Anyone switching from FCP

I edited a feature film length project on Red Raw 4k files natively in Premiere CS5 on a VAIO with an i7-720QM processor and 8GB of RAM, with no issue.
 
I like Premiere so far, but I think there's a lot of screen real estate that's taken up by the borders of all the windows. Final Cut allowed you to see a lot of tracks, even on my 21.5" imac and even with waveforms showing at smaller track sizes. Premiere only allows you to downsize to a certain point with wave forms showing. I also like how man tabs you can fit into Final Cut's browser... I option open a lot of bins at the same time and it's easier to switch back and forth with them. Maybe it's just time for a second monitor on the home system.

That said, I tried editing some Red R3D files I found online and it worked fine at lower playback resolutions. I was honestly amazed I could do anything with them after hearing so much about how difficult Red is in post. I'm on an imac with an ATI Radeon 4670, so I've only got the Mercury software engine, but it still seems ok. Just ordered more RAM though. Also tried native editing of files from my T2i and those are ok at 1/4 resolution during playback.

I just don't get it. I'm importing all flavors of codecs, native and transcoded, AVCHD to P2 and canon h.264 into FCPX and they all handle like butter! Even on my Imac 27" I7 w/16 gigs ram (2010) I'm having NO issues with playback at full res. I have also imported 1080/60p and I have not one issues playing them back. Throw all this at an 8 core or 16 core and forget it, easy as pie editing. I throw all these codecs into a single time line and just edit away.
Now, let the FCPX SDK go about and you will see all sorts of support for all the issues the "PROS" are yelling about.
I have FCP7, CS5.5, and now FCPX. I'm going with FCPX hands down! Just give me my multicam and external monitoring via AJA, some of my plugs, and I'm set. And they are coming! All of them! Anybody notice all the deals for CS5? Ummmm......
 
I just don't get it. I'm importing all flavors of codecs, native and transcoded, AVCHD to P2 and canon h.264 into FCPX and they all handle like butter! Even on my Imac 27" I7 w/16 gigs ram (2010) I'm having NO issues with playback at full res. I have also imported 1080/60p and I have not one issues playing them back. Throw all this at an 8 core or 16 core and forget it, easy as pie editing. I throw all these codecs into a single time line and just edit away.
Now, let the FCPX SDK go about and you will see all sorts of support for all the issues the "PROS" are yelling about.
I have FCP7, CS5.5, and now FCPX. I'm going with FCPX hands down! Just give me my multicam and external monitoring via AJA, some of my plugs, and I'm set. And they are coming! All of them! Anybody notice all the deals for CS5? Ummmm......

Amen to that!

Can we please move this thread to the Adobe Premier forum!?
 
Now, let the FCPX SDK go about and you will see all sorts of support for all the issues the "PROS" are yelling about.

Yeah, I want a plugin to display timecode overlays. ?!?!?!?!? It doesn't even do THIS?
 
I put in my order for Media Composer 5.5 and Pro Tools. No more Final Cut. My next step is DaVinci Resolve, and Apple is my past.
 
The "pros"? Look, if I think FCP X is great, I'll be using it at home for sure. But there's just no way that it'll be used, even with a plethora of plugins, at any of the places that I've worked. It can't output to tape, it doesn't do multi-cam and it doesn't let you monitor out. True, all those could and probably will change in future releases, but that's why this is a botched release that will lose many in the time and cost sensitive professional environment. Even if they wanted to stick with FCP 7 while these issues are being resolved they cant because of the possibility that they'll need to add seats. But the biggest deal breaker of all is that with Lion on the horizon, we'd have to have Premiere to open legacy projects. So why even bring in FCP X? Why not just switch to Premiere or expand the Avids? At a few places I've worked, like MTV's 'Made', the editors are pretty evenly split between Final Cut and Avid. I can't imagine things will stay like that for very long, especially since many workstations are leased from places like Postworks and who knows how long they'll hang onto their macs that can run FCP 7. In its current state, I don't think Final Cut is an option anymore and if you had to make the decision, why would you trust Apple after this?

Like I said, for home, sure I'll use it if I like it. And I'll still use FCP 7 where I can, matter of fact I'm using it on two nickelodeon jobs right now. The problem is there's not really a future in FCP for the network and post house market with very little indication that things will change. The reason I opened Premiere is just to make sure I know my way around in case it comes up, which it most certainly will when I least expect it.
 
