How was business in 2023?

Very nice graph but challenging no doubt. I have been thinking about this thread a bit and while there is a definite change in the industry, I also think there is just basic saturation in media. High level images are everywhere and this creates a sense of entitlement. For a long time, industry folks where hired because they were better or what they produced was better. Well, now 'better' is not needed as much. I see this as a need to provide a service that is still needed (right side of the graph). Basically, find some new niches. YouTube is in itself a new niche.

Normal people still do not know or want to know how to operate cameras and sound equipment etc... Skills and expertise are still needed, just the application might be in another way.

I am going to start looking at some different fields and see if there is any type of need for content creation with a slant towards live streaming. I have found that streaming is more difficult than it looks and I think folks want somebody else to handle it so to speak. So maybe some market opportunities exist to show up and create a show/broadcast on location and go home. Done. Of course in fields with disposable income (bottom part of the graph). What used to be a large production is nowdays compressed into a single person showing up with cameras, lights, mics and computers to create a broadcast an entire show. Weird, strange, sad, exciting and modern at the same time. But I think that is what level it will take to still be relevant in the freelance market to day. Overdelivering in comparison to the past for sure.

What ideas are you guys thinking about?
 
Ironically, I am working on a video right now in which my client used AI to write a script, and then deepfake to generate voiceovers. But they still need a real human to edit it. At least for now.

Some edits will always need a human touch, like a very precise story/edit to make it "just right", exactly how the human brain is thinking - but many will not because the art will be very irrelevant.

Content factories will exist, pumping out anything and everything. Will be especially effective in marking/sales where I imagine there to be hundreds of short videos on a daily basis (vs. the same commercial over and over, or the once or twice a week YouTube formula).

Thinking about it from a company's perspective, that's incredible. Different videos hitting different cultures and brains all at once and the system has all the numbers to run itself (pull content, recycle it, create more of the same which has been successful with view/retention rates, track the amount of playbacks from the same sources suggesting it's working, etc).

With all that said, I'm still very much a realist and as much as I envision this advanced world for video production, the bottom line still is that the fake videos have to look good or good enough. Right now they are a little weird-looking, but getting kind of close. I said something like 5 years the other month...5 years, 10 years...the advances in this stuff come very quickly these days.

But, in general, the idea of that kind of video automation is a dream come true for everyone but Joe.
 

He said he would send me one once the channel has been established. I will ask him if he's okay with it being shared here. He is really going all out and trying to do this right, signing a lease for a studio space so that he can build a set and install a grid, etc. Should be something to behold once it's all set up.
 
.

I've been staring at this diagram a lot lately:



Supposedly, finding a way to put yourself in the middle as far as your work goes is the recipe for a truly happy life.

I'm usually pretty good at puzzles, but I haven't cracked this one yet.

My children are my ikigai, although obviously that won't be true for everyone. After I started having kids, I shifted away from working on things I was passionate about and towards things that were more stable and higher-paying. Early in my career when I was an AC on larger productions and shot small indy projects, I used to say to myself "at least I don't shoot weddings." LOL. At various points in my life, I dreamed of making feature films, documentaries, or experimental films. What I do now is sort of passion-adjacent. It's also worth noting that every job is a mixed bag and even if you're working on exactly what you want to work on, there will be parts of the job you dislike.

The point of my in-depth analysis is that you have to understand the present and past in order to predict the future. My handler at Christie's told me they had suffered a severe drop in YOY profit in 2023. But I did a little research and concluded that 2023 wasn't THAT bad of a year. It's just that 2022 was a stellar year. Christie's provides about 60% of my revenue, so any changes with them will substantively affect my bottom line.

Weddings are about 15% of my revenue. 2024 is going to be a decline in work for wedding shooters but possibly only because 2023 was very busy, and either way i dont think it will affect me.

And I think that's what you see in this thread -- different people having a different year depending on their specialty. We're all cameramen but we virtually work in different industries.

