HDSLR: GH6: why is ProRes 3840 x 2160 impossible?

FoxAdriano

Well-known member
Hi,
with my GH6 I would like to record in ProRes 16:9 3840 x 2160 without crop, but it actually seems incredible, there is no such possibility with GH6.Why is it possible in 5728x3024 but not in 3840 x 2160?
Thanks for some info.
 
The main reason is because ProRes at 4K and HD resolutions isn't necessary. Nobody in their right mind would use ProRes on the GH6 because the other 10-bit 4:2:2 Intraframe codecs on the camera offer the same level quality, and same ease of editing, at a fraction of the bit rate of ProRes. ProRes is an inefficient outdated codec for acquisition. But if you really have your heart set on 4K ProRes you will get your wish:

"Panasonic has already announced that a future firmware update will allow users to record in ProRes with lower resolutions, including Cinema 4K and FHD."
 
Thanks for your reply.
I agree with you on everything but ... today I did some tests with both ProRes V-Log at 5728x3024 and also V-Log 3840 x 2160 H.265 MOV files. The result is incredibly better with the ProRes shots. Much much much better, without enlarging the image. Why GH6 doesn't have the option to shoot 5728x3024 with H.256 MOV? If you need a better video, you must use ProRes, even if I don't like it. Anyway if ProRes is an obsolete codec and if H.265 gives the same results, why does Panasonic include ProRes at lower definitions? I would have preferred it to raise the definition shooting with H.265 MOV.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your reply.
I agree with you on everything but ... today I did some tests with both ProRes V-Log at 5728x3024 and also V-Log 3840 x 2160 H.265 MOV files.
Just to be clear, I never suggested using an H.265 codec. The camera has better codecs.

Even though I'm not a fan of H.265, I'd love to see your side-by-side testing that shows ProRes is "much much much better". I'm skeptical. Please upload about 10-20 seconds of original ungraded ProsRes and H.265 footage of the same scene and let us judge for ourselves.

I can give you a link to my Hightail account if you don't have a method of your own to upload original, ungraded, footage.
 
Last edited:
If you think it's appropriate, I'll send you 2 files. But how can you say that there is no big difference if one file was shot at 5728x3024 and the other at 3840 x 2160? That's what I mean. Otherwise, what's the point of putting 5728x3024 in the Menu if the difference is minimal?
I'd be curious to know which codec is better than H.265, since it is a modern codec.
 
Last edited:
If you think it's appropriate, I'll send you 2 files. But how can you say that there is no big difference if one file was shot at 5728x3024 and the other at 3840 x 2160? That's what I mean. Otherwise, what's the point of putting 5728x3024 in the Menu if the difference is minimal?
I'd be curious to know which codec is better than H.265, since it is a modern codec.
When you said "The result is incredibly better with the ProRes shots. Much much much better, without enlarging the image." That certainly sounded like you are talking about overall picture quality and not frame size -- and then attributing that difference to ProRes vs. H.265. If that was not your intent, then your need to take care to express yourself more clearly. I don't know anyone, other than you, who would describe 5728x3024 as being "Much much much better" than 3840x2160. Most monitors couldn't even show the difference between those two resolutions.

Obviousy, 5728x3024 is a little higher resolution, but that is entirely different than image quality,which is what you implied. ProRes has nothing to do wth it. It is a little like saying a 8"x10" photo looks "Much much much better," than a 5"x7" photo. Nobody would say that.

The purpose of H.265 is to use a lot of compression to keep file sizes smaller. Period. It is not a necessarily a better-looking codec than other other codecs. It just more efficient. In other words, it just saves storage space and also provides more efficient streaming at comparable bit rates. Unless you care about file size, there is no reason to choose a H.265 codec as an acquistion codec for shooting. In fact, a lot of older computers and hardware will really struggle to playback H.265 smoothly.

ProRes or XAVC-I (H.264) are far better choices unless you really have a need to cram as much footage onto a memory card as you can. And in that case, I'd suggest buying more memory cards. They are cheap.
 
I would like to tell you that I only make documentaries about indigenous peoples around the world. I like shooting and being in the field. I have had a camera since I was 18. Now I am old and I don't like studying. ;) I can't stand theoretical technique, I like working with the camera, even if I understand that you need to know the technique to make better videos. I only know the basics. But I'm happy with that. So even my tests are all empirical. jejejeje
Now I'll send you the 2 files. Look at the difference.
https://we.tl/t-znlkPsuS19
 
1) Your file won't open for me.
2) Compressed files are not original files.
2) If your comparison is only about resolution, I don't care anyway.
 
OK. In the ProRes clip you can see a much sharper picture, with better chromatism and more three-dimensional and therefore more real.
 
Hi,
with my GH6 I would like to record in ProRes 16:9 3840 x 2160 without crop, but it actually seems incredible, there is no such possibility with GH6.Why is it possible in 5728x3024 but not in 3840 x 2160?
Thanks for some info.
For some reason, most of the high-quality record settings in the GH6 (and the G9m2 and probably the GH7) set the aspect ratio to 17:9, instead of the usual 16:9 for standard 4K. At 4K resolution, a 16:9 aspect ratio has a resolution of 3840 x 2160. However, once you go to an aspect ratio of 17:9 at 4K, the resolution is 4096 x 2160. I agree... it's a little annoying. I shoot a lot at those higher quality settings, but always output 3840 x 2160, so I just zoom in slightly on each clip in my editing software (DaVinci Resolve) -- the exact zoom factor is 1.07. That eliminates the two thin black bars at the top/bottom of the screen and leaves me with 3840 x 2160 pixels on the screen. Yes, it is a little pain, but I've gotten used to it. Like you, I wish that Panasonic would give us a few higher-quality settings that are standard 4K (3840 x 2160). What would be outstanding is if they allowed us to use a custom setting to set our preferred codec and resolution. THAT would be nice!
 