I ordered Avid Media Composer 5.5 and Pro Tools 9. I am going to get DaVinci Resolve now too.

Is Sorenson Squeeze my best bet to replace Compressor?
 
The SDK does make things interesting. I am wondering if Apple decided to make a really, really good engine and just let 3rd parties "build the car" so to speak and handle the higher-end pro features via SDK (if that's the intention, they really ought to communicate this).
 
Sorenson will get the job done but I disagree with how they make compression presets that you can't adjust or access unless you sign up for their Sorenson 360 service. Plus they had some weird quirks that would crash the program (may have been my system though).

Telestream is awesome. I've played with it a bit and we used it at the TV station I worked at.

Adobe Media Encoder smokes compressor but has some interface quirks that really bother me. I'll be contacting Adobe all week with feature requests. But the quality is good and it's incredibly fast.
 
Hmm. I already own CS5.5, but I haven't gone deep into Media Encoder. I am in a bit of a post-Final Cut transition here. Adobe now means more to mean than the Photoshop, Illustrator, and After Effect combo.

Thanks for the heads up about Sorenson. I will look into Telestream.

For you Resolve folks, I am a bit confused about the Avid-Resolve workflow.

Do I need this for Resolve 8: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/produ...esign_DV_RESOOFTDNX_DaVinci_Resolve_Avid.html
 
Everyone coming from FCPro should at least try Premiere CS 5.5.

Adobe is serious about constantly improving the app, and they know that editors who make their living cutting video want a company who listens to them.

I remember when Premiere was buggy, crashed, and was just wonky.

Those days are gone.

Check it out.
 
I've always had Premiere CS5 sitting around...now I'm giving it a try again. It used to be my editor of choice until I went MAC, but I'm happy to give it another go. The only thing that I hope for in whatever CS6 becomes is a broader support for the playback engine. Lots of MAC people out there with ATI cards which Apple seems to be pretty exclusive on now, particularly their laptops which many pros work on. It would be amazing for the program to take advantage of my MBP's 1GB graphics card. Lots of room for performances boosts if they can figure it out.
 
I'm halfway through my first job with fcpx and I think it's going to be the right tool for me. Like most people I panicked and downloaded a trial version of Premier CS5, but because my graphics card was not up to scratch Premier was very slow. So, back to FCPX.. With help from a Ripple training tutorial and a few days editing I now feel reasonably comfortable with it. Yes, it's very different, but in my opinion it is a very good editing system that suits my type of work to a tee. I shoot digital (XDCAMEX) and output to DVD and the web. I make most of my income from editing, so I want the toolset (FCPX and Motion5) that wil help me get there.

Neil McClure
McClure Multimedia
 
Everyone coming from FCPro should at least try Premiere CS 5.5.

Adobe is serious about constantly improving the app, and they know that editors who make their living cutting video want a company who listens to them.

I remember when Premiere was buggy, crashed, and was just wonky.

Those days are gone.

Check it out.
i ve been playing around with PP cs5 and i cant figure out a few things. one being is when i import the mxf files from the p2 card the spanned clips duplicate which is very annoying.
 
Well, FCP7 still works and will do so for several months until the plugins come to FCPX (i need monitor out via Matrox MXO mostly).
I see no reason to jump ship. After all anything else than FCP7 will need relearning and adjusting, so why not learn FCPX? And from what i saw in the first week with it......it is probably the best editor inused in my 15 years in the business. It just lacks a few drivers and a couple of tools, but on the other hand it offers tremendous advantages to other NLEs already now.
 
He sure put on the kid gloves before that interview.

I find myself agreeing with Frank P from the other page. Almost word for word. Same thoughts and experiences.
 
i ve been playing around with PP cs5 and i cant figure out a few things. one being is when i import the mxf files from the p2 card the spanned clips duplicate which is very annoying.
Use the Media Browser in Premiere Pro CS5/CS5.5 to import your media and you should not see that problem anymore. Media Browser is smart and import long shootings as one clip instead of multiple instances of the same clip.

If Media Browser is not open in the UI, Windows > Media Browser.

I personally did not like nor use Media Browser earlier, but when i discovered how it handles spanned clips and that i don't have duplicate clips i anymore fell in love with it. :)
 
Back
Top