I will say that I've seen a decrease in frequency and rates of job postings on sites like mandy and productionhub. I wasn't sure if that was indicative of industry-wide malaise or if people are using those sites less.

Personally, I'm heavily exposed to doing business with Christie's and I don't have another high-volume client waiting in the wings if things there go south. Which they easily could for a few reasons, in order of likelihood: 1) new management comes in and brings their own production freelancers; 2) the iPhone and/or AI eat my lunch; 3) the auction market tanks or the company folds due to imbezzlement or something. The wedding industry seems stable but it's easy to imagine the product going out of fashion or even garish weddings themselves going out of fashion, particularly following a harsh recession.

But if you weren't happy with the status quo for business before 2023, then I think it makes sense to eye a transition as Charles has. Because while I think there's a decent chance that the status quo for production could return (outside of streaming because I think that was always a temporary bubble), I think there's only a small chance that our core business model as it was will expand.

But I would look at your situation differently. You have a very valuable asset going forward, which is your freelance clientele and earnings. That puts you in a position of strength because you won't be desperate to settle for the first opportunity you can find. In fact, you might be able to find some flexible work arrangement that lets you keep the business you already have and build on top of it. I wouldn't recommend this exact approach, but I've read many articles about people working two simultaneous full-time remote jobs. It's easy to imagine tacking on something remote to what you do.

Also, if you were to take a 9 to 5, I don't see why you would have to take an entry-level job. You have valuable skills and experience and if you could find a position that relates to video then you should be able to get yourself a better offer than if you were doing something unrelated. Maybe you can use your social connections to help find something better-suited to you.

The last thing I'd say is that since I sold out, I haven't tried to create opportunities for myself. I've just responded to demand. Shooting weddings or shooting for Christie's-- I got into both by applying to jobs postings. I used to apply to hundreds per year before I became too busy to take on more work. (I still apply to some in the winter.) So if you want to get into a new venture like livestreaming, I think it makes sense to try to suss out demand and get a clear picture of the business potential before making investments.

Starting a YouTube channel doesn't make much sense to me, assuming that it's video-oriented. If the industry is actually tanking, then who is going to be your audience? If folks like us don't need to watch reviews and tutorials anymore, then who is going to watch? And if there is an audience, then that means that the industry isn't tanking, which means you should still be able to make money in freelance production. Am I wrong?
 
I agree with a lot of what you say Abe. I have always viewed freelancing as a position of power if you have skills and expertise. Being nimble and having many irons in the fire is one's best defense. It is tough as a small business to truly gauge demand. Market research is important for new ventures and many times, we just need to believe to move forward due to the lack of data.

I remember the concept of 'selling out'. Ha. It is a young person's phrase for sure. Making a living in a chosen field while being your own boss is a privilege/luxury compared to so many other people. I look back at how out of touch those thoughts were. But they were innocent and idealistic. Concepts that seem to disappear later in life.
 
The last thing I'd say is that since I sold out, I haven't tried to create opportunities for myself. I've just responded to demand. Shooting weddings or shooting for Christie's-- I got into both by applying to jobs postings. I used to apply to hundreds per year before I became too busy to take on more work. (I still apply to some in the winter...

This might suggest your rates are too low. Perhaps you could put prices up and offer a winter discount? I only point this out as I'm terrible at valuing my own time and skills properly.
 
I agree with a lot of what you say Abe. I have always viewed freelancing as a position of power if you have skills and expertise. Being nimble and having many irons in the fire is one's best defense. It is tough as a small business to truly gauge demand. Market research is important for new ventures and many times, we just need to believe to move forward due to the lack of data.

I remember the concept of 'selling out'. Ha. It is a young person's phrase for sure. Making a living in a chosen field while being your own boss is a privilege/luxury compared to so many other people. I look back at how out of touch those thoughts were. But they were innocent and idealistic. Concepts that seem to disappear later in life.

