Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
- Thread starter readw
- Start date
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
Top DVX Bottom Pal PD150. The bottom looks like it has more resolution which is why I think it's Pal.
Top DVX Bottom Pal PD150. The bottom looks like it has more resolution which is why I think it's Pal.
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
The first shot which had almost 3kw of light in the setup has some movement but little evidence of interlace lines indicating that it could have been shot using progressive mode. The colouring in the first shoot looks a little more film like and as other people have pointed out not as hard.
The second shot has the blue chroma edge and the hardness to the image that gives it that typical video look of the PD170 camera.
The first clip was shot using a DVX100ae (PAL) on cinemode (progressive) 25P, f2, 1/60
The second shot was using a PD170 (PAL, interlaced, 25i, ~f2 1/60
The second shot was lit using a 150 watt hmi light from the outside with a 1/2ct blue gell and a redhead with a 2ND filter from the inside.
Interestingly, most people got it right.
The first shot which had almost 3kw of light in the setup has some movement but little evidence of interlace lines indicating that it could have been shot using progressive mode. The colouring in the first shoot looks a little more film like and as other people have pointed out not as hard.
The second shot has the blue chroma edge and the hardness to the image that gives it that typical video look of the PD170 camera.
The first clip was shot using a DVX100ae (PAL) on cinemode (progressive) 25P, f2, 1/60
The second shot was using a PD170 (PAL, interlaced, 25i, ~f2 1/60
The second shot was lit using a 150 watt hmi light from the outside with a 1/2ct blue gell and a redhead with a 2ND filter from the inside.
Interestingly, most people got it right.
J.R. Hudson
Spirit Animal
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
I never was a good gambler
I thought it was a trick :-/
I never was a good gambler
I thought it was a trick :-/
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
I've actually been thinking about this issue a lot lately and I'm not fully convinced that soft=film. While discussing some of Disjectas work the topic of sharpness came up and he pointed out (rightly so) that film transfered to digital is quite sharp. I agreed with this but I still felt that there was something about video that made it stick out as being so "sharp." I'm beginning to think more and more that what we are percieving as a sharpness issue is in reality a DOF issue. We are seeing *too much* sharply and as opposed to the selective sharpness of film. I'm almost convinced that this is what makes the difference.
I've actually been thinking about this issue a lot lately and I'm not fully convinced that soft=film. While discussing some of Disjectas work the topic of sharpness came up and he pointed out (rightly so) that film transfered to digital is quite sharp. I agreed with this but I still felt that there was something about video that made it stick out as being so "sharp." I'm beginning to think more and more that what we are percieving as a sharpness issue is in reality a DOF issue. We are seeing *too much* sharply and as opposed to the selective sharpness of film. I'm almost convinced that this is what makes the difference.
antomic
Well-known member
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
"I'm beginning to think more and more that what we are percieving as a sharpness issue is in reality a DOF issue. We are seeing *too much* sharply and as opposed to the selective sharpness of film."
amen...i have been fighting that arguement for ever.
"I'm beginning to think more and more that what we are percieving as a sharpness issue is in reality a DOF issue. We are seeing *too much* sharply and as opposed to the selective sharpness of film."
amen...i have been fighting that arguement for ever.
darkstyle8
Active member
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
top is DVX bottom is PD
top is DVX bottom is PD
Motherboard
Well-known member
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
please don't tell me the bottom one is the DVX
please don't tell me
aawwwwwwwwwwwwwwggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
please don't tell me the bottom one is the DVX
please don't tell me
aawwwwwwwwwwwwwwggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
scharky
Veteran
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
[quote author=readw link=board=Clips;num=1104154995;start=15#23 date=12/28/04 at 14:09:37]The first shot which had almost 3kw of light in the setup has some movement but little evidence of interlace lines indicating that it could have been shot using progressive mode. The colouring in the first shoot looks a little more film like and as other people have pointed out not as hard.
The second shot has the blue chroma edge and the hardness to the image that gives it that typical video look of the PD170 camera.
The first clip was shot using a DVX100ae (PAL) on cinemode (progressive) 25P, f2, 1/60
The second shot was using a PD170 (PAL, interlaced, 25i, ~f2 1/60
The second shot was lit using a 150 watt hmi light from the outside with a 1/2ct blue gell and a redhead with a 2ND filter from the inside.
Interestingly, most people got it right.
[/quote]
Hey guys, the contest has been over for a while. Readw already let us know which is which
[quote author=readw link=board=Clips;num=1104154995;start=15#23 date=12/28/04 at 14:09:37]The first shot which had almost 3kw of light in the setup has some movement but little evidence of interlace lines indicating that it could have been shot using progressive mode. The colouring in the first shoot looks a little more film like and as other people have pointed out not as hard.
The second shot has the blue chroma edge and the hardness to the image that gives it that typical video look of the PD170 camera.
The first clip was shot using a DVX100ae (PAL) on cinemode (progressive) 25P, f2, 1/60
The second shot was using a PD170 (PAL, interlaced, 25i, ~f2 1/60
The second shot was lit using a 150 watt hmi light from the outside with a 1/2ct blue gell and a redhead with a 2ND filter from the inside.
Interestingly, most people got it right.
[/quote]
Hey guys, the contest has been over for a while. Readw already let us know which is which
Motherboard
Well-known member
Re: Just a bit of fun... Guess the picture
yeah wich is which????
c'mon
yeah wich is which????
c'mon