Empire - Lawrie Brewster - New Age Film

The Power of Film?

Yes the power of film - and yes i should warn you this is again one of these long rambling semi essay like waffles - that I do oft in between cups of black coffee and my editing.

As artists, (yes including even the most determinately entrepenerial minded American :P) it's worth to consider the power our films can have, (or don't have) and the power and influence the moving image can have (be that on the individual for the bourgeoisie or society for the socialist ;)

We are perhaps more immediately familiar with this concept through photography - there are indeligble images that are kind of printed on our minds.

Due to my macabre nature (and to follow the theme of our film Empire) we'll look at the power of those images expressing what i suppose you could call the cruely, or aft consequences of mankind.

We're familiar with the photography of the holocaust, of skeletal frames hanging on wire fences, piles of bodies and so on. Likewise images of war and mayhem, the famous mid death photograph of the vietcong executed by a South Vietnamese officer etc. Even the photography of prison abuses in Iraq too have in popular culture, like all those other examples helped foster political and historical impression.

For those who don't read history, and even for those who do, we can only see the past, as illustrated - and while our dissociation is easy with the pre-photographic history, we are far more impressionable to percieve eras and events where there is photography.

Let's take my film, there is no photography, and the era was mostly conceptualised in visual arm through neo-classical semi romantic art forms (which kind of continued until events like the American Civil war brought both commissioned art and emerging photography to a painful and horrifying comparison (and reality check) for normal folks.

Artists incidentally were no less efficient at capturing atrocity when allowed too...

A fine example would be Francisco Goya, an artist who sketched a famous series of drawings based on incidents, things he saw etc (the collection of pictures is called 'Disasters of War'

They can be seen here (and are graphic)
http://www.napoleonguide.com/goyaind.htm

Or a more famous oil painting produced later based on one of his sketches.

goya.jpg


Which is a little less glorious than say Napoleon Crossing the Alp!

David-Napoleon.png



Now painters like filmmakers faced similar challenges when they might actually have the unbelievably rare opportunity to paint something they wanted (instead of a commissioning master) and if it related to something like war, tragedy etc, how do you express it? As we know, in war there are acts of heroism? If your a suburban middle class American you just know it will consist of a mini back garden epic of you and your friends taking down Saddam (if your a Brit its still taking down Hitler haha) and if your Scottish like me its probably taking down the tax man but still! Annnyway!

But when we focus on one aspect the fact that it is plausible to exclude all elements bar the ones we want to express (say the story of a heroic soldier saving his injured buddy... (i mean it must be good its worked since they published The Odyssey... doesnt necessarily make the story plausible or complete anymore or does it?

Right let me clarify - because we can focus on say the valour of a guy saving his mate on the battlefield, and if we tell that in a romantic heroic kind of way, then while its plausible that there is nothing else in the events of the story but these heroic concepts do we still do ourselves and the viewer a disservice with romantic simplification of things like war?

Now you see I love films like Kelly's Heroes (a subverive hippietastic take on ww2 thanks to Donald Sutherland.) but its a cynical film - tongue in cheek... what about John Wayne's Green Beret? Or *cough cough* We Were Soldiers or if you can really stomach it - The Patriot or if your some kind of satanic demon then yes... Pearl Harbour!

Now you see crap though some of them are (your allowed to disagree and be wrong) hehe :P thats fine because there is a mass market for big explosions and bombastic scores coinciding with heroic one liners. What about the indy?

What about you?

I know this is rambling - its the way i roll hehe. The power of these films are to 'entertain' while using simplified and comical depictions of war to numb any kind of intellectual response or cost in reality of those conflcits. (Take the doodlebug raid at the end of pearl harbour... where the b25s bomb Japan, yet no civilians, any 'humans' are seen hit) while the cagey japs mercilessly gun down Johnny on the airstrip (before Luke skywalker makes 2 zeroes fly into each other.)

Too many filmmakers are happy to thrust themselves into the subjects of war, murder brutality, even attempted rapes and serial killings and soooo on without any intellectual curiousity.

Intellectual Curiousity

That is - what does the filmmaker have to say in his film. Now ive waffled on enough about that before, but the second point is what can a filmmaker say? What is the power at his finger tips. Just as the images i cited before helped capture a generation and era, so can your films have powerful effects on the viewer, (no not the paranoid musings that the terrible liberal media are turning us all gay... well except for my new festival video reviews that will!) No - good and powerful effects that you can have on the viewer, that by having some intellectual curiousity and exploring a purpose in your story... without the defensive dismissal of 'oh its a message movie' and thinking it will be like say Casualty of War...

That in fact one can become a director whose works are far more influential and are encouraging and at the same time are derived from the filmmakers own growing, maturing and inquisitive mind. For the Autuer minded director this is quite useful... but its also useful because there is a hunger I believe for independent film to be that counter balance to pure mass superficiality - and it can do so with business success and within popular genres.