I'm not opposed to taking some unknown risks and making some investments to move in a new direction. I'm just kind of risk-averse and you need to make sure you can afford to lose what you put in. Many start-ups take out loans for the initial investment and then they don't lose everything they've got personally if it doesn't work out.

I don't think that "selling out" is a totally meaningless phrase. In theory, if I were willing to be poor for longer and have a riskier, less stable living then I might have been able to make it as a DP or director in features. I already took on more risk and instability pursuing a freelance production career than I would have by getting a 9 to 5 or going to dental school. But we probably all have to sell out in some way or another at some point, even the Stanley Kubricks and Christopher Nolans of the world.
 
Last edited:
This might suggest your rates are too low. Perhaps you could put prices up and offer a winter discount? I only point this out as I'm terrible at valuing my own time and skills properly.

Well, my rates are not that high to be sure. But I think I've done a good job getting them to the maximum that each repeat client can handle through multiple rounds of negotiations over the years. (I think I don't have the same rates for any two clients. Although I usually give roughly the same offer to new clients.) And I do offer a winter discount on my wedding rate because winter is super slow in the wedding business.

But the reason I'm so busy sometimes is because Christie's does its major blue-chip sales in spring and autumn (known as "auction season"). I think this has been the pattern for decades if not centuries, and other auction houses do the same thing. There are smaller sales and private sales all throughout the year, but May and November each have a week full of big sales of expensive works, which means they need a lot of videos made in the lead-up.

Christies puts me on retainer roughly from March thru May and September thru November. This means that they book all my weekdays for editing, with the option to convert any edit day into a shoot day. On top of that, they usually book at least a quarter of weekend days on a case by case basis and there's usually some overtime work in the evenings.

May/June and September/October are also the height of wedding season.

These days i turn down a lot of weddings in those months but back in 2021-2022 when we were saving for a house (and house prices were inexorably rising), I would work like 30 days per month in the busy season, including shooting or editing for multiple clients per day if it was physically possible. It was nuts.

July and August are usually not quite as busy for me but i still get work from Christie's and wedding studios as well as my other random clients so they're fine.
 
Pretty normal year for me honestly. Of course I'm not living in LA (or any other city) and doing high end narrative work, so
things like strikes influence me much less. Definitely depends what sort of work you are doing in my opinion. Probably also
a huge variation in answer depending on your market.

I'm mostly corporate, doc, and online promo videos, that sort of thing. A little freelance news, a comedy TV series, and some
live streaming fill it out. Very normal year for me, but I never even try to predict what that means for the future as that
is a fool's game in my opinion.
 
2023 was a strange one for me.

Professionally, it was probably my most successful year to date, as I got to operate and shoot for not one, but two, Academy Award winning directors (one day-playing, and the other full-time). On a pair of films that (I suspect) will have some genuine cultural impact worldwide. So that’s been really fantastic.

Also the Arabic period drama series that I shot in Kuwait in 2022, was released, and (at its peak) was the 4th most streamed show in the Middle East. So that was a great milestone too (it’s nice getting on the charts somewhere at least!).

Financially it was pretty miserable though, as the main film I worked on (which was an 8-month long shoot), was paid at “award” rates (that’s our minimums here in Australia). So I was putting in 50-hour weeks Monday to Friday, and then working almost every weekend (for eight months) just to stop my bank account from going backwards.

So it was a seriously tough slog, even while “living the dream” (working on a film that people will actually go see).

One of these days, it would be nice if the two aspects could combine - good money for good work.
 
So it was a seriously tough slog, even while “living the dream” (working on a film that people will actually go see).

It's funny how most people assume that those working with top-tier directors are well-compensated, while most of the time it's the opposite. Meanwhile, Ken Burns is doing fundraising dinners to finance his next picture.

But good for you. Seriously. I wish that I could glimpse that world that world one day. But I won't hold my breath.

