Lighting Family Dinner Table

Hello,

The dinner shoot had to be abandoned because of uncontrolled lighting. I rolled off some examples to show. Basically I turned up the iso to 800 and shot a f2 to get reasonable exposure on the subjects. Was hoping for an overcast day but direct sunlight hit the shades and turned them white hot. To have pulled this off acceptably, the windows would need to be controlled down by 1.5 - 2 stops and more fill to the faces (as suggested). Thankfully this shoot was just of test using my family members in preparation for an upcoming brief involving actors, etc. Ended the night with terrible imagery -- but a wonderful meal!!

Properly lighting a table has always been a challenge for me. The advice / photos given are helpful. Thanks to everybody and I hope the discussion his helpful to others and continues a little bit longer.

FYI - using just one 150 watt china ball for a table scene can yield acceptable results if you are constrained by time, location, space, etc. I posted some grabs from a shoot about 1 1/2 years ago in a restaurant shooting 800 iso at f2.

Here you go:

View attachment 68896View attachment 68897View attachment 68898

From restaurant:

View attachment 68899View attachment 68900View attachment 68901View attachment 68902View attachment 68903View attachment 68904

Cheers,

Mark

On the first shot, why not just scrim the windows instead of abandoning the shot?
 
^^ Hi Paul, I didn't have a scrim with me, just the china ball.

I carry a roll of black insect screen from Home Depot that makes for a good scrim material. It comes in 48" X 84" rolls and is inexpensive. I have cut the stuff up for custom nets/scrims and it would work great for windows, if you do not need to see out of them (Like in the first two example shots). It is NOT heat resistant, so don't use it very near hot lights. I keep the stuff, along with a basic grip electric kit, in a bag that I can throw in the trunk of my car.

http://www.homedepot.com/p/t/100565927?catalogId=10053&langId=-1&keyword=insect+screen&storeId=10051&N=5yc1v&R=100565927#.UVR2Uhlt9r0
 
I carry a roll of black insect screen from Home Depot that makes for a good scrim material. It comes in 48" X 84" rolls and is inexpensive. I have cut the stuff up for custom nets/scrims and it would work great for windows, if you do not need to see out of them (Like in the first two example shots). It is NOT heat resistant, so don't use it very near hot lights. I keep the stuff, along with a basic grip electric kit, in a bag that I can throw in the trunk of my car.

http://www.homedepot.com/p/t/100565927?catalogId=10053&langId=-1&keyword=insect+screen&storeId=10051&N=5yc1v&R=100565927#.UVR2Uhlt9r0

Great idea.
 
I carry a roll of black insect screen from Home Depot that makes for a good scrim material. It comes in 48" X 84" rolls and is inexpensive. I have cut the stuff up for custom nets/scrims and it would work great for windows, if you do not need to see out of them (Like in the first two example shots). It is NOT heat resistant, so don't use it very near hot lights. I keep the stuff, along with a basic grip electric kit, in a bag that I can throw in the trunk of my car.

http://www.homedepot.com/p/t/100565...toreId=10051&N=5yc1v&R=100565927#.UVR2Uhlt9r0


David, terrific idea!
 
...avoid the white table cloth!

Why? I know a ton of beautiful shots with withe table cloth. As a mater of fact, some of them became beautiful, because of the light bouncing of the cloth. Oliver Stones JFK, Gossford Park, Downton Abbey and more come to mind.

Actually I used white cloth a few times wit great results.

Did I miss something.
 
Why? I know a ton of beautiful shots with withe table cloth. As a mater of fact, some of them became beautiful, because of the light bouncing of the cloth. Oliver Stones JFK, Gossford Park, Downton Abbey and more come to mind.

Actually I used white cloth a few times wit great results.

Did I miss something.

I also like a white cloth if not a whole table cloth strategically placed napkins for filling the faces.
 
David, terrific idea!

Actually, I am glad that Frank showed up in this thread. I am pretty sure I got the idea for the insect screen from him in another post a good while back. I think he used the term "Bobinette" for the material that he used.

That screen material from HD is closer in light intensity cutting to what would be called a "Double" in a pro scrim. Works great.
 
I think he used the term "Bobinette" for the material that he used.

Yes, that was probably me. I'm using that since years, when I was not able to afford "pro" material.
Much later, when I bought my first flags with single and double net, I found out, that it is almost the same stuff.

The nice thing on insect nets and bobinette is, it comes in different grades (densities) from different companies.
Also in shops for bridal fabrics, you find a whole cheap variety of nets and silks for different lighting situations.

I have a 4x4 frame that I use with all sorts of weird materials to control light. Even camouflage nets, that give nice dots of light, or nets with leaves on them or rags woven in, and what not. Almost like a cocolores. You just have to get creative here, and look outside the "industry". Most of what you need is already there, and most of the time for a much better price.

I also use the insect net a lot for dimming down china balls, without changing color temperature. - just drape one or more layers over them, till you reach your levels.

Frank
 
Last edited:
Why? I know a ton of beautiful shots with withe table cloth. As a mater of fact, some of them became beautiful, because of the light bouncing of the cloth. Oliver Stones JFK, Gossford Park, Downton Abbey and more come to mind.

Actually I used white cloth a few times wit great results.

Did I miss something.

Not at all ...and I am sure you have great examples including your own work.

If one has the skills and facility to "control" it so it doesnt dominate the scene and take the eye from what it is meant to see...go for it.

The fact its large, white and detail less is the challenge. Underexposing it, will turn it grey. Exposing it high on the IRE makes it "bright".

(Digital white really is awful without detail and some cameras are really challenged by it if not managed.)

Minimising the expanse of it by camera angle, art direction, blocking and pooled lighting on the talent is how I would deal with it if confronted by the situation.

I personally would not ask the art department to art direct one to assist me to fill faces.
 
Back
Top