It is admittedly a challenge for those who enjoy the comforts of the so called Western World, lets face it, we have films about who can get laid first, about the horrors of losing a pink ipod or a bachelor party gone wrong (and if its a micro indy then each will feature an airsoft gunshot death and a torture interrogation scene.) Thats fine but it doesnt take that much effort to explore real stories for inspiration, in literature, the news, folk stories, heck even youtube!

In fact just recently with the protests in Iran over their disputed election youtube has waived a rule for violent video content on the basis of journalistic merit. One of the most disturbing videos you will ever see in your life (and will be viewed by millions) has by the merit of its 40 seconds become a beacon for a revolution and probably a symbol for democratic freedom against adversity for decades.

For the curious, the video depicts a beautiful and very brave young woman, who is shot in the chest by an unseen gunman while protesting. She collapses and dies within seconds surrounded by people trying to save her, (the 'Neda' video.)

Now... its horrific, and you may think powerful because its real. Yes it is because its real, but we encounter it not as reality but via the screen (if any of you have seen Videodrome you can imagine what Professor O. Blivion would say.)

Something like...

'the battle for the mind of north america will be fought in the video arena, the television screen is the retina of the minds eye, therefore the television is part of the physical structure of the brain, therefore whatever appears on the television screen emerges as raw experience - therefore television is reality and reality is less than televison.'

If one watches something like the Neda video or any uncensored journalistic recordings of atrocity it does empower ones capibility to understand the nature of visual power, (and in this context horror) but also the ironic opposite. Our blithe accomodation of horror if delivered with punchy one liners and fast beating music.

Because so many filmmakers start out emulating what they like in their fav movies and tv, its worth going back to the drawing board, to be brutal with oneself so that we can understand our own limitations, to be so aware of what we can't stand, that we might be willing to make a film that can change something... a film with the power to change things.

Yes - im afraid there will be a part two to this :) feel free to comment and discuss
 
Last edited:
Look at Nightlight, and Mahlen, and my flick, and your flick.

Mahlen had to send his footage to his 3D Team!

Dont worry. A little bird told me some of the greatest films ever made didnt use any 3D, any mattes etc. Not to detract from the great work and effort people are putting into that aspect in this fest.

Interesting point on the pictorial view of history Lawrie and how it shapes our vision.
 
I read every word Lawrie, not sure if I'm getting it though so here's a few ramblings imo...

Generally movies are an escape from real life. My parents generation grew up during the war.
One a soldier, the other a nurse. Both with very diffrent opinions which reflected in what movies they each enjoyed watching.

For me movies are a stress reliever, plain and simple. Different movies for different moods.
I think most of the 'general' viewing public wants something easy to digest, to escape from real life.

Again, it's hard to avoid the word 'Entertainment.'

Still there's room for truth based films. Schindler's List comes to mind. The story was still told in a way that engaged the audience.
I think it comes back to wanting to escape via movies and other entertainment in general and not be reminded about how brutal we us mankind still really are.

In fact, making a movie focusing on compassion during a war, and even herosim, I would find more enjoyable. To know there is still a measure of humanity and compassion still left in some people during times of conflict would inspire me more than seeing the horror we're capable of.

And maybe that's what your short is about anyways. I'm confusing myself now.

A side note: Shorts, I think, have a lot more freedom of expression
whereas feature films lean more towards returning a profit for investors.
So places like dvxuser are ideal to test ideas. As well as short films in general, imo.

So yeah, I'm really looking forward to it. New ideas, new looks, what's not to like? I just wish I had the vocabulary you have. :beer:
 
Hey Noel thanks and Raptor hey hey! Good to see you here :)

I'll follow on in your comments there Raptor as its great to get a little discussion going, and thanks for reading through! I have a lot of respect for you good sir and appreciate your reply :)

Your right 'popular' mainstream movies, and even what we might term arthouse, and independent films are by their nature an escape from reality, I'd propably be a little metaphysical on this (what - there is no truth etc that kinda thing) and say even those films that depict 'reality' are only onto themselves creating another escape form designed to illicit different feelings/human responses from the audience.

We have interesting instances of what may feel like 'realism' (in this connotation we always imagine the grim though don't we!!!) for example noir, film noir, movies such as Fritz Lang's M for the Weimar Republic, and of course the Noir films of America (perhaps less so the more sensational gangsta movies) but you get the idea.

Your right people who experience war, savagery or economic depression rarely for any remote kind of entertainment want to watch something trying to recreate their unfortunate circumstances. (Unless you the audience to a Berthold Brechte play!) Yeah as we know they more or less rushed to see musicals - comedies etc. Likewise in the Victorian era before cinema, the musical halls etc - the comedy acts etc were probably the opiate of the masses before hehe.

When i think entertainment i dont (and i know you dont or anyone does really) imagine it as mutually exclusive to artistic merit or artistic aspiration. If we look at a Hollywood blockbuster we can easily compare different merits from say,

The Dark Knight vs Batman and Robin :P

This is taking us a bit from the power of imagery i was blethering about (i'll get back to that part two.) But taking that film as a point, and my reference before to intellectual curiousity, i think there in lies the difference.

