"C" settings footage - am I shooting wrong?

danielisaiah

Active member
"C" settings
1080 / 24p
50 shutter
kit lens
slight CC
GOP 12



I don't know guys. I guess I'm a little frustrated. I'm seeing a lack of clairity in motion shoots. What is the difference between us (GH13 users) shooting 24 fps and a director shooting a major motion picture at 24p? is it the film medium? when panning.....even at slow and moderate speeds, (especially at whipped pans) the picture seems to just break down. There is a a lot of "strobing" or "studdering" if you will. I asked a couple friends to watch the video and they see it as well. it almost feels like there is duped frames or even frame dropping going on. Ive included some links to some trailers....some with quite a bit of movement. There is a smoothness that just isn't there.....even with this amazing hack. I dont know. am I doing something wrong?
:violin:

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/fox/knightandday/ (watch beach scene)

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/independent/valhallarising/

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/lions_gate/theexpendables/ (trailer 1)
 
Last edited:
You gotta get that thing on a tripod and pan nice and slow. The hack didn't make it a handheld camera imo. I see all kinds of people waving it around but you wouldn't shoot like that with these things if you want that smooth feel.

I thought it looked good by the way. I see where it does that moving quickly over the horizon. Before it would have just looked like a muddy mess. Put that on a tripod and do it again and you should see a much better result.
 
Last edited:
it's you

it's you

You must be coming for the 30p world of video, like me, all 24p stuff looks 'stepped', especially in the theater. Drives me nuts, but that's what the film guys love. It is everywhere. You'll get used to it at some point, I'm told. Still, my clients prefer 30p. Your stuff looks great! I bought and sold my GH1 last fall, well before the hack. Just ordered a new one with the Hot Rod PL mount. I cannot wait to get my hands on it. Love the ergonomics and settings of that camera so much more than the Canons (I have them all). Keep shooting and posting and watching. I can't believe this stuff is coming out of that little GH1 now. Amazing.
 
Yeah it is pretty amazing. Also you can always play with the shutter to see what you think feels and looks right for the subject. Choosing that shutter is aesthetics. There is probably a limit to how high you can push the shutter with the new hack. Might take some tweaking of the hack to find the sweet spot that suits you.
 
I thought it looked good by the way. I see where it does that moving quickly over the horizon. Before it would have just looked like a muddy mess. Put that on a tripod and do it again and you should see a much better result.
To me it seems that studdering is due to rolling shutter effect -- camera is panning fast enough where it starts to become more pronounced, especially when you have sharp geometric lines in the frame (palm shot) . The absence of mud makes it more visible now; it is was there all along, just not the worst offender.

At the heart, this is still a first generation CMOS censor $1,000 cam and no software hack can fix that.
 
"C" settings
1080 / 24p
50 shutter
kit lens
slight CC
GOP 12



I don't know guys. I guess I'm a little frustrated. I'm seeing a lack of clairity in motion shoots. What is the difference between us (GH13 users) shooting 24 fps and a director shooting a major motion picture at 24p? is it the film medium? when panning.....even at slow and moderate speeds, (especially at whipped pans) the picture seems to just break down. There is a a lot of "strobing" or "studdering" if you will. I asked a couple friends to watch the video and they see it as well. it almost feels like there is duped frames or even frame dropping going on. Ive included some links to some trailers....some with quite a bit of movement. There is a smoothness that just isn't there.....even with this amazing hack. I dont know. am I doing something wrong?
:violin:

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/fox/knightandday/ (watch beach scene)

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/independent/valhallarising/

http://trailers.apple.com/trailers/lions_gate/theexpendables/ (trailer 1)

I liked the video actually, some great shots in there, especially that perfect rack focus off the leaf.

Strobing happens when you pan a bit too fast without a subject to look at.

I'd like to see some people do some tests at 1/30 shutter to see if the motion blur hides the strobing.
 
Hi-

I'm seeing the 24p stutter too (also in my footage) and it looks to me like a cadence issue, playing 24p at 29.97. I don't know if there's a way to change the pulldown to a different scheme that plays smoother, or rendering out at 24 (or 23.98) instead of 29.97, I'm still messing with it myself...
 
It's vimeo / flash fault

If you download the wmv video that was uploaded, it looks fine

EDIT: vimeo converted the file to 30.0 fps , but the uploaded wmv was 23.976 . The vimeo encode has inserted dupe frames
 
Last edited:
@Daniel - can you do a test later to see what happens if you upload to vimeo in a different format than wmv ? e.g. h264/aac in mp4 container
 
Back
Top