Final Cut Pro 7 --> Wishlist

filmguy123

Veteran
- New text/titler built into interface. Adobe Premiere's blows doors on the Final Cut titler that is built in, but Adobe's lack keyframing of most text effects. Also, rework and incorporate Livetype's capability + templates directly into the FCP titling interface, plus templates similiar to Adobe's.

- Better retiming controls. Option to turn on/off ripple editing when changing the speed on a clip. A time stretch tool, where you simply grab one end of the clip and drag it's new length (also seen in Adobe).

- Native MXF support and file handling. Ability to edit directly off P2 cards. (also seen in Adobe).


- Support for consumer camcorder direct to digital formats (this should be included in iMovie anyway, and transfered over to Final Cut Pro, even though this isn't their market). However, it is their market - pros use all kinds of tools, even cheap cameras for dangerous shots.

- Ability to add more labels or "keywords" to clips. Similiar to iPhoto for sorting photos. Then, the ability to create "smart bins" where it would auto filter these results. For example, I want to label clips for a sports highlight as "defense" "offense" + "good take" or "best take" + "66" or "13" for player jersey numbers.

- Option to create a new media file from a clip in the canvas. What I mean is, lets say you have captured an entire 60 minute tape and as one giant .AVI file. Or even on a smaller scale, you have a 5 minute clip with 15 distinct different clips that you may use in a video. In the canvas, you could have placed these all as seperate clips with different in/out points marked... however, they all still link back to the same massive media file. It would be great to have an option to "extract clip to seperate media file" or something, so that you physically get a copy of this particular clip, with its current in/out points (and probably some handles) as a totally seperate media file. This would allow for resorting it into bins and applying labels in different bins, especially as mentioned in the point above. Further, it would help when it comes to applying effects such as "smooth cam" - rather than analyze the whole media file just for a six second snippet, the canvas clip could be its own seperate file.



------------------------------------------------------------------

OH - if any of these things, or things someone else mentions, are already present, please share, and how to do them!
 
- keyframeable time changes. Ie, simply add a keyframe to make a clip go from 100% to 50% and interpolate the speed change, hold at 50%, and then back to 100%. Ability to select easy in and easy out on these curves.

- Spotlight search added to the project manager, while maintaining the standard search (and adding new functionality, as detailed before).
 
I don´t think its possible right now, so here it goes:

hold n to snap to beginning of clip, hold shift n to snap to end of clip (like in AVID)
 
- Support for consumer camcorder direct to digital formats (this should be included in iMovie anyway, and transfered over to Final Cut Pro, even though this isn't their market). However, it is their market - pros use all kinds of tools, even cheap cameras for dangerous shots.
I'm assuming you mean native support as opposed to the current transcode-to-ProRes support?

- Ability to add more labels or "keywords" to clips. Similiar to iPhoto for sorting photos. Then, the ability to create "smart bins" where it would auto filter these results. For example, I want to label clips for a sports highlight as "defense" "offense" + "good take" or "best take" + "66" or "13" for player jersey numbers.
Maybe we'll see some tech from Final Cut Server bleed into FCP kinda like how stuff from Shake bled into FCP and Motion. Of course that wasn't until after they killed off Shake so maybe not...

A work around, and you may already be doing this, is to add those descriptors in a comments column then do a "find all" for a specific descriptor then drag all the found clips into the correct bin. It's not automated, but it'll work.


- Option to create a new media file from a clip in the canvas. What I mean is, lets say you have captured an entire 60 minute tape and as one giant .AVI file. Or even on a smaller scale, you have a 5 minute clip with 15 distinct different clips that you may use in a video. In the canvas, you could have placed these all as seperate clips with different in/out points marked... however, they all still link back to the same massive media file. It would be great to have an option to "extract clip to seperate media file" or something, so that you physically get a copy of this particular clip, with its current in/out points (and probably some handles) as a totally seperate media file. This would allow for resorting it into bins and applying labels in different bins, especially as mentioned in the point above. Further, it would help when it comes to applying effects such as "smooth cam" - rather than analyze the whole media file just for a six second snippet, the canvas clip could be its own seperate file.
I'm not at my machine right now but you can do this right. If you make sub-clips then use the Media Manager to make copies you'll have independent clips w/no generation loss and they correct timecode.

