Cheap IFB

scottfs

Well-known member
Doing some more indie production sound. I want to feed sound wireless to director and scripty. Comtek seems to have cornered the market on this.

Is there a way to feed the output of a Mixpre 6 mkI to a wireless transmitter, send to receiver on director and scripty, then to headphones? I have two Rodelink digital wireless units. Can I split the signal from the line out to a Y splitter, then send the signal to both?
 
The two most popular systems are Comtek and Lectrosonics, but you’re talking about a pretty decent investment ($1400 and $2400, respectively, for a 2-receiver system).

You might be able to use your RØDELink as a cheaper solution, but there are some caveats. I’ve seen people use Sennheiser G3 systems (100-series) as IFB, but the AF output on the receiver is a bit anemic with only rudimentary output control. I’ve found that not to be enough to drive headphones at a reasonable level. Your RØDE may have the same issue. The solution there is to grab a couple of Behringer P2 headphone amps (about $40/ea) and send your receiver into that (requires an XLR output cable). That means having two things clipped to the belt - receiver and headphone amp - but it solves the output and level control issues.

As for output, you can use the MixPre-6’s 3.5mm out, but you need to make sure that the cable is properly wired. Your best bet there is to contact Remote Audio in Nashville, tell them what you are needing to interconnect, and let them come up with the proper custom cable.

If you’re doing more of this work and have the income to justify the investment, there’s no substitute for a proper IFB system. There are a couple alternatives to the Comtek and Lectro systems that can work well, but you aren’t going to spend any less to make it happen. Sennheiser IEM receivers are compatible with their G3/G4 transmitters, offering a solid alternative to Comtek and Lectro. Or, the Sennheiser G4 ew512 systems feature receivers with dedicated headphone outputs (the up/down arrow buttons control headphone volume when not in menu mode) and can work well, too, but again at these price points you might as well get one of the proper systems.
 
As someone who wears a Comtek most of the time, I can tell you that it is critical to be able to get to the volume control quickly and easily, something that may not be as easy on a bespoke wireless receiver. While it might seem rudimentary, remember that a director and script supervisor have their focus elsewhere and fiddling with electronics is not part of that.

Alex's suggestions above are quite thorough but asking a director to wear a headphone amp on top of a receiver with cable between is a bit of a hard sell--sounds messy and bulky.

Whatever you do rig up, I'd make sure to do it in a padded holster with belt clip such as the one Comteks are generally supplied with as they will be dropped, a lot.
 
Agreed. You've got to have a knob on top. If you're really budget minded, a way to go is to get a used G3 transmitter and buy some of these - https://www.aliexpress.com/item/330...earchweb0_0,searchweb201602_,searchweb201603_
They are compatible with the G3. They even look like a G3. They work well. The downside is that they have a limited number of compatible channels, so you won't have as much channel selection as you would like. Also, you will have to build a chart showing which channel on the G3 goes with which channel on the Leicozic. So not nearly as good as the real thing, but the performance is there. If Leicozic made a portable transmitter, this would be a great alternative with full channel compatibility. If you can use the Leicozic base station transmitter, it should by a really nice system. Check Ali Express for all the Leicozic packages. I use this setup for IFB and camera hops. One commercial I did used the audio from the camera hop instead of my F8 files for their final cut and no one complained. It sounded good.

Another way to go is to get used Comtek clones from ebay. A company called Listen Technologies sells them. The reviews I read said they are compatible with Comtek and work as well. I bought some and if Comtek works like Listen, well, I think they're a piece of junk. They have hardly any range at all. I'm still wondering what I'm doing wrong because if they work the way I'm experiencing them, I don't know how they are in business.

Listen Technologies has a portable transmitter, but they don't show up often on ebay - https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...logies.TRS1&_nkw=listen+technologies&_sacat=0
 
Last edited:
You can get 1/8" splitters that will split the same signal to two, three or even five outputs. Each additional output will drop the db, though. Comtek are great because they're actually pretty tough and they operate in the 200 mhz range. So they won't compete with your other wires. That said, I use G4 IEMs which have higher quality and a user-controllable volume knob on top. Plus you can buy additional non-IEM G2/G3/G4 receivers to use as hops that will operate on the same frequencies so no need to split your output. Standard wireless receivers don't really work because they don't have user-controllable volume and would offer pretty weak levels unless you were to add a headphone amp. But you'd have to kludge that together.
 
KISS... Don't try to piecemeal something together just to save a few bucks. It looks unprofessional and will be a pain to deal with for all involved, especially those using it, that need something simple(put headphones on, adjust volume). Heck, I run into people on occasion where just adjusting the volume with a single knob is like a man with no arms trying to swing a hammer to drive a nail. I don't know how many times we've had talent standing in front of the camera and say their IFB is either too loud or not loud enough and instead of adjusting the volume on the box themselves(usually right in front of them on the table or clipped to their waist), the audio guy has to run over and do it.
 
As someone who wears a Comtek most of the time, I can tell you that it is critical to be able to get to the volume control quickly and easily, something that may not be as easy on a bespoke wireless receiver. While it might seem rudimentary, remember that a director and script supervisor have their focus elsewhere and fiddling with electronics is not part of that.

Exactly. And that’s just it: just because you can make it work, doesn’t mean you should. To repeat my earlier statement, there’s no substitute for a proper IFB system.

The Lectro systems sound better than the Comteks. They cost more, too.
The Comtek systems are just as standard and common on sets (if not moreso).
Sennheiser IEM receivers are perfectly acceptable as they do have tactile volume knobs on top. They’ll work with any G3/G4 transmitter.

Anything else is a kludge. Showing up on set with a kludge isn’t a confidence-builder for the director and/or producers. Using other wireless that requires a headphone amp to work properly means keeping up with more stuff. It makes it functional, but it makes it clumsy.
 
