Anyone switching from FCP

can i assume that you are using an nVidia card to get that performance?

david


You don't need a super fast Nvidia card. My old GTX260 worked well, and it works even better with the card that replaced it a GTX560Ti. Nearly everything is in RT including DSLR footage with Magic Bullet Looks applied! You can just add the card to the txt file " cuda supported cards" in the Premiere folder.
Let's see.. how much is a GTX 560Ti? Around $240.. not a lot actually... Now... how about a GTX260? or 460? http://www.amazon.com/EVGA-GeForce-PCI-Express-Graphics-01G-P3-1366-TR/dp/B004DKWLB4 $140... There ya go!
 
Yes, knee jerk reactions are not good. But this isn't quite a knee jerk reaction. Heck, I'm still on FCP 6(!) so I'm fine waiting a little. But my needs are going to be changing soon in terms of both quantity and quality of footage I'll be working with. I'm looking to upgrade both hardware-wise and NLE-wise, and now that it seems pretty clear that the FCP will not meet my needs*, I need to start thinking about the viable alternatives. Testing trials of both Premiere and Avid MC is a good idea (although I know there is a somewhat steep learning curve with Avid). But you can form reasonable opinions about certain aspects of NLEs (and the programs they "talk to") without actually having to test the programs.

So, perhaps making the question somewhat more specific will be helpful: suppose that you want to work on everything from P2 to XDCam footage to DSLR to RED to 16mm & 35mm film footage; that you want backwards compatibility of your project with previous versions of FCP; that you want output options for everything from DVDs (Bluerays included) to web to tape of various sorts (HDCAM SR included) to film; you want relatively straightforward integration of your NLE with ProTools and DaVinci Resolve; that your proj ects will range from music videos to industrials to weddings to (low budget) indie-documentaries and narrative fiction films for festival distribution.... what, in terms of all around package, would be the advantages / disadvantages of the Adobe vs Avid? (Let's put the issue of money to the side for just a moment, although feel free to comment on that as well.)

*I realize I could just stay on FCP(7) (FCS3), but it looks there's going to be no more support for it, and there are other editing platforms that take advantage of 64bit processing, etc. So it seems that the smart thing to do is to move to a different platform rather than stay with something that, yes, gets the judge done, but not as well as other tools that are within one's reach.
 
Premiere Pro for me, I've been looking for an excuse and or reason to switch to PP and FCP X is definitely it. I already know Avid but I've had nothing but trouble trying to load it onto my Mac.
And yes it was a Mac version which is why I learned FCP 6 and 7 in the 1st place.
Premiere Pro seems to be my logical choice since I've started working with Photoshop and After FX so I'll stay with them until a better option comes up or who know I may actually like PP.:nads:
 
probably going Premiere Pro. Will make the transition slowly over the next year, finishing up all FCP projects and starting new ones in CS5.5.

Looking forward to what Adobe does with CS6, hopefully they take some of the great ideas from FCP X and incorporate them into a proper NLE.
 
Not planning on switching anytime soon. But we do have the CS5 Production Premium for After Effects, so no matter what we won't be left out to dry.

I'm gonna watch FCPX progress. I'm cool with a new "way" to edit. Storyline whatev, it maybe better and faster. Cool. If I don't see significant upgrades and third-party support, then I'm out. If the app stays like this til next year, that's bad. Updates to include better export functionality, and better project resource management are top priority changes that need to be changed asap. I fully expect Apple to have a DVD/Bluray Studio upgrade, a Soundtrack upgrade, and a Color upgrade in the next year-6months. If not, CS5 is the light with some Davinci Resolve on the side.

Also, they really need to get a FCPX demo out so people can try it out before blowing $299....
 
Spot on.

Every major NLE developer offer trials.

I'm pretty sure I won't buy without trying it first. So, no demo means no purchase.

Everyone that "video edits" should have CS5 anyway for After Effects. It's like a minimum purchase for Production house of any size. So Premiere is always a fall back for anyone who doesn't like the new (or is missing functionality).
 
can i assume that you are using an nVidia card to get that performance?

david

GTX 480 :)

You can get the cheaper cards though, not much of a difference in performance because they all have so many of those Cuda Cores for the Mercury engine to play with :)

FCP feels like a Nokia 2110 in comparison.
My 8 Core now just sits in the corner sulking. (Original plan was to have PC for messing around with my Af100 and FCP for long form and 'serious' stuff).
I'm literally making movies on my gaming machine while my work machine acts as eye candy for clients and stubborn editors.

I chuck F3 AJA Pro Res files onto the same timeline as My Af100 native files and edit 100 minutes without a single render or stutter.
Any renders are happening in the background with Media Encoder. It's really friggin awesome!

