen in the master). It's hard to tell if there is another window not seen in that shot that was used instead, but it is also possible that an instrument was placed inside the room for the turnaround as I suggested above. Too close for a Source 4 (even a 50 degree wouldn't have wide enough coverage at that distance). So, could be a smaller instrument up against the side wall. This does actually help explain why the far side wall is "seeing" so little of this light (except at the bottom)--close proximity allows the inverse square law to do it's thing, contributing to dropoff (the downside is that if the actor moves around much, you feel the intensity change significantly). Is this scene viewable online?
 
I hate double posting but out of curiosity I posted this on the ask dave mullen thread on you know where and he suggested combo of hard and soft lights as well, even referenced the lekos Charles did. but after i posted the high wide shot it was obvious to him that a single HMI with half diffusion over it.

Speaking of inverse-square law and I guess "fall-off" - a hard light does not have quick fall-off like a soft source does, but am I correct that the further away you place a soft source from its subject the more fall-off you will get, and hence less light reaching the back walls, but also a larger soft source will light more of the area, and be harder to control spill?

So is it forseeable to use a smaller soft source placed far away with serious grids and flags to light your subject but not as much your background? Or would you place it closer, say off frame and get that quicker fall-off effect?
 
David and I are pretty much suggesting the same thing with minor variations. However I still feel that the turnaround on the young gent was re-lit. The angle of the window relative to where he is standing would have looked much more frontlit from the perspective of the camera than what we are seeing, not to mention the directionality of the light source (it's downwards in the master, and up on his coverage). I strongly believe that was recreated from inside the room. BTW the soft topper he is referring to would have been a frame set from inside the room, not diffusion on the lamp itself, as that wouldn't have delivered a solid enough cut.

Regarding the hard/soft scenario you described--once a soft light moves far enough away, it starts to turn into a hard source. The reason for falloff on a soft source is the scattered light rays going this way and that. Once you get back far enough, you've eliminated the ones that aren't coming back at you, the source becomes effectively smaller and you reach a point of dimishing returns.
 
yes the young chap had to be relit for his shot since his torso has lighting on it not seen in the wider shot of him. Also if you look at the sofa behind him you can see a horizontal streak of light, I almost had a feeling that maybe perhaps as a quick 'm dirty lighting job a narrow bank was layed down facing upwards, which is why we might see his pant leg so brightly lit. Not sure.

Thanks for your answer on turning a soft light into a hard light source, makes sense. But obviously there are probably not a lot of scenarios where you'd use that. I guess maybe if you were looking to inefficiently boost ambient in a small space and keep an overall flat look.

Thanks again for your input on all this, its appreciated.
 
yes the young chap had to be relit for his shot since his torso has lighting on it not seen in the wider shot of him. Also if you look at the sofa behind him you can see a horizontal streak of light, I almost had a feeling that maybe perhaps as a quick 'm dirty lighting job a narrow bank was layed down facing upwards, which is why we might see his pant leg so brightly lit. Not sure.

I wouldn't call the adjustment made between the wide facing the young man and his closeup a "relight"--at most the soft topper was raised very slightly so that a little heat would make it into the bottom of the frame. I was referring to the complete turnaround from the super-wide master from behind him to the coverage facing him. As I noted, I believe they saved the big gun pushing through the window and replaced it with a separate unit inside the room for the young guy and probably another one for the seated guy, three or four feet upstage from the window. Or, if this was a set, they pulled that wall and rebuilt the source from further away. That wide shot is definitely from the same scene, right? Just wondering because the lighting is pretty significantly different on the seated guy as well.

As far as the kick in the sofa; leather will tend to spread sources so while that looks like a single kino tube reflection, it's more likely given the circumstances to just be a reflection of the standing guy's key or the diffusion topper in front of it. A kino on the floor wouldn't reflect that high up in the sofa, and it also wouldn't deliver as crisp a shadow as seen on the standing guy (nor could it be as delicately cut/diffused off his face).

It's been interesting doing Lighting Forensics!
 
Could be a single source....

Lift it up high to accommodate for the way it falls through the window.
Now look at the lamp shade behind the sitting guy. That reflection... could be foam core bouncing the light from the window and for the semi-close shots just put some foam core or white paper on the table / beneath the standing guy's knees.
You only need a slight amount of changing the source placement and you wouldn't compromise the the general look.

But flags are your friend indeed. It did a shoot last week and I wish I had more stands and flags rather than lights.
 
Back
Top