Is DVX100B History ??

TimurCivan said:
Are you kidding? high definition footage is far and away the best way to make productions intended for standard def. you shoot HD, edit, CC, Composite, then master in HD. then you down res to SD for DVD distrobution. It will look 10X better than working in a SD only environment. My personal feeling is this. You aquisition medium should be 2x better than your end medium. HD is the natural choice for SD productions, the workslow is similar, and cheaper than Film. If your final product is HD i would say shoot film. if your endproduct is a film release print, shoot anamorphic S35. The post production process can really mush up footage. the higher quality the initial medium is the easier it will be to maintain quality in the end.
That doesn't make any sense, unless the DVX isn't SD resolution, you are still getting a 720x480 (actually SD is 640x480 technically) image. Where it would be helpful to shoot HD is if you want to zoom digitally in post, SD has no room for that. Similarly, Spiderman 3 was shot on film rather than HD because the director wanted to re-frame in post. As it is the DVX down rezes, the CCD is capable of higher resolution as seen with the Andromama modification. I just think that unless you need HD for distribution, it seems like a big hastle at this point.
 
Barry, thanks for fighting the good fight and for the honesty. Please don't inflict any more harm on Jan's eardrums.

Based on the AVC HD camcorders now out, I've wondered if maybe AVC HD isn't quite ready for primetime. Maybe Panasonic is working on it and taking the time to get it right. There may be filmmakers like myself, who'll whine a little about the wait but are very willing to do so if it means a quality camera, with things done right from the start, instead of half-assed, like some of the competition has done. As for CMOS chips, unless there's some breakthrough there, I hope Panasonic doesn't use them. The Panasonic filmlook has a bit of noise as a by-product of that look, and CMOS sensors have noise (and rolling shutter) by nature- sounds like a bad combination to me.

Jan, the news that this camcorder won't fall into your product line is very depressing to me, to the point of questioning if it'll ever be done, or done right. Barry explained how you and Stuart English were responsible for the DVX cam, and how you two had to fight to convince Panasonic Japan just how much filmmakers would love to have such an amazing camera. Anyways, I just wanted to thank you for doing your job so well and for always telling us what's happening at Panasonic. I really do like the way Panasonic tells us what's coming down the pike, far in advance.

Hey Jan, I don't suppose you could smuggle AVC HD in addition to the DVCPRO HD codec onto an HVX200A update, could you? That way it could still be under your control. I'm only half-kidding here.

Thanks.
 
Back
Top