Can anybody point to footage which doesn't have the sony look?

Sttratos

Veteran
I'm thinking of moving back to sony. But I really don't like the built in sony look. I know they are sony cameras but I think I got really tired of the sony look when I had my EX1. They all look the same. EX1, EX3, FS100, FS700, F3. I like the features of the FS700 or F3. But I must be able to get a different look. Can anybody point to FS700 or also F3 footage which has not the sony look? Better if it is a movie or drama and not sports, corporate or documentaries.
 
Sorry, this is sports, but I tried to make the FS700 look more like my 5D3: https://vimeo.com/58075075
Skin tones aren't great (and was using kit lens- worked well for this application though), but the FS700 has a lot of settings that can be tweaked.
You'll need to log in to see these images: http://cinema5d.com/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=45529&start=20
Compared to 5D3, looks decent to me color / detail wise, especially in super low light (1 candle).
Will do some tests side-by-side with the 5D3 and see what it takes to match the FS700 to the 5D3.
 
Sony doesn't use such heavy-handed processing as Canon does (that makes green a bit less green than it really is and red a bit more red), so Sony has this more "down to earth" quality. It's more realistic. You will have an easier time matching Sony cameras to other ones as they tend to calibrate them quite neutrally (except their consumer line). The downside to this is that the images don't "pop" like Canon cams do colorwise.

Canon cams have quite a lot of color science going on between the sensor and the output. Read more about it here:

http://provideocoalition.com/aadams/story/color-matching-a-canon-c300-to-an-arri-alexa
 
James_H what I mean by sony look is this yellowish skin tone and everybody’s hair seem to have a red cast or look brownish and lots of red in image like it's dirty with red hues and this harsh look to images too. It looks much like video this sony look. I was told that maybe only F3 can escape the sony look because you need s-log for this.
 
IMO the sony look is a myth, probably caused by the popularity of ex1's. They have a habit of looking over-stabilised and documentary like - something they are more than often used for, where the user doesnt intend on getting a filmic look.

if it is a colour problem making you think 'sony look' then its due to a white balance / grading issue, not the look of sony cams in general.
 
Slog is a very good thing, and i would put the F3/F5/F35/F55/F65 into a seperate class from the FS100/700, and them a step above the EX range

I have expereince with gradeing most of them (no F5/55/65 yet)

your notes re;
yellowish skin tone and everybody’s hair seem to have a red cast or look brownish and lots of red in image like it's dirty with red hues and this harsh look to images

do not reflect my experence with theSlog camera's, and depending upon camera profiles and IR polution present may be accurate for the FS range on a bad day.. but that's not what i get out of my camera

You mentioned three clips that you liked, can you provide a link to these clips?
 
Slog is a very good thing, and i would put the F3/F5/F35/F55/F65 into a seperate class from the FS100/700, and them a step above the EX range

I have expereince with gradeing most of them (no F5/55/65 yet)

your notes re;


do not reflect my experence with theSlog camera's, and depending upon camera profiles and IR polution present may be accurate for the FS range on a bad day.. but that's not what i get out of my camera

You mentioned three clips that you liked, can you provide a link to these clips?


Where I mentioned?

I never saw a sony clip without sony look. Only from F35.

I was not talking s-log cameras. I was talking cameras without s-log look like video and have sony look. Maybe F3 with s-log has not. F35 has not but is because its a expensive camera probably.
 
http://vimeo.com/48711717

Here's some un-graded dailies from a music vid. I shot with an FS700 a while ago. I've shot a ton of stuff lately, but haven't posted yet. This is nothing fancy, just used Cinegamma 1 with a few minor tweaks. The only part I don't like is the outdoor part with the couple. I used a gold reflector and it caused a yellowish look to the skin. I now only use the silver for the most part, especially outdoors.

Personally, I really like the image from the FS700 when NOT using the stock profiles. Coming from Canon, I am really happy to not have that baked in Canon look where everything is really warm and it looks graded right out of the camera. Sony's colors look much more like how the scene really looks whereas Canon is a stylized version of everything.

I do notice with the FS700, you have to shoot more towards the wide open spectrum otherwise everything is really sharp and can look video-ish. I generally shoot between f2 to f5.6 (sometimes f1.4) and I really like it.

I also tend to turn the sharpness down to -4 and transcode with 5DtoRGB on Full Range. AVCHD and quicktime does not play nice together which results in loss of DR. 5DtoRGB on Full Range has NO effect on my Canon 60D footage, but definitely changes AVCHD footage very noticeably.
 
Last edited:
I have an FS700 and struggle to get that 'film' look. Most things i've tried in post are adding grain and wider aspect, but these don't really do the trick. Shooting wide open helps but then you loose a lot of sharpness. I'd love to be able to figure out a recipie! James Vernon's stuff seems pretty good https://vimeo.com/jamesvernonfilms
 
James Vernon's stuff is amazing. Shows that it's not the camera. Also, James really takes advantage of the Slow Motion and uses it well and gets a feeling you simply cannot achieve with the C300, C100 or other DSLRs because they don't really have slow motion.

Here's something in progress that is almost done. We have to reshoot 1 shot and a few creative directions. But I think it looks pretty good and not video IMO.

http://www.builtbyugene.com/mov_clients2/hilow01/HILOW_MainComp_0304b.mov

Good luck in your camera quest.
 


https://vimeo.com/58574828


Here's a piece I just finished with a very light grade - more of a bleak, low contrast look - I actually like that about the Sony Nex cameras. They seem to be able to achieve a lower contrast look naively than most of the low-mid priced Panasonic and Canon.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top