I gave the indie dollie a test run last friday

Well, it's all business expenses, I mean starting any business costs money and I don't believe in a production company not owning production equipment. That has to be one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. If I actually found out that major production companies didn't own any equipment I would assume they were run by morons. The price of renting equipment isn't worthwhile if you're doing frequent productions. Now a development production company that only shoots features, for instance, that I can understand, why buy Technocranes, 35mm cameras, Fisher dollies (which you can't buy anyway), etc. if you are just developing and producing features? But if you are making music videos or commercials and you don't own the means of production, that's as stupid to me as a restaurant without a blender, an oven, stove, etc. It makes absolutely no sense. We heard from the very start down here, "Well it's a rental market, everyone rents." I think there are a lot of people down here with no business sense, or everyone is afraid to own, because the price of renting commercially is ludicrous, you look for office space they want $700 for 100 sq. feet. I'm going to get into that business sooner rather than later, we've already discussed buying a commercial building. I've never seen a market so out of whack as this one. Since everyone refuses to buy anything, I don't know if it's lack of money or lack of intelligence or what, then the companies that rent anything are in the business of ripping you off. I would say it's more than just a rip off, it's like highway robbery. $9 for a $187 indestructible c-stand per day. Yeah, that makes sense, thanks Mole Richardson! I told them I'd give 'em $5 and that's it, they said fine. But just the fact you have to negotiate everything is exasperating after a while.

If you shoot 2 projects per year, I guess it makes sense to rent if each one only takes a week or less to shoot. But if you shoot 3-4 projects per month even one day each, you better buy, because in 8 months for what you just flushed down the toilet in rental fees you could have owned everything. Also it's funny some people make a big deal about, "Well the rental guys keep everything working and tested and in great shape." This isn't like 1932. This is 2007. The HVX200 is still considered a prosumer camera, i.e. it's built to work. It won't just stop working for no reason as long as you take good care of it. Rental companies don't know anything more about servicing an HVX200 than your average consumer does, so that argument is worthless. And c-stands don't need servicing. Basically when it comes down to it we decided that we'd rather pay everything upfront and own the means of production than making rental companies rich by overcharging for everything.

What's funny is apparently only n00bs and major studios rent from the big guys, because everyone else knows they are a rip off, but the major studios just don't care. Or maybe they are getting incredible breaks that make prices affordable because of the equipment volume rented. That must be the case, I would think, because they're absolutely a rip off for low budget filmmaking.

Why a company as big as Warner Bros. wouldn't own its own massive equipment rental company, I have no idea. Just look at Google -- they used to just have a search engine, did they content themselves with that? Absolutely not. They bought DoubleClick, one of the biggest online advertisers, and they had already launched Google Adsense, then they bought MySpace, and they continue to buy other related businesses. The big studios aren't apparently smart enough to figure out that if companies are making money off them, they should own those companies to prevent the outflow of money. It's not difficult to understand. Eventually if you've been in business long enough you should own virtually every business type that you spend money on. If you're a massive film production company (WB, Fox, etc.) you should own a location agency yourself, that way not only do you keep someone from getting rich off your needs but you make money off other people's needs, you should own an equipment rental company, you should own transportation companies, you should probably even own an aerial helicopter company, etc. They seemed to figure out that you should own your own studio backlots, give them a cookie for that I guess, but I can't understand any business plan that doesn't eventually end in you owning every part of production from start to finish. Telecine houses, editing labs, everything. Nobody should be making money off you, you should be making money off everyone else and giving your main company a discount on services rendered to the parent company. That's the type of vertical integration that they teach in any good business school. The film industry just doesn't seem dominated by people who understand business very well. Of course, most of these studios are now owned by larger parent companies, and that is an example of excellent vertical integration. But that wasn't the innovation of the film companies; that was just market forces that snatched up valuable assets. Who knows, maybe the major studios do own more companies than I know, but I shouldn't hear about Paramount renting out lights from Mole for Indy 4. They should already own all of those lights. I thought that was a joke or something, Paramount is too poor to own all of its own production equipment?! That makes no sense at all.
 
Jonathan,

I completely agree with you. I started this film idea/project with ZERO gear. So everyone told me JUST RENT IT. after checking prices of rentals and assessing how many days and how long it will take for me to complete a 130 minute period film filming week-ends mostly, it became obvious that renting was the stupidest idea, money wise.

Also when you own you;

1- know you gear
2- Know where it's been and if it is working well
3- don't have to waste time and gas driving back and forth to rental companies to rent and then return gear
4- If you outdoor shoot gets rained/cancelled, you don't lose money on gear you rented and could not use.
5- if you decide to film something at a moment's notice (ex: a great cloud storm time laps) you can cause the gear is HERE and READY to go.