Chris Nolan had something to say in that film, and did so within the confines of a hollywood budget, execs etc and the film was all the more powerful for it. Now does it have to be something to do with war? lol no (i use that as an example for reference to this film) but if its irrelevant (what one has to say) then often so is the film. That can be superficially entertaining one or twice, but then how much so?

Let's take comedy, Trains Planes and Automobiles had far more to say, far more intellectual curiousity on the part of John Hughes than say Scary Movie? Even those comedies that are hilarious (but seemingly 'dumb') are in fact quite the opposite,

Ace Ventura 2 is a farce drawing from the tradition of comic performance akin to the Renaiscence Commedia Del' Arte (if i can spell that right)

Your right by our basic nature a more 'entertaining' film based on war would be one focussing on compassion. Brechte would call this the classic aristolean story with the 'cathartic' ending, the bourgeiose (forgive typos) happy ending, it sends us home with 'relief' that all is well in the world' and there in we stop thinking.

Its designed to make us feel happy, and thats fine but that also comes with a cost for the discerning filmmaker that doesnt necessarily want to make his audience feel unhappy but may want his point to linger. This is especially important i think for emerging indy's who may want their character, their auteur elements to remain with audiences.

Its far more subtle than to say just have a sad ending (like the somewhat ridiculous Robin Williams vehicle Jacob the Liar.)

Your right of course in your comparison to shorts and features, and their profitability, but then for indy's thats a different ball game altogether.

The classic almighty 'big entertainment' concept doesnt necessarily apply to us, if you get my drift. So i wouldnt say my point is -anti-entertainment pro message, id say that the two are both essential.

That the message is not a political point or anythign specifically ideological, but that it is something the director has to say himself through his story that demonstrates some intellectual curiousity on his part - so that in his story it reflects not only himself or herself discovering something enlightening, but that we too may share that.

Which in the best films occurs, as when Steve Martin takes John Candy into his home at the end of Trains, Planes and Automobiles, or when we learn the inescapable nature (of the far superior Japanese 'Ring' movie.) etc
 
Right a visual cut is locked (ok 2 of the shots arent)

Sound design tomorrow, an edit is getting uploaded for the composers... albeit slowly as hell...

Apparently im getting a day off tonight from this edit to attend a Bohemian dinner party/regular party - and so in true austere fashion i intend to wear colourful (yet tailored) attire and explore the meritous world of homemade cocktails, with which i intend to soon with a special friend too!

Hurrah for cocktails and delights!
 
How was the cocktail party Lawrie, was it as delightful as you hoped, or was the edit of Empire nagging at the back of your mind all evening long?
 
I have to admit that I quite enjoyed your ramblings ;). If I may interject one thought... Within the realm of blockbuster war movies, I find it interesting that so many directors (or producers, or writers... whoever decides on the actual story) choose to oversimplify the plot, without giving the viewer the chance to "digest" the supplied facts. Perhaps the heroic theme dictates a rather common structure of the plot (which after a few movies becomes way too predictable). I guess what I'm trying to say is, if you're going to show violence in your movie, make it count. More and more movies I watch include it merely for the gore and shock.

That is all.
 
Well a bit more shooting here and there - its all coming along and should be done juuuust in time!

Here is a pic - of my mommykins (the producer of fine rolls to feed my crew... of me... and my cast of 4! Yey!

mum.jpg
 
Yes thru the power of technology I'm posting from an airport lounge! Yey so visuals locked, some minor sound fx adjustment and we just add music then voila! This is a dreamlike or nightmarish psychological film that I think and hope u do too, has retained this dark fairytale like vibe! More to come!
 
Well a bit more shooting here and there - its all coming along and should be done juuuust in time!

Here is a pic - of my mommykins (the producer of fine rolls to feed my crew... of me... and my cast of 4! Yey!

mum.jpg

^... I think you just set yourself up for some photoshop fun. :)

Looking forward to checking out your entry! Looks like it was a lot of fun making it. Good luck!
/j
 
Oh my goodness that's hilarious Noel hehe! Ur right Edgen!! I can't even fathom what zaza will do hehe

Thanks zaza I appreciate ur comment I've been very lucky to get this on time in the time! I just wanted to attempt a nightmarish historical fairytale from hell! Ill post workflow after fest if folk are keen!

I shot edited fx'd myself and while that's only impressive if one likes the film I can def say I will be doing a more contemp film next hehe

Edgen ur film looks ambitious and that excites me (well so does zaza's screen grabs haha tho I'm really the girls body double hehe)

Most of all I'm just glad to be a part of this fest!
 
I KNEW I'd seen your Mum somewhere before....it's a little known fact she played the lead in "Oliver"!

1246151284.jpg

"Please sir, may I have some more?"
 
Honestly what can i say to all that!!!!

There are just no words to express lol except WOW!

Lawrie's mum as she's now become popularly known (I'll have to credit her as this for the movie hehe) is now a star of multiple films!!!

I think the Oliver Twist pic is the winner muhahahhaa (though im a big fan of Ben Hur and 300 hehe...)

That is trully the most absurd posts to have hit these film threads!!!!!
 
Back
Top