Adobe changes to new product cycle and announces CS version 5.5

They have charged for dot releases many times. The Design and Web suites have this pretty much every time a new version of Acrobat comes out.

Also, there was Premiere 6.5, After Effects 6.5, Premiere PRO 1.5 (when they added HD support, among other things). The Production CS suites, of course, have not had a dot release like the web/design suites have, so we've had CS2/CS3/CS4 without a paid upgrade.

That being said, I'm not sure there's enough in the new package for me personally to warrant a paid upgrade. The Audition swapout for Soundbooth and the new audio workflows there and with multiple audio sources will be nice, but I'm not sure I can't wait another 12 months when the release CS6.

If it was a $199 upgrade for CS5 owners, I'd do it. If it was a $299 upgrade, I'd really have to consider it heavily (mainly for Audition). But at $399, I'm not in a big hurry.

The subscription plan is a great idea. I can think of lots of times I'd want to bring on another/multiple editors who normally work in Final Cut or Avid, and this is perfect for that. If it was $49 a month with 1-year commitments, I'd really consider doing it myself. But with a predictably $400-$700 upgrade each year, it doesn't make sense mathematically.

At any rate, I think this all moves in the right direction, just not exactly the right pricing. If having prices go up a bit helps to ensure constant development and support of the Adobe apps, well...isn't that kind of what we all want? Ask a current Final Cut Studio if they'd be willing to pay for an upgrade opportunity once a year, and I bet right now it looks pretty appealing. :)
 
I only just did my CS4 to CS5 upgrade within the past 6 months, accordingly I won't consider another paid upgrade for (at least) another 6 months . . .
Probably a no brainer for some -- a few of 'em are nice features but I'm "out" for now, although I do agree with scapsinger . . . I'd do it for $199.

P.S I already have Audition . . . went through that exercise a few versions back.

Just goes to show though, for some . . . if they put $5 (or more) per gallon on the pump we'd pay it.
 
Actually, I've found that upgrading on an every other release seems to work best for me. I went from CS3 to CS5. And unless CS6 has something absolutely earth shattering in it (it won't) I'll wait to CS7 (at least) to do an upgrade. Adding .5 releases and a subscription model won't get me to buy anything.

Now customers can use Adobe Production Premium CS5.5 for as little as US$85 per month.
Now compare the pricing schemes:
- CS3 releases on 4/20/2007 for $599 upgrade
- CS4 releases on 8/23/2008 for $599 upgrade (14 months later)
- CS5 releases on 4/10/2010 for $599 upgrade (18 months later)
- CS5.5 releases on ??/??/2011 for $1020/year (12-14/15/16? months later)

Wow. What a deal. Can I please have 2? Of course if you're like me and skip a version, then the upgrade from CS3 to CS5 cost you $599, instead of $2720 (which is what it would have cost under a subscription model).

So, how will the model actually work? Will they still offer full version number entry and upgrade points? Probably yes on entry points, no on upgrade points. I could picture them making people pay to upgrade based on the following rate:

Number of months since your version released X monthly subscription rate = your price to upgrade. And once the upgrade price is higher than the full price, you'll just pay the full price.

SO kiss those upgrade prices goodbye.....

Anyone know of a Gimp like alternative to After Effects? Don't need it today, but tomorrow?
 
Last edited:
The upgrade from CS5 to CS5.5 is $399. Not sure I'm down with spending 2/3's the price of a full release upgrade for a .5 upgrade a year later.
 
I've only got AE, so the thought of paying $179 to get the Warp Stabilizer when I've already got the capabilities in Syntheyes is a bit hard to swallow. The camera blur looks nice, but hard to justify that unless it's on par with some of those third party lens blur plugins.
 
Awesome, got my pre-order in today at Adobe for 5.5 :-) Confirm email says shipping May 3rd.
I have to say I am very impressed with Adobe customer service/marketing. I saw the announcement here on the forum and went "Oh Crap! I just bought CS5 PP a week ago" No sooner than I clicked into email I already had a message from Adobe waiting for me with instructions to get the free upgrade! I figured that they would do something for a recent purchase, but I expected to have to root around the website and be on hold for 2hrs to get it. Painless process!
 