Both the Comtek and Listentech systems are available in 72 or 216MHz versions. They are x-compatible but sound is degraded some. I has seen a lot of non-portable base station Listentech Tx on eBay, which is powered by 12V and good for a cart. I had an all Listentech system for a while, which sounded as good as the Comteks, but some of the belt clips broke off the receivers so I got rid of most of them and got more Comtecs.
Right, on just about every movie I work on there is some idiot who states, "I don't hear anything", it either the Rx ain't turned on or the volume is down.,, duh.
 
... Right, on just about every movie I work on there is some idiot who states, "I don't hear anything", it either the Rx ain't turned on or the volume is down.,, duh.

We call those people 'special'. They are found on almost every set.

I've thought about trying the Listen base station for my cart. But that would be spending good money after bad. I like the G3/Leicozic so much better. If I had the money, I'd go with G3 IEMs, but they are selling for about $350 each (used) on ebay vs $45 for the Leicozic. Maybe I'll buy one here and there over time. If I were a full-time sound guy, of course I'd go with what Alex says and buy the good stuff right off.

And so, as we see, if you go cheap, you end up spending even more money than doing it right in the first place. But those are the realities of not having money or not wanting to spend it.
 
Last edited:
I have a bunch of cheap stuff sitting in storage, we have Lectro in our studio because we finally got tired of fooling with the cheaper stuff. The distances that we use them in are very small, but a lot of RF up on the hill where we are.

I've used Comtek in the past, and it worked way back then. There was some older Telex stuff that wasn't too bad, but not sure if it is still around.

I've also used a lot of "licensed" 2 way radios with "mods" done to keep the TX from timing out. I think a lot of this rogue stuff has gone away, but know there i till a few places that use them (legal or otherwise) because you can get massive range and clear channels (until you set up on the output of a BAS relay).
 
Comteks. Shop around and you can find them used for good deals.
It's what people on sets expect and if they are an experienced producer,
director, scripty, they know and are comfortable with Comteks.

The Lectros sound better but the average non sound mixer type person has a tin ear anyway
so buying the Lectros is probably throwing good money after bad.
 
We call those people 'special'. They are found on almost every set.

I've thought about trying the Listen base station for my cart. But that would be spending good money after bad. I like the G3/Leicozic so much better. If I had the money, I'd go with G3 IEMs, but they are selling for about $350 each (used) on ebay vs $45 for the Leicozic. Maybe I'll buy one here and there over time. If I were a full-time sound guy, of course I'd go with what Alex says and buy the good stuff right off.

And so, as we see, if you go cheap, you end up spending even more money than doing it right in the first place. But those are the realities of not having money or not wanting to spend it.

Yup. Not wanting to spend it!

Comtek 2 receiver set is $1400 new. Some folks say you can use use #72 with the new 216 (I think).

I work in Sacramento, fly away from country. 1 hour flight from LA, might as well be Siberia. There are some paid jobs, but there are a couple of almost full time guys who suck up the work. Most jobs pay...nothing (hey! Exposure!)

The Sennheiser IEM is $999 for one transmitter and two receivers. Might go that route. Thanks all.
 
Comteks. Shop around and you can find them used for good deals.

That's what one of my audio guys did. I think he got all, or most, of his off of eBay.

What really sucks, though, is that most people on set that use them, treat them like crap, forget about them and just toss them "wherever". Which is why he probably bought used ones on eBay.
 
I've had Comtek, Listen Tech, and Lectro. Everybody asks for "a Comtek", so you might as well have them. I have a set of Listen Tech because they are very cheap and sound the same as Comtek and use standard AA. They key is to use the full powered base stations with these systems. I know some people manage to get away with adapting one of the small body pack transmitters with the mic input, but I always got terrible range and interference when I tried to put it in my bag. The full size transmitter has balanced inputs and much better range. Buy used.

The Lectros are better in every way and cost more. One nice thing about the Lectros is that you can let your camera hops and IFBs work off the same transmitter if need be.
 
Based on that input, I'll give the Listen base station a try. I had no idea a portable transmitter could be so bad having been used to Sennheiser's performance.

Regarding your comment on Electros, that's why I like using Sennheiser; one common set of equipment for IFB and hops, even if they may have separate feeds, you have one set of inventory.
 
Based on that input, I'll give the Listen base station a try. I had no idea a portable transmitter could be so bad having been used to Sennheiser's performance.

Regarding your comment on Electros, that's why I like using Sennheiser; one common set of equipment for IFB and hops, even if they may have separate feeds, you have one set of inventory.

I've heard of some people just using the standard Sennheiser receiver as an IFB. It is a bit of a pain to change the volume, but they drive a headphone fairly well.
 
I've heard of some people just using the standard Sennheiser receiver as an IFB. It is a bit of a pain to change the volume, but they drive a headphone fairly well.

On standard stereo HPs, the audio would only be on the left side. With the EM100 portable Rx, even at the max AF setting it is anemic unless the Tx sensitivity is set much higher then normal. The more expensive EM-300, 500 and 2000 Rx have a separate HP output as I recall.
 
Yep, even with the transmitter sensitivity turned all the way up and the receiver output turned all the way up, that setup has minimal volume. It's not workable as for me.
 
Based on that input, I'll give the Listen base station a try. I had no idea a portable transmitter could be so bad having been used to Sennheiser's performance. ...

I received the LT-800 today. It's so much better than the portable transmitter. The Listen portable transmitter made the system nearly useless. Now I have two systems; the Listen 216 Mhz and the Sennheiser/Leicozic system. I'll be adding Sennheiser G3 IEMs when I see deals on ebay.
 
Back
Top