Is their a trailer for your Kuwait series online?
 
One of these days, it would be nice if the two aspects could combine - good money for good work.

Isn't there usually some scheduling balance between doing commercial work and doing artistically fulfilling work even for top-tier talent? In any case - please share links as the work comes online!
 
2023 was a strange one for me.

Professionally, it was probably my most successful year to date, as I got to operate and shoot for not one, but two, Academy Award winning directors (one day-playing, and the other full-time). On a pair of films that (I suspect) will have some genuine cultural impact worldwide. So that’s been really fantastic.

Also the Arabic period drama series that I shot in Kuwait in 2022, was released, and (at its peak) was the 4th most streamed show in the Middle East. So that was a great milestone too (it’s nice getting on the charts somewhere at least!).

Financially it was pretty miserable though, as the main film I worked on (which was an 8-month long shoot), was paid at “award” rates (that’s our minimums here in Australia). So I was putting in 50-hour weeks Monday to Friday, and then working almost every weekend (for eight months) just to stop my bank account from going backwards.

So it was a seriously tough slog, even while “living the dream” (working on a film that people will actually go see).

One of these days, it would be nice if the two aspects could combine - good money for good work.

Congrats on the milestone projects! Did you buy an Alexa 35? What if you land another 8 month project that uses a different camera?

Do you have any advice for meeting not quite established but definitely have potential Directors in the indy space who would take a chance with someone for a narrative project? I'd love to collaborate with a Director and shoot a short film but have never been able to find these people!
 
As a long time lurker, I'd like to share my two cents. Business for me was my biggest year so far. But that's because I'm a video production agency operating as a videographer. I pull in contractors when I need to (low overhead). I find my own work and hunt for it. As you all know, selling is a numbers and relationship game. My company has managed to weather this AI storm so far because we focus on human-centric talking head storytelling. (Cinematic docu-style work for Brand Story Videos, Testimonial Videos, Culture & Recruitment Videos, etc.)

I've found a way to repackage boring talking head and b-roll videos and sell them to clients to solve a specific business problem. I think that so far, regardless of how the AI trend has impacted social media videos, training videos, etc, I still see a huge need for this kind of human-centric work with every business that has a website. But I could be wrong.
 
I've found a way to repackage boring talking head and b-roll videos and sell them to clients to solve a specific business problem. I think that so far, regardless of how the AI trend has impacted social media videos, training videos, etc, I still see a huge need for this kind of human-centric work with every business that has a website. But I could be wrong.

You are not wrong. You are exactly right. Nothing has fundamentally changed in 40+ years of corporate video since VHS came a long and opened a whole new world for non-broadcast production. If you offer a service that solves a a specific business problem or benefits the client in some other way, you will always be busy. AI and social media won't change that.
 
One of these days, it would be nice if the two aspects could combine - good money for good work.

I think that is a unique aspect of our business that makes if different from a lot of other professions. It is often the most interesting, high profile, prestigious work that comes with the lowest pay. I have always leveraged the more mundane, yet lucrative work, to offset the lower pay offered on stuff that I know I will enjoy more. It's a balancing act. But generally I have given priority to the option that pays better, and as I get closer to retirement I have few regrets about the choices I've made on what projects to say yes or no to.

ON a slightly different note, when I hear some people complain that business is dead or very slow it makes me wonder if they are adapting fast enough to a changing market. You can't run your business the same way year after year or you will get left behind.
 
Last edited:
I find my own work and hunt for it. As you all know, selling is a numbers and relationship game.

Would you mind speaking about your methods for connecting with clients? I suspect that what I really need in order to get better at that is a personality transplant (because I'm shy). Nevertheless, it's the single most important part of our business and if you have any tips you care to share...
 
