Elowah Falls with the GH13

Here's my contribution to the fray (as a first time poster here, and obviously I haven't figured out how to imbed the vid directly...)



Shot this morning on a hike in the Columbia River Gorge (in Oregon) trying out the AVCHD "C" settings with 24 native on my GH1. Believe it or not, I only had a (Kodak) 4x card in the camera and it functioned great except for 3 shots (wide angles, lots of detail with a pan or tilt) where it gave me a write error after 15 to 25 seconds of recording. Lenses were Panasonic 20mm f1.7, and Nikon 28mm, 55mm and 180mm. iso 100, 1/50, "smooth" with contrast -2, sharpness -2, the rest at 0/0.
Of course this is smashed down to H.264 720 for Vimeo, (and from an AIC original, no less; I only have Final Cut Express) this "new" footage from the camera is truly astounding.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
WOW! That's incredible! Although, with scenery that beautiful, you could shoot with a VHS and it would look nice. ;-) I only noticed a couple spots, at around 1:55 and 2:25, where it broke up a little. The two close shots of the waterfall. But then a shot like that would probably cause any other camera to explode. Thanks for sharing.
 
Great work - thanks for posting.
:thumbsup:


You're all making me want to run out and get a GH1.... I'm sure I'll cave soon enough.
:)
 
Wow, those are some amazing images. Wish there were places like that where i lived.

One thing, seems to be an issue with your frame rate/pull down method. I see some image jittering.
 
There is a pulldown and it's a bugger, if I export (using QT conversion) at:
29.97, I get a cadence that goes 1,2,3,4,4
23.98 produces 1,2,3,3, (looks horrible) and
59.97 produces 1,1,2,2,2,2,3,3,4,4 which you think would look the same as 29.97, but is actually smoother, but just by a bit.
I'm just grappling to get a 24 frame export that is actually straight 24fps, no introduced frames.
 
Your post says "native 24p" Settings.

So you're using 60i Wrapper > 24p?

That's not native.

Shot this morning on a hike in the Columbia River Gorge (in Oregon) trying out the AVCHD "C" settings with 24 native on my GH1. Believe it or not, I only had a (Kodak) 4x card in the camera and it functioned great except for 3 shots (wide angles, lots of detail with a pan or tilt) where it gave me a write error after 15 to 25 seconds of recording. Lenses were Panasonic 20mm f1.7, and Nikon 28mm, 55mm and 180mm. iso 100, 1/50, "smooth" with contrast -2, sharpness -2, the rest at 0/0. Of course this is smashed down to H.264 720 for Vimeo, (and from an AIC original, no less; I only have Final Cut Express) this "new" footage from the camera is truly astounding.
 
Oh, no this is an issue with exporting from Final Cut only, the vid coming in from the camera is 24p. Unless the transcode into Final Cut is adding frames, which it very well could be, I'm using Express, not Pro...

aaaand just looking at the timeline it appears that although the clips say "24" stepping frame by frame through the timeline shows the 29.97 cadence. hrmph. Probably be a limitation of FCE, no true 24p.
 
Oh, no this is an issue with exporting from Final Cut only, the vid coming in from the camera is 24p. Unless the transcode into Final Cut is adding frames, which it very well could be, I'm using Express, not Pro...

That's really weird. I've never heard of that happening but could be!

If the footage from the camera is 24pN with no pulldown, then there shouldn't be any pulldown issues at all. You should just drop and cut.

Hope ya get that figured out!
 
So for any future reference, I found that importing the 24p mts files directly into After Effects keeps them at 24p, and looks spectacular (how does it do that, no transcoding?) but obviously AE is a lousy program to edit in!

I tried importing the AIC export from FCE into a 24p After Effects comp and some shots ran at exactly 24p, some shots included a repeated "cadence" frame, mystifying. The lesson is don't try to use FCE for this footage!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top