I like the new subscription model. For about the price of a grande latte a day, you have the use of the full CS5.5 deluxe package with only a 1 month cost up front.
 
I like the new subscription model. For about the price of a grande latte a day, you have the use of the full CS5.5 deluxe package with only a 1 month cost up front.

True, but that way you can't have your Adobe and drink your grande latte too. Stop paying Adobe and you the software stops working.

Worse still, you end up paying more than double the normal upgrade price. Their normal release schedule has a new version coming out every 16 months on average. So at $85/month x 16 months... you pay $1360 over the life of a full version instead of $599. You are much better off financing an upgrade purchase on a credit card. Here's the proof:

Assume your credit card carries a high 20% APR. With a $599 charge you'll pay $85 each month for SEVEN months and on the eight month you'll pay off the remaining balance of $47.67. Grand total over 8 months: $642.67. $599 principal, $43.67 in interest. The next 8 months are FREE. But buying on Adobe's subscription (loan shark) model, and you pay the $599 on the principal and then keep on paying another $761 in interest.

So which is better, $43.67 in interest or $761 in interest?

This kind of super high interest rate (that's what it is) used to be called usury. Apparently today it's called business.
 
Last edited:
True, but that way you can't have your Adobe and drink your grande latte too. Stop paying Adobe and you the software stops working.

Worse still, you end up paying more than double the normal upgrade price. Their normal release schedule has a new version coming out every 16 months on average. So at $85/month x 16 months... you pay $1360 over the life of a full version instead of $599. You are much better off financing an upgrade purchase on a credit card. Here's the proof:

Assume your credit card carries a high 20% APR. With a $599 charge you'll pay $85 each month for SEVEN months and on the eight month you'll pay off the remaining balance of $47.67. Grand total over 8 months: $642.67. $599 principal, $43.67 in interest. The next 8 months are FREE. But buying on Adobe's subscription (loan shark) model, and you pay the $599 on the principal and then keep on paying another $761 in interest.

So which is better, $43.67 in interest or $761 in interest?

This kind of super high interest rate (that's what it is) used to be called usury. Apparently today it's called business.

No one is forcing you to go the subscription route, and I could see a scenario where it would make more sense. Say you need to bring in a few freelancers for a short term project, but don't have enough licenses as it is. Right now, you can install CS5 on two computers, but can only use one computer at any given moment. If you need to run it on three or four machines for a couple of months, it makes WAY more sense to go the subscription route, then buy 3-4 more copies of CS5.5. 4 new full copies = ~$6k. 4 copies via subscription = $340/month x 3 month project = $1020.
 
The subscription rate makes perfect sense for somebody cutting their own indie films. You only have to keep the subscription active for 1 month every 6 months. So say you start in May, you cancel at the end of May... You'd need to renew by the beginning of November to keep the subscription active for another 180 days. Say you shoot a film in August, and edit in August, September, and October. You only paid for 5 months out of the year, because you only used it for 5 months out of the year. If you don't shoot anything the following year, you only need to pay for 2 months, that following year. 7 total monthly payments over 2 years.

If you're constantly editing and doing freelance work... sure it makes no sense to do it that way.


EDIT: Now that I think about, you can actually knock off the November payment, since you had paid for those three months that you actually edited the film (to keep the subscription active)... so 6 payments over two years.
 
Last edited:
The subscription rate makes perfect sense for somebody cutting their own indie films. You only have to keep the subscription active for 1 month every 6 months. So say you start in May, you cancel at the end of May... You'd need to renew by the beginning of November to keep the subscription active for another 180 days. Say you shoot a film in August, and edit in August, September, and October. You only paid for 5 months out of the year, because you only used it for 5 months out of the year. If you don't shoot anything the following year, you only need to pay for 2 months, that following year. 7 total monthly payments over 2 years.

If you're constantly editing and doing freelance work... sure it makes no sense to do it that way.


