Uncompressed HD acquisition is extremely rarely practical for anything else than broadcast and TV stations. Smart and effective compression is the key to success in the future. No doubt about that in my mind. Silicon Imaging and RED are promising projects that hopefully soon will land in hands of average guys like me. Hey, we're talking cost of average cars, not houses here
For now, at least for me, it's too early even for P2. Capacities have to go way up and prices way down to make it practical. Working on the set (not to mention on documentary or hiking in the mountains with camcorder handy), the last thing I want to worry about is technology. Many folks like me still appreciate freedom tape brings. HDV and 63 minutes of recording on $5 media will keep us happy for quite a while
With no hesitation I choose to have more time to master my shots, help the director and make better movie than spend that time taking care of technology and RAID systems on the set. HDV (especially XL-H1) is not bad at all, imo, quite the opposite
If you guys have resources, if you own or can rent hi-tech hi-bandwidth stuff and workflow, good for you and I can't say I don't envy you
but I think good times are coming for all of us. Soon compression technology will be so effective and available very few of us will actually demand anything better. I believe it's question of just a few years, maybe even less, with SI and RED planned to be commercially available in 2007.
For now, at least for me, it's too early even for P2. Capacities have to go way up and prices way down to make it practical. Working on the set (not to mention on documentary or hiking in the mountains with camcorder handy), the last thing I want to worry about is technology. Many folks like me still appreciate freedom tape brings. HDV and 63 minutes of recording on $5 media will keep us happy for quite a while
If you guys have resources, if you own or can rent hi-tech hi-bandwidth stuff and workflow, good for you and I can't say I don't envy you