Barry_Green
Moderator
We are constantly evaluating the fests and the voting system in order to ensure complete fairness. We have changed the way voting works before, and if/when we feel that it needs to be adjusted again, we will do so.On the other hand, I don't like the idea of the voting being a popularity contest. If the films were anonymous and everyone would just have to vote purely on which one was best we would probably get a much better sense of which one was a better film.
As for a "popularity" contest -- a massive thread probably means that many people will be AWARE of the film, and that they will WATCH the film, but that doesn' mean they'll vote for it! Pre-voting hype is fun and all, but once viewing opens and people start commenting on the films, we usually see the popularity of certain films' threads skyrocket -- the better the film is, the more likely people are to go in and comment, which makes the thread more popular, which raises awareness, which gets people to watch and vote, and basically the whole thing takes care of itself.
It's like this: Hollywood hypes the living snot out of many films, and they do so in order to get a big opening weekend. But once Friday night hits, the reviews are out. And while some might be swayed to go see a movie by a film's ads, lots of people are swayed by the reviews as to whether to go see it or not. And ultimately, people go on IMDB and vote how they felt about a film based on whether they liked it or not.