Anyone switching from FCP

No, but I have a book somewhere on CC and they jump between color, avid and davinchi. They all seem fairly similar as far as the tools go. The other things davinchi handles I am not so sure about. It's mac and linux only and I have a PC.
 
I'm halfway through my first job with fcpx and I think it's going to be the right tool for me. Like most people I panicked and downloaded a trial version of Premier CS5, but because my graphics card was not up to scratch Premier was very slow. So, back to FCPX.. With help from a Ripple training tutorial and a few days editing I now feel reasonably comfortable with it. Yes, it's very different, but in my opinion it is a very good editing system that suits my type of work to a tee. I shoot digital (XDCAMEX) and output to DVD and the web. I make most of my income from editing, so I want the toolset (FCPX and Motion5) that wil help me get there.

Neil McClure
McClure Multimedia

Same here. FCP and Motion pay my bills. FCPX is different, but IMO the editing part is way ahead of anything else. Now they "only" need to fix the ingest and output plus external hardware issues. That will keep them busy for a while, but in the long run this is the tool that I need as a small production unit; fast, slick and with enough tools to get 80% out of the house. The rest .... probably go DaVinci.
 
Cute cartoon. Though in the real world, some of us were waiting since Final Cut 6 for something to come about. Final Cut 7 was just a minor update. After this mess, "replace everything with Avid" or Adobe is a pretty solid way to go. I hope it works out for people who stick with Apple. I was thinking about leaving long ago, and now this just made that decision so very easy. I replaced everything with Avid and Adobe.
 
So if I replace everything with Avid or Adobe I need to...
- re-learn software
- get new hardware
- adjust my workflow
- going with Avid paying $$$$$

and what exactly is that good for? If i stick with FCP7 and wait for FCP-X to grow up in the next few months, what will such a knee-jerk reaction do me good? Nada. Zip. Dumb.
 
You're going to have to relearn software anyway because FCPX is so different from FCP7. Premier and Avid function primarily like FCP7 so the learning curve shouldn't be as great.

Your hardware will still work with Premiere, and probably with Avid too (there's a 30-day trial for both).

Your workflow will probably be close to the same because Premiere and Avid both import/export XML, EDL, OMF, etc...

How expensive do you think Avid is? The price has dropped dramatically in the last few years, and they even have support for some (limited) third party hardware. It's not a $30,000 system anymore. It's more like a $3,000 system brand new (+computer). Since you own FCP you can get Media Composer for $1,000. If you need OMF, FCPX will cost $800 ($300 for FCPX, $500 for Automatic Duck OMF Export). If third party vendors provide FCP7-FCPX tools and XML import/export the cost will go up. Avid and Premiere may end up the cheaper options, depending on your workflow/needs.

Premiere and Avid both provide robust software that's been proven to work - FCPX is still a gamble at this point. Adobe and Avid make their money from editors, not iStuff. They're dedicated for the long haul - maybe Apple is, maybe they aren't. Something to seriously consider if you make your living doing this.

Premiere and Avid both have more realtime playback and format support then FCP7. While you're still transcoding waiting for Apple to fix FPCX, others will be editing natively and rendering less. If you have clients that become aware of this they'll wonder why they're paying you to transcode when another post house/editor would have been halfway through their edit already.

Times change, software evolves. Whether FCPX works out for you or not, it's probably in your best interest to learn at least Premiere or Avid. If Apple doesn't grow FCPX in the next few months, will will not learning another piece of software do you good? Likely, no.

Then again, FCPX may be the second coming of editing software. Right now - it's not, but time marches on.
 
We each have to make that decision on our own. If you think that fcpx will work for you, then more power to you.

I have found the transition to Premiere CS5.5 seamless.

My mxo 2 already works with it, and so do.most of my plugins.

And unlike fcpro x, i can open up old fcpro projects.
 
With the people who say we're overreacting, that cartoon up above (you don't know what the 'real world' is), that we should 'just wait', FCP 7 still works... I've resigned myself to the fact that you just don't get it and you won't until you want to make the jump to professional editor at a network or a high end post house and, surprise!, we were right that all the places we work cannot wait or trust Apple to put back in all the features they took out. Not to mention, from the places that were even slightly considering waiting or using it, they've said that you can't see the source and the canvas at the same time? Is that true? That and the fact that they there are ZERO work-arounds for a lot of the missing features that are necessary and used on a daily basis. Sticking with FCP 7 is happening and it'll probably be around for about a year during the transition. So yeah... X is a frigging unusable mess in the broadcast world and they need a company who will listen to their needs, not dictate the way things should be done. Sorry, it's a non-starter and everywhere I work that uses it has plans to move on down the road, whether they put the features back in or not.
 
I actually clicked on an Edius email on Monday.


I have been using Edius for 5 years. I love the interface and how fast it is, although it's not very feature rich. I use After Effects for that. If only Edius would get with the times and make the program 64bit (vers. 6 supports it but is not true 64) and also the color from what I understand is an 8 bit instead of 10 bit color system. This is why for years Edius was more realtime friendly than avid, adobe or fcp.
 
I read somewhere Adobe is planning a major campaign to capitalize on the FCPX mixed reception. I would hold of for that to see what they have to offer...
 
I have been using Edius for 5 years. I love the interface and how fast it is, although it's not very feature rich. I use After Effects for that. If only Edius would get with the times and make the program 64bit (vers. 6 supports it but is not true 64) and also the color from what I understand is an 8 bit instead of 10 bit color system. This is why for years Edius was more realtime friendly than avid, adobe or fcp.