And I agree when you rent gear you never know if it is going to work right. I experienced that with a shoot at Paso Robles car show - a once a year event. I filmed a dialogue there and the rental adapter for shotgun mic was bad and kept cutting off on and off: Result? Scene not useable and no way to redo it - for another year.

Since owning my own gear I have never run into any technical problems. everything has been bought NEW and of decent quality and I take very good care of it. And it's there for me when I need it.
 
Last edited:
Renting is only good if it's a one off or limited use piece of gear. So friggin happy I just got most of my stuff.. Just the hassel of not having to deal with the usually surly and overly bitter rental staff at most places is reason enough to own gear..
 
I totally agree with you two. There are a lot of advantages you don't even always consider about owning your own gear, until you need to rent something you don't own. It costs more than just the price of renting gear, too, as Deuce said you also have to arrange for pickup at various rental places and usually if you're going to rent a bunch of stuff it won't be at one place. I mean, you'll go to one place for grip and lighting equipment and another for camera and lenses plus accessories. Last time was extremely stressful for us because I was supposed to have everything I needed to shoot except for some lights, except that my order with B&H hadn't shipped because of a communication error and their extremely long Jewish holiday. The guys at Mole Richardson took forever to get our lights and grip equipment together, there was just a lot of screwing around, apparently understaffed or something, and he forgot a few pieces of the order I had to remind him to get, so after what seemed like forever we had only 20 minutes to get to Birns & Sawyer (close to Mole, but awful time of the day to drive) and pickup our follow focus and our reference monitor (these were on order from B&H). I was already annoyed that the monitor was $250 for a day, which is really harsh for a $2,800 monitor. Fortunately Birns & Sawyer wasn't all ticked off we got there just before closing, about 5 minutes before, and they stayed open quite a bit past 5 anyway. There were, however, problems with the order that added up to ONE HOUR of waiting there. Apparently whoever had the follow focus that was supposed to be rented to us (they have many, but this one was due back) hadn't called and hadn't returned the equipment, so they were trying to figure out some way to help us out, which I appreciated. Finally they decided to open a new follow focus package and let us use that, if we promised to be careful with it because they still wanted to sell it later, but that whole process took us an hour.

It ended up we spent about 3 hours or so total driving to Hollywood, going to two rental places, and picking up the equipment. That doesn't include the time we spent already calling them, filling out insurance forms, giving them my life history, figuring out if they did or did not have the equipment we wanted (Mole was out of the type of dimmers my DP wanted, so we got two 2K hand dimmers), and haggling over price. I would say the entire ordeal took us about 6-7 hours for sure, because these guys were not exactly fast about anything.

I am not at all saying that everyone should have the money to go buy everything; the fact is, most people can't afford to just go buy every piece of equipment they need. Even we don't want to buy 1.2Kw HMIs because they're for periodical use and we'd rather just rent them when we need them unless we're seriously using them 3-4 days per month because we have a shoot going almost every day, but I don't see that happening for a long time. Certain things do make sense to rent.

I do think if you have the money, though, and are really serious about wanting to be in the film industry either as a professional or even if you just spend a lot of time doing this as a hobby, it makes perfect sense to own the equipment you will be using commonly or on nearly every shoot. There is this great feeling of power (i.e. freedom) of having what you need to go make a professional project and knowing that if someone contacts you about a spur of the moment filming opportunity you can make it happen without too many headaches.

My problem right now is a logistics one. Not too long ago I wasn't far along with making professional work, so I had my XL-2, my SE-66 boom mic, and a lousy tripod that couldn't hardly be considered even consumer grade ;) I could fit that into the back of my tiny Celica. Now, last shoot with the stuff we rented and what we owned, it barely, barely fit into a large U-Haul van. With what I have bought since then (M2, lenses, Porta-Jib, more light kits) there's simply no way that even a van would hold the stuff comfortably. I could probably make it all fit somehow, but then you have to unload everything before you can shoot anything, and that's really inconvenient and let's be honest requires more grips or PAs available to help out. So we want to buy a truck, but that's the easy part. Where the heck do we park the truck? If I have to park it in an unsecured location, then I might as well not buy one at all. That would involve leaving all of my equipment in secured storage, which we have, and then loading the truck for every shoot we do. If we're going to do that, why pay insurance and parking for the truck plus the cost of buying it when we can rent the truck from U-Haul or wherever else? So the key is finding some secured monthly parking where we can leave the equipment in the truck ready to shoot whenever and on the day of the shoot just get in the truck and drive to the location. Neither one of myself or my business partner own a house. I own a condo, so I have secure parking but you can't fit a truck into the garage. My business partner will probably buy a house sometime in 2008, so we may get a truck then and just back the truck against the garage, add a security camera or something along those lines and it's Burbank so it's pretty safe anyway. But for now I'm at a loss, I couldn't find any parking like I was describing in Los Angeles. We've both searched online a bunch of times and found mainly car parking in unused garages or whatnot.

