I want all TV motion "enhancements" banned

Ok let me rephrase and state my demands for TV makers. I'm looking at you samsung...

I, Darren, do not want you to alter my TV image, and most people i know, are confused as to why their movies look like soap operas on your TVs. And then I, Darren, have to explain to them what your tru-motion crap is and what it does and that it's the reason movies look like utter garbage on your TVs.

For those of you out of the loop on TV tech, certain tvs, most notably samsungs, have a "feature" which essentially removes the motion blur, rendering movies into absurdity. The average user doesn't know why nor know that they have the ability to turn it off, and samsung has it enabled by default, dug several layers deep into the menu system.

I know this is entirely hyperbole, but im in a ranting state of mind. because it's utterly absurd that billions of dollars are spend yearly to make movies look as they do, as we expect them to, as we enjoy them to(well not all movies but you get the idea), only to have TV sets everywhere entirely change what it looks like.

If you have no idea what i'm talking about, just go to a best buy or other tv retailer and just look at thier TVs, chances are you'll see what im talking about right away, especially if they have a movie you know playing. I was at my friends house and the 5th element was on, and it looked practically animated because of the tru-motion.

I know nothing about starting petitions, but if anyone does, let's petition tv makers to stop this nonsense. You could say that it's pointless, but under this pet peeve of a rant is the thought that should any film i work on actually get aired on TV, to dvd, netflix or otherwise, might end up being watched with these "enhancements"

As with the star wars special edition "enhancement", i think this technology should be shelved. Or more reasonably, be defaulted to OFF, not ON.

cheerios
 
Yeah, I go into this in the 24p tute.

It wouldn't be nearly so bad if they weren't shipped with "tru-motion" ON at default. And there are some TVs (LG, life is not so good here) where you can't turn it off.

Have repeated this mini-"conversation" several times:

"I don't know what's wrong with the TV. Something's off."

click-scroll-scroll-click-click-POOF

"WHAT DID YOU DO?? THANK YOU!!!!"
 
Yep, i've had that mini conversation far too many times.

The sad part is though, that more than a few people just don't seem to notice or care, or perhaps think that it's what they're supposed to like because it's a new tv that they just bought and certainly since it's new, whatever the picture looks like is what it's supposed to be... idunno. Just doesn't make sense to me.

I think the idea may have not been intended for anything but sports, but they never figured out how(or never cared to) make it so that it only enables when watching sports.
 
I think the idea may have not been intended for anything but sports, but they never figured out how(or never cared to) make it so that it only enables when watching sports.

the solution would be simple. have it off by default and have a "sports mode button" that you can toggle on and off with the remote.
 
I love how its always buried in the menus. It took me FOREVER to get this off my parents TV.

They finally upgraded to a big HDTV after using a 19" tube TV for YEARS. Once they get the new TV my Mom hates it and continues to watch the old one....until I "fix" it. I don't understand why anyone would want this engaged.
 
I don't understand why anyone would want this engaged.[/QUOTE said:
probably because most of us wouldn't buy into the 3D crap and they're trying whatever else they can to get us to buy newer "better" tvs
 
Yep, had this discussion numerous times. Uga has the best suggestion above. A sports button.
 
I kick myself in the rear for not double checking my LG tv that I bought last year - 120hz just isn't my jam, and literally NO options to turn it off that I've found. unfortunately I'm getting used to it in the sense that I don't notice it as much as I used to. Great image, but that added 'realism' just annoys the bejebus out of me.
 
Back
Top