24p Advanced? Need a little more incite...

I haven't had much experience with Premiere Elements, but "interpret footage" is not the way you want to go. That's generally a method for taking standard video -- 60i -- and making it play back in an approximation of something else, in this case, 24p.

The problem is that the footage isn't really 60i footage; it's recorded that way out of necessity. Extra fields were added to the 24p footage to make it fit in 60i, but it's still 24p footage. I can't imagine you'd end up with anything but a mess.

24p footage should not be "interpreted"; it should not be "deinterlaced." The only proper way to deal with it, to edit it as 24-frame progressive footage, is to remove its pulldown correctly.

Premiere Elements doesn't have this ability, so until you move up in editors, you're best off shooting 24p standard and editing it on the 60i (29.97) timeline.
 
Sincere thanks for your input David. Kinda what I figured.

Looks like PE simply adds a duplicate frame in between every 4, so that every 30 frames there are 6 "extras" that offer no motion... that's what I noticed when I counted frame by frame. I can't figure out what it does to footage I "interpreted" to 24.

I'm also still not clear as to how to recognize when something is interlaced by looking at one frame at a time. Some blur is inherent with motion right?

Anyway, I'm moving up the learning curve on this & these forums are valuable (yet time-consuming as I'm reading everything!). I hope I'm on the right track to understanding this stuff. I guess the 24p function of my DVX100a is useless to me till I shell out some more $. Next question then would be when I'm ready to upgrade NLE... Premiere Pro vs something else to handle this? (Or even going Mac..I know, that's a big question, I don't expect you or anyone to really answer that!)

At least I still have great progressive footage I can use and edit with at 30fps. The look is so beautiful with this camera.

Always thanks for all help & insights.
 
24p vs 24pa compare

24p vs 24pa compare

24p is better if you are printing to film , where 24pa is better for printing to dvd or web :)
 
Back
Top