Anyone switching from FCP

. For now though I'm not getting all emotional about the career threatening inadequacies of FCP X and how Apple has slapped me in the face. It is version 1.0.

The problem is that it is NOT version 1.0 it is version 10 er....or ver 8..... If this was truly a version 1.0 then Apple would not not have killed the support and ability to buy FCP7 immediately, but would have waited until FCPX was established and accepted. Then the use base for FCP7 would have naturally declined and they could sunset the application.
 
If this was truly a version 1.0 then Apple would not not have killed the support and ability to buy FCP7 immediately, but would have waited until FCPX was established and accepted. Then the use base for FCP7 would have naturally declined and they could sunset the application.

It's totally uncool for Apple to kill the FCP 7 support and not allow for new updates. That's a bad deal for all of us FCP 7 users no matter how you slice it.
 
It's totally uncool for Apple to kill the FCP 7 support and not allow for new updates. That's a bad deal for all of us FCP 7 users no matter how you slice it.

It is rude and uncool, but it makes sense if they are giving up on the higher end pro market. I am getting ready for my switch to Avid. I am done with this.
 
I thought everyone would get a kick out of this article I just found when I looked to see how Avid's stock is doing today. It is dated May 20th.

"With Apple having just completed a bottom-up redesign of Final Cut, about the only hope that Avid has of regaining market share would be if Apple totally screwed it up. Possible, but not likely."

http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2011/05/20/does-the-a-in-avid-stand-for-avoid.aspx

Well, I think everyone from all areas of production has agreed that Apple screwed the pooch on this one, right? I'm just curious to see which other A-brand gains market share.
 
It is rude and uncool, but it makes sense if they are giving up on the higher end pro market. I am getting ready for my switch to Avid. I am done with this.

I had to go back to Avid for a recent job, and I still prefer Final Cut 7. So this is a no-win scenario for me. Might download the trial for Premiere at some point to see how that works.
 
Regarding the original question: no one has really given an answer to pros and cons of Premiere CS5.5 vs. Avid MC 5.5. Anyone care to comment on that?
 
Of course there is an element of personal preference. But you're telling me that, for example, we can't come up with a list of considerations upon which to base these preferences?

For example, (1) Avid is a more accepted in Hollywood and big time productions than Premiere, (2) Premiere has speedier real-time playback of RED footage than Avid on equivalent machines (3) Avid has better media management for larger projects, etc.--these, or things like these, are all objective facts. There are others out there that I think many of us don't know. For example, how easy is it to have Avid interact with After Effects? Is it a chore, or is it more difficult, but still easy, relative to Premiere? What about Pro Tools interaction?

Of course, having this info won't by itself determine what you choose. But you need SOME information upon which to base decisions. Generally, more information is better. So, for those who are familiar with either one or both, what do you think are their strengths and weaknesses relative to certain tasks?
 
"Better" is not an objective fact. AVID has a steeper learning curve than Premiere, and is somewhat more expensive.
 
Of course, having this info won't by itself determine what you choose. But you need SOME information upon which to base decisions. Generally, more information is better. So, for those who are familiar with either one or both, what do you think are their strengths and weaknesses relative to certain tasks?

Ultimately they both can deliver the same end product. For me it's flexibility. With Final Cut you can push and pull and manipulate the footage in a much more intuitive way. I experiment more when I'm in Final Cut. Avid's interface is more rigid. Also, Final Cut tolerates lower horsepower machines much better than Avid.
 
"Better" was just a placeholder word. Clearly, we can objectively say that certain programs accomplish certain tasks faster or allow greater control or require less (more) steps to accomplish a particular task or take more time to learn (as you mention), etc. (Also, I'm actually not sure that Avid has "better" media management. All I know is that people SAY it does, but I'm not sure why they do. That's why I want to know the pros vs cons of, say, media management on Avid vs Premiere.)

