48 or 44.1 kHz and 24 vs 16bit- which is best trade off for file-size vs quality?

eco_bach

Well-known member
Do I really need to record at 48kHz, 24bit to have the best quality wav files on a Zoom H6?

Which combination of kHz and bit depth is BEST in terms of file size and quality if the most that will be done in post is perhaps some EQ and slight reverb?
 
Do I really need to record at 48kHz, 24bit to have the best quality wav files on a Zoom H6?

Which combination of kHz and bit depth is BEST in terms of file size and quality if the most that will be done in post is perhaps some EQ and slight reverb?

File size in nearly irrelevant; audio files are miniscule compared to video files. Sample rate for professional video is 48kHz. For music CDs it's 44.1kHz. So... when you get a choice 48kHz at 24 bits if your target output is video, and 44.1kHz at 24 bits if your target is audio only CD.
 
Yes, 48khz for video.. period Why not use 96k then? The consensus is 48k is more than sufficient for dialog. (S/FX and music is another story) 24 bits can give better quality especially at low amplitude levels. However some NLEs do not support multiple bit depths (and sample rates), so for instance, if the camera's audio is 16 bit and the audio recorder's is 24, there could be problems. To blur things more, many budget recorders record files @ 24 bit, but in fact the cheap A/D converters have only 16bit (and less) quality. (another example of 'you get what for you pay for')
 
To blur things more, many budget recorders record files @ 24 bit, but in fact the cheap A/D converters have only 16bit (and less) quality.
I've heard this as well. Does anyone know if this applies to the Zoom?

No sense using 24bit, if there is no increase in quality
 
I've heard this as well. Does anyone know if this applies to the Zoom?

No sense using 24bit, if there is no increase in quality

My philosophy is to use 24 bit/48K even if the recorder is only good for 16. With an 8 GB SD card in my Zoom H4, trying to 'optimize' for space is somewhat 'no value added', unless of course I was trying to record seminars that lasted hours...

But in most short film, and I would presume long film, shooting, the takes are short, if the takes are properly identified, swapping out cards, securing them, uploading to archive devices, there should be no problem with just going as with large files, which the difference between 16 and 24, is one byte. so that yields half again as much data at the most.

Not anything like going from SD to HD to 4K in video... where each increase is about 4x data.
 
I agree with the "use 48 kHz/24-bit if you got it" philosophy, as there is almost no drawbacks to using 24-bit. Some low cost recorders are slightly noisier when recording 24-bit instead of 16-bit, but most aren't.

Also, 24-bit makes quite a big difference over 16-bit when you go to manipulate your recording with an audio editor.
 
BIT DEPTH
It also somewhat depends on WHAT you are recording.
If you are recording a monotonous talking-head lecture, 16 bit is probably fine.
But if you are recording live music, especially from some loud ensemble (rock band, orchestra, etc.), then having the HEADROOM makes 24-bit VERY attractive.
Likewise, if you are recording dialog from amateur "actors" where levels will be unpredictable and all over the map, having that headroom is a life-saver.

SAMPLE RATE
Certainly, recording any kind of audio for video should be 48K sample rate. 44.1 is only for audio (CD) release.
You can use 96K after you get some experience doing esoteric audio manipulation and you find you need it.
 
48 is not an option. It is what video sound is at and anything else will need to get converted. You don't want conversion if possible. 24 bit is optional. I personally think it's worth it. When we did tests on a variety of gear from $$$ to consumer 16 to 24 was instantly obvious. 96 is optional and personally I would never go there for dialog. I might go there for FX because then you can slow it down to 50% and still have a high quality smooth sound.

The first thing most editors will do with your 96K files is convert them to 48. If they don't they will have to convert everything else to 96 to use it in the session.

If you have the $$$ and have a dedicated dialog editor them maybe? They will probably at lest keep them at 96.

Space in general is a non issue. I came in when space was a BIG issue. 44.1 doesn't really save you much at all. 16 saves some from 24 (1/3) and 96 is twice the size of 48.
 
For good quality without going to a too large file use 24-bit.

Sampling frreqiency: use 44.1 if it will end up on CD, or 48kHz if it's sound for video.
 
Back
Top