Better shooting at 50fps or 60fps?

Hi! If you’re shooting video primarily for personal use and your devices can handle 60 Hz, shooting at 60 fps can offer smoother motion, especially for fast-moving scenes. It provides more flexibility for slow-motion effects if you decide to use them later. However, if you’re accustomed to 50 fps and are happy with the results, sticking to 50 fps is perfectly fine. The difference might be subtle, but 60 fps generally provides a bit more fluidity. Ultimately, it’s about what works best for your specific needs and preferences.
Generally, I would agree with what you say re 50/60p fluidity. The thing to be mindful of is if you live in a 50Hz country, most editors will have their monitors running at 50Hz. To avoid running 25/50p material at 60Hz because if you don't, you will be now forcing your video to be frame rate converted by your graphics card or CPU graphics chip to a frame rate that it was not shot in. Never a good idea in a 50Hz environment if you want to assess quality without unnecessary frame rate conversions getting in the way. If my business was in the States or Japan where the mains frequency is 60Hz then I would definitely be shooting, editing and displaying everything in a 60Hz environment. If living in a 50Hz world, likewise. Shoot, edit and display everything for the 50Hz environment where your video is going to be viewed.

Obviously, 24p is a different subject, as 24fps doesn't work smoothly in either a 50 0r 60Hz world. To display 24p material in either of those environments requires pull down techniques to be applied. Another necessary nasty conversion for viewing in the 50/60Hz world, which destroys the cadence of the original filmmaker's objective of shooting at 24p.

Chris Young
 
Many devices (esp Monitors, and "world" TV and STB) now offer the ability to change the Refresh Rate to match that of the Frame Rate of the video. Even Apple's TV Box can do this. That way you can watch all your content at their correct refresh rate. The only devices that don't do this are mobile phones. They all seem to be stuck with a 60hz base (eg 60, 120 etc), but such device are hardly for critical viewing and you are much less likely to notice stuff like pull down issues.
 
Not as many as one would like. Not many domestic displays will play 24p film material correctly. It's not just the frame rate, it's all the other post-processing that goes on with the video stream that can make it look quite different from the way it was shot and intended to look. On many monitors and video displays, if you show 24p material, it generally gets pumped out at 60Hz. Unless, in the case of TVs with Filmmaker Mode where the TV receives embedded data from the file and switches to 24p and applies all the other gamma characteristics that are embedded in the file. But that is not the majority of TVs. How often have I seen 24p Blu-ray being interpreted to 60Hz. Far too often. Finally, for those of us with a bit of a tech background understanding this is not a major issue. For the general viewing public, though, it's a very different story, as most of them don't know or care less as to what is going on under the hood.

It's all a bit of a first world problem really though, isn't it?

Chris Young
 
Yup :) - While, I've selected and setup all my gear (PJ, TV, Monitors) to auto switch refresh rates, I agree... most viewers don't notice and if they do, don't care.
 
Back
Top