Disappearing Threads

OldCorpse

Rockin the Boat
There was a thread in the Panasonic GH Cameras - GH Hardware, Lenses etc., dealing with a budget speedbooster from Fotodiox. It was about 2-3 pages long, and I contributed to the thread, saying that I just bought that booster, and was going to post my review in that thread, as there was a lot of interest in this kind of hardware. This was just yesterday. Today, I go there, and the thread has disappeared - like, completely. This is frankly appalling. I can understand if the thread is contentious, go ahead and lock it. But to completely disappear it in an Orwellian fashion as if it never even existed, well, that takes the heart out of anyone who wants to contribute content to this site. The whole purpose of this site is to provide a safe place for people to be able to honestly review gear and share experiences, and when a thread to which you contributed and are actively monitoring, simply disappears with no notice, it really makes one feel as if there is no point in the whole thing. Why write anything if it's just going to disappear at any moment, with no notice, with no warning, with no trace of any kind.

I am completely disheartened and disappointed by this action. I guess I won't be reviewing this equipment, and wonder what the point is in any further contributions. This was a very, very bad move indeed. Lock threads, moderate, but don't pull this kind of disappearing stunt, it really puts into question the integrity of the site.
 
Oldcorpse. Appreciate your thoughts here.

The actions of the OP were dishonest and noted by other forum members within the thread (non moderator). The issue we have is that this site is operated through paid advertising. This was a clear attempt to circumvent our forum policy of "no unauthorised advertising". Part of our role is to operate the forum for the benefit of the majority of members and I acknowledge this may upset some from time to time. However on the other side of the coin if there's no benefit to paid advertising why do it? And then wheres the forum?

Hope this clarifies the matter. As a forum member you are welcome to start your own thread and place a review of any product for any company you're not employed at, so please don't let this incident deter you from doing so.
 
Noel, Any chance the original thread's posts still exist? Personally I'd be annoyed at re-typing posts.

Further, I would suggest that it would be a more transparent move from DVXUser's Mods to keep a thread in place & put a notice about why content was deleted / removed.

The two reasons I see for this is that it shows the honest users what happened (w/o having to start a new thread saying WTF?!) and secondly it does some shaming of a vendor that was trying to get around the rules.

Personally I like DVXUser & I want to support the businesses that support the site. Even more, if I know there are some businesses that are trying to be dishonest, then it is a reason for me not to give that business some of my money. (If they can't be trusted with DVXUser rules, can they be trusted with providing a good product?)
 
Agree with both posts above. I was very anxious to see results on this speedbooster clone, and the thread was very telling. I came back specifically looking for it, and found nothing. It has paralyzed discussion on the actual product, not to mention how it portrayed the company. Rather have an explanation by the mods rather than deleting a thread full of decent content.
 
If the thread had been started by someone / not the person from the company, that's workable for sure.

In addition, the persons dishonesty in this case was to circumvent our advertising policy and not to scam people or anything like that so we have no interest in naming and shaming.

Finally I've been over the thread. TO be honest I dont think anything has been paralysed. Just start up a new thread - people will post user experience.
 
I can see the reasoning behind the naming & shaming.

Still, is it possible to leave some sort of notice. "This thread has been deleted due to rule #..., please start new discussion / continue discussion in this thread..."?
 
Back
Top