BTW, some uses of "better" ARE objective, e.g., "FCP7 is better for working on projects that require multiple editors than FCPX" or "LeBron James is a better basketball player than me." :D These statements of course are based on objective facts (which we can appeal to in justifying them). Presumably there is justification for them. Is it the same case with saying Avid has "better" media management? Does it? What's the justification for saying that? Maybe there is none or maybe there is. Or maybe in certain contexts its better, but not in others.
 
I have premiere 5.5 as part of my adobe bundle, but chose not to install it. Didn't even look at it. Checked out some YouTube tutorials last night. I gotta say, it's looking more like the fcp interface than ever. Even has an option to remap the keyboard shortcuts to fcp shortcuts. Plus the mercury engine will use my gtx285. Looking pretty tempting. Guess I'll have to install it and see...
 
learly, we can objectively say that certain programs accomplish certain tasks faster or allow greater control or require less (more) steps to accomplish a particular task or take more time to learn (as you mention), etc.

Still subjective terminology and in no way an objective fact. An objective fact would be "Premiere CS5 does not require Red Raw files to be transcoded." A subjective argument would be "Premiere CS5 is better at working with Red Raw files than Final Cut Pro." You may think that using Red Raw files in their native format is "better," but someone might think the transcoding process to ProRes is "better." Hence, why that would be a subjective argument.

(Also, I'm actually not sure that Avid has "better" media management. All I know is that people SAY it does, but I'm not sure why they do. That's why I want to know the pros vs cons of, say, media management on Avid vs Premiere.)

Exactly, but no one wants to right out what AVID does with media management, they just want to write that it's "better" and leave it at that. I may absolutely hate the way AVID media manages, or I might absolutely love it. But tell me what it does and let me decide if that sounds like it appeals to me.

BTW, some uses of "better" ARE objective, e.g., "FCP7 is better for working on projects that require multiple editors than FCPX" or "LeBron James is a better basketball player than me." :D These statements of course are based on objective facts (which we can appeal to in justifying them).

There is no being "based on objective facts" when using the word "better"...period. An objective fact is "Final Cut Pro 7 will save projects and can look for media if the project folder is moved to another hard drive, while Final Cut Pro X requires a few workarounds to allow a similar workflow. Or, "LeBron James statistically makes shots 78% of the time he attempts them, while I make shots 10% of the time I attempt to." Those are objective facts.
 
Actually, I'm still on FCP5, would like to upgrade to FCP7 now. Anyone can help?

I'm on CS4 as well, will def upgrade to CS6.
 
They both have trials so feel free to try them out for yourself. My opinion is that Adobe offers a fast, modern, and complete package.
 
Exactly, but no one wants to right out what AVID does with media management, they just want to write that it's "better" and leave it at that. I may absolutely hate the way AVID media manages, or I might absolutely love it. But tell me what it does and let me decide if that sounds like it appeals to me.

At the heart of it, it's because Avid converts everything into its own omfi or mxf format upon import and gives it a unique file number, making it almost foolproof. This eliminates media managing screwups, which in final cut are usually from footage that has the same name as another file, or lacks timecode or a reel number. FCP7 has mostly resolved these issues but there are still occasional hiccups. Also, the organizational tools in Avid's media manager are just deeper.
 
I'll say another thing about AVID that appeals to me from what I've heard: being able to make extensive use of the keyboard. I've been finding myself use the keyboard for tasks more and more, as opposed to the mouse, and having an NLE that shines in that arena definitely perks my interest.
 
If you want to be a keyboard based editor, try Avid. I could run an Avid about 90% of the time using only a keyboard. Marking, cutting, subclipping, renaming files, logging footage, etc...could all be done by a keyboard and done very, very quickly. You can map pretty much any command or menu item to the keyboard. I miss that kind of control and speed.
 
If you want to be a keyboard based editor, try Avid. I could run an Avid about 90% of the time using only a keyboard. Marking, cutting, subclipping, renaming files, logging footage, etc...could all be done by a keyboard and done very, very quickly. You can map pretty much any command or menu item to the keyboard. I miss that kind of control and speed.

FCP 7 has the same level of control. Actually, I have a machine with both AVID and FCP on it, and I have the keyboard mapped the same for both programs.
 
Back
Top