EDIT: Now that I think about, you can actually knock off the November payment, since you had paid for those three months that you actually edited the film (to keep the subscription active)... so 6 payments over two years.

Of course, that's not how it really works. Once subscribed and your account is set up to automatically debit your account, people don't bother canceling. In your scenario, why even start in May if you aren't going to shoot until August?

And is there a value to restarting a subscription at the 6 month point for 1 month, and then suspending it again? I know about their 6 month suspension rule, but what's the harm in just letting it expire and not re-subscribing until you need it again, say 10 months later for example? I know that this sounds like I'm actually making an argument against myself, but I'm not. Because again, most people will end up never canceling their subscription. There are times when I won't touch a program for weeks, but then need it for a couple of hours. Whoops - did I suspend my subscription? Darn.

Adding, that the month to month option on the production bundle actually starts at $129. So using your scenario, $129 x 6 = $774. Full version upgrade price is $599.

And again, reality is that you either won't cancel your subscription, or will end up needing to restart it much more often than you plan.
 
...Because again, most people will end up never canceling their subscription. There are times when I won't touch a program for weeks, but then need it for a couple of hours. Whoops - did I suspend my subscription? Darn.

Adding, that the month to month option on the production bundle actually starts at $129. So using your scenario, $129 x 6 = $774. Full version upgrade price is $599.

And again, reality is that you either won't cancel your subscription, or will end up needing to restart it much more often than you plan.

You sound like you assume that most operations are like yours. That simply isn't the case. Honestly, for a lot of folks it doesn't make sense to go the subscription route. But you assume it doesn't make sense for *anyone*. I'm pretty sure Adobe did some research into whenther this was a viable option or not before implementing this option. This subscription model seems to me a lot like renting any other piece of equipment. For some folks renting makes no sense. For some folks buying makes no sense. Just because one doesn't make sense to you and your business model doesn't mean it doesn't make sense for anyone else.

Look, if it doesn't work for you, don't do it. No one is forcing you to. But do don't assume it doesn't work for anyone else. All your numbers are based on upgrades... not everyone has that option of upgrading and need to buy full copies. I can see several scenarios, including the one I already described, where it makes more sense to subscribe the buy new full copies.
 
No one is forcing you to go the subscription route, and I could see a scenario where it would make more sense. Say you need to bring in a few freelancers for a short term project, but don't have enough licenses as it is. Right now, you can install CS5 on two computers, but can only use one computer at any given moment. If you need to run it on three or four machines for a couple of months, it makes WAY more sense to go the subscription route, then buy 3-4 more copies of CS5.5. 4 new full copies = ~$6k. 4 copies via subscription = $340/month x 3 month project = $1020.

I think your example is probably the closest one can get to arguing in favor of an end user going with a temporary subscription model. (Of course, those are 50% more expensive than the 1 year subscription. The $1020 price tag is actually $1560). But I think it breaks down a bit when you look at what actually happens when you bring in freelancers for a short term project.

It has been my experience (personally hiring freelancers and producing with companies that hire freelancers) that freelancers hired for a particular job are hired for a particular skill set. Got a big, multi episode show that needs editing? You hire in editors who will edit. They won't do compositing, encoding, illustrating.... They will need editing software (no Photoshop, Illustrator, Encore, After Effects). That stuff is going to be handled by other people. (For a show that needs multiple editors though, you rent turn key Avids and hire Avid editors.) Yes, you can get subscription of PS, IL, AE, PP all on their own. And maybe that's what you would do. In that case the model would work. But I think that's the rare exception really.

Quality, Speed, Price - pick two for a mid-level budget, pick one for a small budget. For a very small budget work, there's never money to hire multiple freelancers. And when you do get to hire a freelancer, you hire someone who brings their own tools (which of course they already own since that's how they learned them).

I think it is the rare instance where a subscription model will end up working.

Still, if it works for you and saves you some money - fantastic. Of course, Adobe is banking on the new model as a way to increase revenue.....
 
Last edited:
Back
Top