Still stuttering with AE though, I wish they would do something clever there.
Lame ass render-before-you-watch nonsense really needs to get with the times now!
 
I wrote a small article about my observations when switching, you can read it here,
hope it can help

Basics of switching from FCP to Premiere
link

and this one might help too

Create a prores sequence in Premiere
link
 
Last edited:
I wrote a small article about my observations when switching, you can read it here,
hope it can help

Basics of switching from FCP to Premiere
link

and this one might help too

Create a prores sequence in Premiere
link
 
Last edited:
i downloaded Avid Media Composer last night. 30 day trial. going thru first tutorial on Lynda.com. im preparing for the future which i dont expect to be FCP X unless Apple snaps to and start posting updates galore. ive got CS5 Premiere already on my system, looked at it over a year ago but its a dog without a killing nVidia GPU. if i dont like Avid then i might have to take a hard look at Premiere again and will need to get a nVidia card. in the meantime FCP7 still works like a champ.

yesterday has changed everything going forward. time to plan for the future.

david

So, is PP not able to use the GPU on ATI cards?

Last time I used Avid MC, it required a USB dongle to be attached to the computer. I'm guessing that has changed?
 
Who I really feel for is anyone who does switch NLE Application (and or Platform) are those that have Legacy Projects .

Legacy projects that may need to be worked on , re-worked again.

Footage , graphics etc that gets recycled. (stock)

Its a real big deal and its compounded by the fact, switching involves 64bit / hardware and plugins.

Keeping the old app / hardware is fine but not the entire solution.

Been there...done that. It was post production mangement hell at the time ....and still impacts occassionally.

Trick is planning for where you want to end up in the future. Dealing with today is something else.
 
You don't need a super fast Nvidia card. My old GTX260 worked well, and it works even better with the card that replaced it a GTX560Ti. Nearly everything is in RT including DSLR footage with Magic Bullet Looks applied! You can just add the card to the txt file " cuda supported cards" in the Premiere folder.
Let's see.. how much is a GTX 560Ti? Around $240.. not a lot actually... Now... how about a GTX260? or 460? http://www.amazon.com/EVGA-GeForce-PCI-Express-Graphics-01G-P3-1366-TR/dp/B004DKWLB4 $140... There ya go!

im on a macpro. those cards arent compatible with my mac right? GeForce GTX 285 which is not available anymore, Quadro FX 4800 & Quadro 4000 are the ones that i see as an option. if others can work on my macpro id like to know. im on a macpro 8 core 2.93ghz Nehalem.

thanks
david
 
Who I really feel for is anyone who does switch NLE Application (and or Platform) are those that have Legacy Projects .

Legacy projects that may need to be worked on , re-worked again.

Footage , graphics etc that gets recycled. (stock)

Its a real big deal and its compounded by the fact, switching involves 64bit / hardware and plugins.

Keeping the old app / hardware is fine but not the entire solution.

Been there...done that. It was post production mangement hell at the time ....and still impacts occassionally.

Trick is planning for where you want to end up in the future. Dealing with today is something else.


I totally agree. I have this problem when I have clients/partners that have projects originally edited on PPro or AVID (And also when I switched from Avid to Edius).

I now have PPro, AVID and Edius on my machine. I do most of my editing on Edius but do need the other two on occasion (and sometimes deal with the nightmare of trying to take form old projects in AVID to add to new ones in Edius).

Those with FCP7 projects really seem screwed. I can't believe Apple has left no solution moving projects to there new NLE. Crazy.

For new projects one can either dual boot and run Edius, or install AVID or PPro, but users with old projects, hopefully someone (third party) will come up with something. Even PPro has some ability to run FCP7 projects, though via XML.
 
I am as most others disappointed with Apple for this non pro version of finalcut x and them canceling further support of the current version. It really feels like a smack in the face after so many studio proffessionals remained so loyal over the years. I myself will be looking at premier pro.

On a side note. Any time a big company like Apple would stoop so low as to erase all the negative user feed back on their site It tells me a lot about the character of the company.
 
Both CS5.5 and AVID MC 5.5 are great deals. I bought AVID MC 5.5 with the crossgrade promotion and boy do I love it.

It's not as fast as CS5 with final output rendering, but many of its effects are real-time and the editing experience is solid and faster than FCP or Premiere once you get the hang of it. Have you ever wanted to feel like you're typing an essay rather than mousing-around clips to make a cut? That's what Media Composer feels like due to the "learn the shortcuts or die" apprach to their software, haha. CS5.5 is going be a better sandbox editor for fudging around with graphics because of its faster playback engine, but AVID is a better 'cutter' once you get the hang of it.

To be honest, there will be times where you'll want both.
 
Back
Top