There is 10 bit color with 6/6.5 if you use HQX. You can double check on the edius forums.

I use Edius way more than I use Avid or PPro. I have the latest of each. Edius can be used via bootcamp and is definitely worth a try. It's one of the fastest NLE's out there and handles pretty much everything native. It was the first NLE to offer RT AVCHD for instance. Grass Valley (who owns edius) is a world class broadcast hardware/software manufacturer used by many major news organizations.

Only downside for me is they could use more CC tools. I usually bounce over to AVID for that. I would not be surprised to see revamped CC tools in the future, and of course there are plugins...

Edius will also take advantage of sandybridge.
 
Last edited:
I am as most others disappointed with Apple for this non pro version of finalcut x and them canceling further support of the current version. It really feels like a smack in the face after so many studio proffessionals remained so loyal over the years. I myself will be looking at premier pro.

On a side note. Any time a big company like Apple would stoop so low as to erase all the negative user feed back on their site It tells me a lot about the character of the company.

I agree. This was the most telling downgrade after they dropped shake. I wonder if they drop the complete "pro app" section in favour of iphone and ipad and appstore and whatever else is generating their hype. Supposedly the system and user folder are going to be residing in the icloud next and apple wants to earn as bandwidth generator. already iphones are generating 50% of network traffic in australia....
time to hope for alternatives! after 25 years of apple maybe the time has come to say bye bye? I already removed all i-apps from my system years ago and refuse to buy any i-hardware....
 
I agree. This was the most telling downgrade after they dropped shake. I wonder if they drop the complete "pro app" section in favour of iphone and ipad and appstore and whatever else is generating their hype.

This would seem to back you up, methinks:
http://www.apple.com/pro/
...still has an advert for Final Cut Studio 3 - and hasn't had any new stories since 2009

That said, I still think the Mac Pro will be continue to be good. I wrote a post on Reduser detailing why, in fact!

Even if it's "for prosumers"... prosumers are going to need tons of horespower to stabilize their stereo 4K footage and scale it down to their 2048x1536 resolution iPad :P

And we can run our non-Apple editing apps on it nicely. Heck, around version 3 or so, FCP X might even be good!

Avid's FCP 7 -> Media Composer sale for $999 just got extended by the way:

http://community.avid.com/blogs/avi...-to-serve-professionals-is-our-lifeblood.aspx

Bruce Allen
www.boacinema.com
 
As a FCP user, this whole thing felt like a swift kick in the nuts at first. Now after researching, reading others' thoughts, etc... I feel a bit better about the future of things in terms of what I will be using for post production in the coming years.

The question is not whether or not FCPX will evolve, but how much and in which direction? If FCPX really appeals to iMovie users and sales indicate that they should go that route, who is to say that FCPX won't get simpler and future revisions and won't eventually become the replacement for iMovie? Of course, it could be the opposite and FCPX might evolve into a great piece of editing software over the next couple years.

The thing I don't like about this whole mess is that if I want to stick with Apple and FCP as my editor of choice, that I am going to sort of be stuck in an approximately 1-3 year holding pattern. I think 1-3 years is a good estimate as to the time frame during which we will see if Apple wants to continue sticking with the pro-market, or whether they are going to abandon it completely by making FCPX a consumer app and by killing the Mac Pro line.

So while I think it is a bit rash to completely write off FCPX and the future of editing on the Mac platform, I am also looking over at that alternate universe known as PC land, and at their nicely remodeled and affordable neighborhoods of Adobe and Avid, especially Adobe. I know I could work in the Adobe Premiere interface, as I was on Premiere 6.5 through Premiere Pro 2.0 before I switched to FCP 6 in 2007. Then there is the fact that Adobe has tight integration with After Effects and Photoshop, plus other useful programs that come bundled with their production suite. Also, I am impressed with Adobe's interaction with their customer base (Adobe TV compared to Apple's relative silence and disinterest over the past few years) and their commitment to evolving their line of software (which is already sounding darn good) for the professional market. Couple that with the fact that for a fraction of the price of even an entry level Mac Pro, I can buy or build a powerful PC to run Adobe or Avid, as well as using both suites of software on a Mac as well if I wanted to do that.

I love working with FCP and my Mac Pro has been and still is a reliable machine. I just feel like I might be causing myself some problems in the near future by being locked into one type of software for editing, and also by exclusively relying on Apple hardware at this point. So I am not going to switch per say, but I am taking a "best of both worlds" approach. I will keep my Mac Pro and FCP 6 (didn't need to upgrade at the time to FCP 7 and was waiting on FCPX to be the end all be all) while I research Adobe's stuff and start looking into my options on the PC side. Come this fall, if it becomes apparent that Apple is just going to stay silent on FCPX and if there are more signs that they are going to abandon or move farther away from providing professional hardware and software, then I think I will keep running my current Mac Pro and FCP while adding a PC with Adobe's Creative Suite as a second editing station. Then in a couple years, if Apple develops FCPX to the point where it is what I want and need, then I can always get it and another Mac Pro.

Interesting times though. I feel that the post industry, both for high-end professionals and prosumers is at a major crossroads right now. One which won't be a fading image in the rear-view mirror until at least a year from now, and possibly longer than that.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if apple is going to have a certification coarse, so you can be certified to use FCPX like the did with FCP7 ? than we will know if it's a true pro app.

Rob.
 
in premier pro when i razor the end of clip A, beginning of clip B and delete the razored ends of the clips the playhead doesn't snap in between the 2 clips. i like this feature on fcp but cant get it work on premier pro.
 
Back
Top