AF100, GH2, Cineform codec and 109 IRE clamping

GrahamH

Well-known member
Until recently I have been shooting with my GH2, converting the MTS files to Cineform avi using Cineform Neo 5.5.1. build 323, and editing in Premiere CS6. If I inspect my footage in the YCWaveform display, the raw MTS and the transcoded avi look identical, with overexposed highlights sitting at 100IRE.

I've now started shooting with an AF100, and when I inspect raw MTS from that, the highlights extend to 109IRE. I can pull them down with a levels control and recover extra highlight detail. However the transcoded Cineform avi is still clamped at 100 and that detail in the "superwhites" is getting lost.

IRE.jpg

Here are my questions:

1) If you are transcoding AF100 footage using GoPro/Cineform on a PC, do you see your footage being clamped in this same way? (If not, what version of Cineform are you using?)

2) In the following post, EOSHD seems to be saying that there are superwhites in GH2 footage, equivalent to those in the AF100, that can be recovered. Can anyone confirm or deny? http://www.eoshd.com/content/8612/mac-avchd-gamma-issues-the-fix

Thanks for any feedback!
 
Cineform avi helped quite a bit when I had a less powerful machine. It still edits a bit more smoothly for me, especially with multiple effects applied. But you are correct, I can ditch it if necessary.
 
There is no such thing as super white or super black, just different display gamma spaces. Cineform is probably conforming to REC709 2.4 gamma limits where any digital value that exceeds 8-bit 235/100 IRE is reproduced as maximum white and any value below 16 is reproduced as 0 black. You are probably working on a computer in sRGB color space where 8-bit 0 is black and 255 is white at gamma 2.2. You need to set your output gamma to comply with REC709 or bring your scope values under 100 IRE max with brightness and contrast before transcoding to preserve your highlights. There is no real difference in how these look on properly calibrated monitors. A 0-255 grayscale step pattern shown on an sRGB monitor correctly calibrated at 2.2 gamma will look pretty much identical to a 16-235 grayscale step pattern shown a properly calibrated REC709 monitor at gamma 2.4. It is only when you move video from one color space to the other that issues like this arise.
 
Thanks for that. However, Cineform's HDLink transcoding app provides no way to pull down the levels. One just loads the files and hits "convert". In older versions, the output still had information above 100IRE if the input files had them. Now it doesn't, for me at least.
 
Back
Top