AF-100 plus Speedbooster: vignette or not with DX-style lenses?

GrahamH

Well-known member
I have a big silly grin on my face tonight, as my Nikon-G to MFT Speedbooster arrived and I've been having lots of fun with the several lenses I have at hand. Which got me wondering whether anyone is maintaining a list of which DX-type lenses do or don't vignette on the AF-100?

For example, my Sigma 30mm f1.4 EX DC is borderline - with an even background I can see the corners darken slightly, but for 95% of shots not enough to bother me.

My Tamron 17-50m f2.8 is similar but slightly worse, whereas I've read elsewhere that the Nikon 17-55mm f2.8 DX does not vignette at all.

Anyone else care to share their experiences?
 
Tough story: depends on the lens. I get full coverage with my Tokina 11-16 and Sigma 50-150. Tested a boatload of others with my GH2; Sigma 10-20 covered but had corner falloff, Nikon 17-55 full coverage, Tokina 16-50 vignettes at the wide end, Sigma 17-70 vignettes at the wide end, Tamron 18-270 covers full through, Nikon 18-200 vignettes full through. Really seems the only way to know is to test.
 
Very interesting. I thought the Tokina 11-16 would vignette at 11mm.

The corners do soften and there's light falloff (not unlike using it on DX)... it will begin to vignette on the GH2 at ~12mm because of the multi-aspect sensor's different crop in video mode - I imagine similar results might be had with the G6. I always test with the GH2 for that reason - if it doesn't vignette or barely vignettes on GH2, it'll be fine on AF100
 
The corners do soften and there's light falloff (not unlike using it on DX)... it will begin to vignette on the GH2 at ~12mm because of the multi-aspect sensor's different crop in video mode - I imagine similar results might be had with the G6. I always test with the GH2 for that reason - if it doesn't vignette or barely vignettes on GH2, it'll be fine on AF100


So that gives you ~8mm f/2 on the wide side. I was looking at the Lumix 7-14mm but The Tokina & Metabones combo sounds like a no brainer wide zoom on the AF100.
 
There's some brain involved... the Lumix is notably sharper, smaller/lighter, and offers auto functionality vs. the Tokina
 
I have a big silly grin on my face tonight, as my Nikon-G to MFT Speedbooster arrived and I've been having lots of fun with the several lenses I have at hand. Which got me wondering whether anyone is maintaining a list of which DX-type lenses do or don't vignette on the AF-100?

For example, my Sigma 30mm f1.4 EX DC is borderline - with an even background I can see the corners darken slightly, but for 95% of shots not enough to bother me.

My Tamron 17-50m f2.8 is similar but slightly worse, whereas I've read elsewhere that the Nikon 17-55mm f2.8 DX does not vignette at all.

Anyone else care to share their experiences?

Can you post an image showing the vignette with the Tamron 17-50mm?
Does it happen at all apertures and all focal lengths?
 
Can you post an image showing the vignette with the Tamron 17-50mm?
Does it happen at all apertures and all focal lengths?

Sure - please see below. (Sorry it took me so long to do this). These shots are all taken with the Speed-booster set 1 click down on the aperture ring - exposure was adjusted so the center of each frame was at 75% zebra. I didn't try stopping the lens way down, but from wide open through the first couple of clicks, I saw not much difference in the level of vignetting from what you can see here.


Vignette.jpg
 
I too have the Tamron 17-50 with the speedbooster and that is what it looks like on my GH3. I still use it when I'm not shooting something against a background that would make it really noticeable. For the cost of $250 used you can't beat it as a 12-35 f2 on my M4/3.
 
I agree - it's one of my most-used lenses on my AF100 (same framing as GH3). On the wider GH2 the vignetting is more noticeable, unfortunately.
 
Hi Guys

I've got the Nikon version of the Tamron 17-50 and was wondering if you are able to manually control the iris with these adaptors? Also, would he Samyang cine series of lenses work well or do they vignette too?

Many thank

T
 
Yes Iris control works fine with the Nikon-mount 17-50.

And ... no vignetting with the Samyangs- they are full frame lenses.
 
Got a rental Metabones just to see what everyone was raving about. Tested on my main lens (Nikon 17-55mm) Vignetting past 20mm but 20mm is plenty wide for me. No vignetting on my full frame lens. Loved the extra light sensitivity. Think I'll buy one.
 
Strange... I tested the Nikon 17-55 with my GH2 (even wider sensor) and it didn't vignette at all. Wonder where the batch variation is?
 
Strange... I tested the Nikon 17-55 with my GH2 (even wider sensor) and it didn't vignette at all. Wonder where the batch variation is?
Actually if the GH2 has a wider sensor than the AF-100 it would make sense that you don't have vignetting with the Metabones on your Nikon DX 17-55mm lens.
 
The GH2 vignettes more than the AF100 (and GH3) ... the difference is evident in the images I posted earlier in this thread.
 
Back
Top