-A
 
- New text/titler built into interface. Adobe Premiere's blows doors on the Final Cut titler that is built in, but Adobe's lack keyframing of most text effects. Also, rework and incorporate Livetype's capability + templates directly into the FCP titling interface, plus templates similiar to Adobe's.

!

You can apply motion, scaling, filters and transiton to the titles in Premiere Pro with key framing for all the effect. You may want to click the link below. There is some good info about FCS and CS3.

http://forums.creativecow.net/readpost/8/977306
 
I'm assuming you mean native support as opposed to the current transcode-to-ProRes support?

Yes, I mean native :) And actually, one of the cameras I tried to use, I couldn't even use the prores, I had to use MPEGstreamclip first to get the file format right.

I'm not at my machine right now but you can do this right. If you make sub-clips then use the Media Manager to make copies you'll have independent clips w/no generation loss and they correct timecode.

OOoooh.... I've been trying to do this and figure it out, but have failed... when you get to your machine, would you mind posting up instructions of how to do this? That would be GREAT!

You can apply motion, scaling, filters and transiton to the titles in Premiere Pro with key framing for all the effect.

Oh yeah, I'm aware of that, I meant *all* properties, like kerning, tracking, increasing shadow strength, changing colors, etc. Like to edit the properties of everything in the text editor. Right now, you can only make the text, and then once you have the file on the time line, apply the same filters you would to any other clips (motion, scaling, filters, etc.)
 
I hear ya. I admit you would not have 100% control of all the titles properties but you can add the shadow effect and use the color correction effect to get some wild looking titles and add depth.
 
OOoooh.... I've been trying to do this and figure it out, but have failed... when you get to your machine, would you mind posting up instructions of how to do this? That would be GREAT!
Sub-clip out your footage, select all the sub-clips then hit "media manager". You'll want to select "copy", "delete unused media from selected items" and "existing file names" then just pick a place to save it and you should be good to go.


Better media management and better integration w/o other apps in the suite would be near the top of my list. I can't think of any new features I really want off the to of my head, but more refinement of the current features would be nice. As the saying goes, amateurs practice until they get it right. Professionals practice until they never get it wrong. FCP still has some practicing left to do.:cheesy:

-A
 
They would do well with a feature that allows you to flip 35mm adapter footage over as you capture it which will do away with the tedious rotate n' render thing. Also Id quite like to see Bruce The Wonder Yak more often.
 
Full metadata support like in CatDV. I would like to be able to view and edit all of the metadata and be able to export as an xml.
 
When you change a clip speed (faster speed) the following clips shouldn't change position.

REAL TIME CORE AUDIO MIXING WITH AU GUI


.
 
When you change a clip speed (faster speed) the following clips shouldn't change position.


Couldn't agree more... I had this on my list as all (non-ripple time changes)... PLEASE APPLE! *And* a time-rate stretch tool, seen in CS3, where you just grab the end of a clip (or begging), and drag to change speed to new length (rather than changing in-out point)... amazing tool!
 
I want FCP to be able to use a decent amount of my 4-cores' processing power... I've never seen it go over about 175%

I want some titling tools that allow different fonts/sizes in each block, but are less powerful and cumbersome than Boris Title3D

I want a single keystroke for "Export->Using Quicktime Conversion->Still Image"

And, again... I want linked muting/soloing of stereo pairs!

(and native P2 support, of course!)
 
i want to be able to keyframe filters (correct me if this is currently possible)
being able to keyframe a blur or something like that would be nice
 
Ok again as we did for the 5 to 6 version:

- BACKGROUND RENDERING !!!! 8 cores and no rendering?????
- Yes, Metadata and MXF support straight into timeline and Browser
- Much better Find especially on the Timeline
- Ability to Select WHICH filter to Copy or Paste when using Properties functions
- If you want to Label a clip on the Timeline it does ONLY color that portion of the Clip not all

Then there will be many but I'll be happy with this ones by now.....since I asked in the 5 to 6 wish list....
 
Back
Top