BobKo,
I hope you can satisfy my curiosity:
can you actually see better video quality by shooting in 4096 x 2160 and exporting in 3840 x 2160, vs recording and exporting at 3840 x 2160?
Please, could you tell me what exact setting you are using?
Thanks for your thoughts?
 
BobKo,
I hope you can satisfy my curiosity:
can you actually see better video quality by shooting in 4096 x 2160 and exporting in 3840 x 2160, vs recording and exporting at 3840 x 2160?
Please, could you tell me what exact setting you are using?
Thanks for your thoughts?
I can answer that question because I shoot 4096x2160 (also called DCI 4K) all the time with my F55 and then crop down to 3840x2160 in post when I export. If BobKo is doing it correctly, there is no quality difference at all. All you are doing in post is cropping off 128 pixels from each side of the picture. The remaining 3840 pixels that are leftover are completely unchanged.

Imagine if you take a 8"x10" printed photo and use scissors to cut a half-inch off from each side of the photo. The remaining photo is EXACTLY the same quality as it was before cutting -- except shorter on the sides. It is no different with video if you do it right.
 
I can answer that question because I shoot 4096x2160 (also called DCI 4K) all the time with my F55 and then crop down to 3840x2160 in post when I export. If BobKo is doing it correctly, there is no quality difference at all. All you are doing in post is cropping off 128 pixels from each side of the picture. The remaining 3840 pixels that are leftover are completely unchanged.
Yes, as far as I can tell, that is correct. As I said, I zoom in slightly (easy to do in Premiere and Resolve) and it becomes a standard 4K image: 3840 x 2160.
 
Adriano, like Bobko I shoot 17x9 with my GH6 to edit in a 1920x1080 or 3840x2160 timeline in Resolve. That is shoot either C4K or "6K " depending in what I want for that project. I like to crop in to frame in the edit so even if I want to use as much as possible 17x9 allows room to move side to side and with "6K " even crop in as well. The quality you get will be more dependent on how you expose the image than the codec you use from the available list, especially if you shoot Vlog. The codec will have an outcome on file size and how well your computer can deal with decode during editing. ProRes or All-i codecs will be easier on the computer but will result in larger file sizes and also need faster drives in your computer to edit. I cannot see any difference on my system to h265 so do not use them. Shooting high quality Vlog 422,10bit will give you the greatest apportunity in editing to correct or get extreme artistic changes. If you get the exposure correct in the first place you do not need this flexibility. Almost all the choices in the GH6 are 10bit so ample flexibility in post. I assume you still use EDIUS which is not as flexible as Resolve in dealing with transforming colour spaces like Vlog to rec709 or to HDR. Also unless you have a modern Intel PC with QS, decode of 10bit 4:2:2 h264 or h265 is an issue for both Resolve and EDIUS. I do not think there is a large difference between any of the codec choices on the GH6 and it is more dependent on storage for camera originals and the editing PC. My choice is mainly 5760x2880@60P 300Mbps Linear PCM audio h265 Vlog to the CFexpress card since that allows me to shoot for several hours without filling card and gives me max flexibility for editing. Downside was Edius could not edit this at all on my PC so moved to Resolve which did, slowly and eventually bought a M1 Studio Max because of its hardware decode and encode my first Apple product !! Can now edit on both Mac and PC as needed since project formats are the same so just move between them as convenient for other actions.
 
My choice is mainly 5760x2880@60P 300Mbps Linear PCM audio h265 Vlog to the CFexpress card since that allows me to shoot for several hours without filling card and gives me max flexibility for editing.
Ron,
I read with interest your answer. But shooting at 5760x2880 H.265, you will not get a 4:2:2 but only 4:2:0 file, so that file is not very manageable in post production, even if you shoot in V-Log.
However, it seems to me that shooting the at 5760x2880 or C4K instead of 3840x2160 just lets you to move the file up and down in the editing to better frame the scene, but If that were the case, you would lose the wide angle which is important in video..... or maybe I'm misinterpreting your words.
 
Last edited:
Adriano. The lens you use will decide how wide the shot is taken 17x9 is just the aspect ratio of the image that is recorded. Yes 4:2:2 will give you more colour information to grade with but 10 bit is more important if you get the exposure correct in the first place. 4:2:2 is important if you want to make extreme changes in grading for a particular "look" for a film for instance. Not sure this is what you do as my understanding is yours is more a documentary so as close to the real thing as possible. So accurate exposure is more important when you shoot. Almost all delivery formats are 4:2:0 so if you do not need any corrections you have lost nothing. Yes of course if you can shoot 4:2:2 10bit its great but not sure necessary. So for me you need the least equipment to carry, small lens selection, mainly zooms to frame shots,small file sizes so you do not need lots of cards, you can use large CFExpress B, Shoot high resolution so that you can crop in editing to get the framing you want. That is how I use my GH6 if I do not need to crop the editing software will use that extra resolution to downscale. Which is how the camera gets the various resolutions in camera anyway.
 
Back
Top