As a long time lurker, I'd like to share my two cents. Business for me was my biggest year so far. But that's because I'm a video production agency operating as a videographer. I pull in contractors when I need to (low overhead). I find my own work and hunt for it. As you all know, selling is a numbers and relationship game. My company has managed to weather this AI storm so far because we focus on human-centric talking head storytelling. (Cinematic docu-style work for Brand Story Videos, Testimonial Videos, Culture & Recruitment Videos, etc.)

I've found a way to repackage boring talking head and b-roll videos and sell them to clients to solve a specific business problem. I think that so far, regardless of how the AI trend has impacted social media videos, training videos, etc, I still see a huge need for this kind of human-centric work with every business that has a website. But I could be wrong.

I appreciate all of the info in this thread and everyone's contributions to this discussion. I'll contribute my part as well.

This is nearly my exact same business model and I have had a similar experience this past year, with a few exceptions and differences.

I also function as basically a one man production agency. I shoot photos, video and also edit and do post production. I also bring on freelancers when I need to expand to a larger crew, but I will typically shoot smaller corporate jobs with just one or two assistants to help with lighting.

I still haven't had a chance to review this past year's job specifics, but I feel like I split my time almost equally doing all three of the above. When I shoot video I am often also doing the post-production and editing for the client. This has been lucrative because the editing can fill in the down times when I am not out actively shooting and I can also squeeze in additional production days during the editing process. My clients like this because they don't have to spend time sourcing a separate editor.

Shooting photos allows me to utilize my equipment and skillset across more than one vertical. I have to maintain additional equipment in-house but my clients know that I can do both and so they will often reach out to me when they need just photos or just video, depending on the project. They don't have to go elsewhere to find a new photographer or someone else to shoot video. I can also piggyback on other productions when they only want to do one thing (either photo or video) and need additional support.

Most of my jobs in the past year have been doing work for local advertising agencies. So they have the B2B client and they need a specialist to go execute the work. This is not ideal since they have the direct connection, but on the other hand they typically have larger budgets, understand the process of what things cost, and have no problem signing off on respectable estimates. They simply add their 15-30% markup on to my cost and away we go.

There are basically two paths that most agencies are taking right now.

The first is to build a full-service in-house team of creatives. Hire photographers, videographers, editors, graphic designers, copywriters, etc. and have everyone on payroll and ready to respond to whatever creative request a client may have. This is the old-school approach to running a creative agency.

In the past several years though I have seen a trend of agencies moving the other way, to a 100% outsourced model. The agency handles the client communication, business development and creative strategy, but all "production" work is outsourced. They are "full-service" agencies who send all of the client's creative requests out the door and work with partners to do the work.

This past year was my first year full-time freelance. Up until that time I had been in-house at various advertising agencies. This has also been my most lucrative year financially. No surprise that you can make more money working for yourself, as long as you have the clients and work coming in. Almost all of my work has come via prior connections and word of mouth. Relationships are the key.
 
Would you mind speaking about your methods for connecting with clients? I suspect that what I really need in order to get better at that is a personality transplant (because I'm shy). Nevertheless, it's the single most important part of our business and if you have any tips you care to share...

Business Development is a big world so a single forum post won't be that helpful, but a majority of business development is a combination of several things: relationships, follow-up, business acumen, and negotiation. I think most creatives struggle with a combination of those things. I had the opportunity to have a sales/business development job for 3 years which taught me a lot about cold emailing, networking, sales CRM's, follow up, contract negotiation, pitching, etc. It was invaluable for me. Today I can confidently go out there and sell $5-10k 1-2 day shoot talking head + b-roll 3 minute videos for clients that I can pull off by myself if I wanted to. The videos are formulaic and repetitive for me, but for many of my clients, it's the first time they've ever gotten a video of that quality before. So I have a little niche that I think is farm-able for quite some time. And then I try to sell monthly packages to repurpose a lot of that interview and b-roll content into 10-20 social media reels for the client in 3-6 month increments. I'm happy to share more of my experience if you're interested. Happy to help.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top