Let's talk wireless systems!

scottfs

Well-known member
Simple question: All about the same money here, so...

Rodelink filmmaker kit
or
Sony UWP-D11
or
Sennheiser G-3


Always borrowed before, but time to spring for the basic wireless kit.
 
I've used the Sennheiser G-3 for years. Very nice system.

Iv'e never used, but have heard reports of issues with the Rode.
 
My only complaint with the Rode is the size of the transmitter. It's bulky.

It's the most idiot proof of the bunch. Total Plug n Play. It also has the best battery life.

I've always had good experiences with the G3, but I have exprienced more dropouts with the G3 over the years than from my Rodelink sets.

I have very limited experience with the Sony, so I will leave that to others for commenting.

Edit: One other complaint with my Rodelink sets: I would have liked more granular control over gain. It's all in increments of 10. That's a bit uncivilized in our day and age.
 
I use the Sennheiser G-3 It works every time. easy to use. Works in all environments so far. I would recommend it.

No experience of the Sony.

As for Rode... The RØDELink system operates in the 2.4GHz frequency spectrum which is shared with common wireless transmission devices such as WiFi networks, Bluetooth devices, microwave ovens and more. The more 2.4GHz devices that are simultaneously running in the same location as your RØDELink system, the more congested this 2.4GHz frequency spectrum will be, cutting down the signal strength and overall operating range for all 2.4GHz devices. In a very busy 2.4GHz environment you may find your RØDELink system is unable to maintain its maximum operating range. I wouldn't use it for my work as it is usually in cities with a LOT of wifi competing of slots.

That said I use Rode NTG1, 2, reporters, Lavalieres, NT1-A and the videomic Me all of which I like,
 
I have Lectro 411s, 211s (+ an old 185 for sentimentality, though it still works good) and some G2s and G3s. The newer SHF (GHz cellular frequency) systems are easier to set up frequency wise, but they come with their own set of issues and may be better for folks with little frequency selection knowledge.
The Sennheiser G2/3 100 series seems to be the standard for a low cost system. Most of my pro film sound colleagues have some for hops, seconds, ect. The competitive Sony is noisier, but decent otherwise. Neither come with pro quality mics.
 
An external scanner should be used with a G2/3 system in suspect areas... the Rx internal scanner is inadequate for detecting all but very high modulation.. I've used G3s in mid-town Manhattan (aka, RF hell) w/o issue with the aid of an external scanner.
Another common cause for dropouts is the Tx antenna in contact with the wearer's skin. That can significantly reduce RF output.
In lieu of an external scanner, at least consult the Sennheiser (or other) up-to-date Frequency Finder to find and avoid frequency ranges in use by OTA TV. Choose a channel that is 'vacant' (best), or has a modulation of at least -80dBm Prx (good).
Praying to the RF gods is another option.
 
I have Lectro 411s, 211s (+ an old 185 for sentimentality, though it still works good) and some G2s and G3s. The newer SHF (GHz cellular frequency) systems are easier to set up frequency wise, but they come with their own set of issues and may be better for folks with little frequency selection knowledge.
The Sennheiser G2/3 100 series seems to be the standard for a low cost system. Most of my pro film sound colleagues have some for hops, seconds, ect. The competitive Sony is noisier, but decent otherwise. Neither come with pro quality mics.

Rick, I am glad you mention the low quality mic. I paired my Sennheiser G2 with a Sanken COS-11d and I couldn't be more happier.
 
An external scanner should be used with a G2/3 system in suspect areas... the Rx internal scanner is inadequate for detecting all but very high modulation.. I've used G3s in mid-town Manhattan (aka, RF hell) w/o issue with the aid of an external scanner.
Another common cause for dropouts is the Tx antenna in contact with the wearer's skin. That can significantly reduce RF output.
In lieu of an external scanner, at least consult the Sennheiser (or other) up-to-date Frequency Finder to find and avoid frequency ranges in use by OTA TV. Choose a channel that is 'vacant' (best), or has a modulation of at least -80dBm Prx (good).
Praying to the RF gods is another option.

Sitting on the transmit antenna is also a common drop out problem, our students do that a lot. No way to fix that sort of problem short of moving the TX.
 
my conclusion is that if the talent is wearing long pants, the best place for the transmitter is just above the ankle. Otherwise, you have to be half-smart and half-lucky.

I saw a youtube video the other day where the cute young interviewer was holding the transmitter in her hand like it was an interview microphone. The lav was clipped to her blouse. Strange, very strange.
 
Simple question: All about the same money here, so...

Rodelink filmmaker kit
or
Sony UWP-D11
or
Sennheiser G-3


Always borrowed before, but time to spring for the basic wireless kit.

Easy choice! Sony UWP-D11, same price as a G3 but the Sony is better! (still broadly the same class of wireless though: entry level. So it is ok getting G3 instead if you find a G3 for a cracking good deal secondhand. But overall, Sony just has various little ways it is better)

The only reason you hear G3 recommended so much more than anything else, is because their father recommended it to them... and why did their father recommend it to them? Because his grandfather recommend it to him..... and why did his grandfather recommend it to him? Because his great grandfather.... (you get the gist of where I'm going here!)

Oh, and just avoid RodeLink if you care about hiding transmitters! Too bulky.
 
Any of the above systems are fairly comparable. in that price range you are getting low power transmitters. So that is something to think about. Is a 30mW transmitter going to be powerful enough for your application? If not, then a budget adjustment to a 100wM or better transmitter might be in order.

All the best!

Dave
 
I cannot recommend that Sony system mentioned above, if it's the one I think it is. Working on campus of major energy company two days in a row. Day 1, fine. Day 2 (different room), terrible. Weak signal, scratchy/squealy audio, etc. Yes, I did a scan. Was probably 10 feet from talent on the bad day.
 
I cannot recommend that Sony system mentioned above, if it's the one I think it is. Working on campus of major energy company two days in a row. Day 1, fine. Day 2 (different room), terrible. Weak signal, scratchy/squealy audio, etc. Yes, I did a scan. Was probably 10 feet from talent on the bad day.

Are you **certain** you are not thinking of their older systems from Sony?

I never used them, but from what I've read Sony's latest wireless (which is what I highly recommend, as I own five of them! Use them professionally. And I own 2x RodeLinks additionally. Used heaps of times Sennheiser G3/G2/G1 as well, and own 5x Lectrosonics too) is a big leap forward on their older models.
 
I've used the Sennheiser G-3 before, and I had interference problems, odd because I was out of the central city.

And I'm worried about the loss of spectrum. Is this a valid concern?

The Lectrosonics would be nice. very nice. But my income and my workload do not justify it. I'm in the extreme backwaters of Sacramento, California. We don't even have decent internet here. I tested it, and AT&T offer 'broadband' speeds that are (literally) between Paraguay and Bolivia speeds.

There is no real film industry here, just commercials and corporate, and not much of that because this is a government town, and they have their own people.

That's why I'm going cheap!
 
Back
Top