The more equipment, the more options, but also the more headaches! haha.
 
Does it have a seat (aka: Can one sit on the dolly while moving it)?

Nope, no seat. At least the one I used. I really do not know if its an extra.

The microdolly guys HQ is in Hollywood, so you basically are pretty close to them. Why don't you go to their website?

wwwDOTmicrodollyDOTcom (Not posting direct link since its not one of the site's sponsors)

I actually tought about purchasing it for my independent filmmaking, but at 2500 prior shipping to were I am, its just too expensive. But I see they have different prices for US and Non US residents, so maybe you guys can get a much better deal...

Its the Best dolly I've ever seen for guerrila type shooting. Setup in 2 minutes, fits in a tripod bag- wheels, platform and tracks (!). Efficient indeed...
 
I've used the "buy what you need and can afford/rent beyond that" paradigm for many years in my recording studio business and it's worked very well for me.

So I own a lot of nice audio gear, but have stopped short of investing in the truly expensive stuff. For example, my main analog audio console, after modifications, cost about $16,000 and sounds excellent. Over the years, music scores for many feature films and documentaries (including "American Splendor", "The Notorious Bettie Page", and many others) have been mixed here (although the latter were done largely in Pro Tools), as well as lots of pop albums and other projects. My clients are happy with the results, and my rates are much lower than major commercial recording studios here in NYC (which, in fairness, is in no small part due to the fact that my studio is in my apartment).

When it's necessary to record a large orchestra however, (as it was with both films mentioned above), or anything else that doesn't fit into my rather modest space, I and my clients go out to one of those major studios for whatever number of days is necessary and record there (I started out in "big" studios, so I'm comfortable working in them as well). It costs my clients many multiples of what I charge here, but it's a relatively short time, and the large space is essential.

Just the console itself at Legacy Studios' scoring stage where we recorded "The Notorious Bettie Page" probably cost them about a million dollars. There's no way I'm ever buying one of those. The studio altogether probably represents an investment of $10 million or so.

Nonetheless, I manage to do better than 90% of my work in my little studio, where I've invested a tiny fraction of that.

So I'm basing my growing HVX200-based film production capability on the same idea. I'll probably level off at about a $40K investment all up, and rent whatever I need above that. Hopefully it'll work out as well for me as the recording studio concept has.
 
Nope, no seat. At least the one I used. I really do not know if its an extra.

The microdolly guys HQ is in Hollywood, so you basically are pretty close to them. Why don't you go to their website?

wwwDOTmicrodollyDOTcom (Not posting direct link since its not one of the site's sponsors)

I actually tought about purchasing it for my independent filmmaking, but at 2500 prior shipping to were I am, its just too expensive. But I see they have different prices for US and Non US residents, so maybe you guys can get a much better deal...

Its the Best dolly I've ever seen for guerrila type shooting. Setup in 2 minutes, fits in a tripod bag- wheels, platform and tracks (!). Efficient indeed...

OK, I am due for a trip to Holluywood cause I am going to Birn and Sawyer to bug Peter a bit :) - he is such a cool guy I love him. he has really been taking good care of me, especially since he is a hotrodder himself and classic car collector. Anywhoo, I'll go see that dolly. $2,500 sound steep though, since Indie dolly is only $1600 and HAS A SEAT. Which is a must have, IMHO.
 
Jonnathan,

I see your dilemma... AS for me, i think I am going to try and be a good girl and keep a "minimalist" approach. I know it's hard cause you always need more stuff to get those cool shots, but I will try to rely more on creativity, the way I film and composition rather than lots of extra cool gear. This way I can throw everything in my truck and go.

It helps to have a trailer too. I happen to have one 9a super tiny, but fully equipped one) cause I love camping and offroading, and it has come very handy already a bunch of time.

Like shooting on location in the desert with 115F. I had some extras, kids and women so we had them inside the air conditioned trailer. We could get out of the brutal sun and get something cool to drink from the fridge and people used the trailer to change too. there is a mirror and vanity with good light for makeup. And I slept in it over that week-end too. PLUS it doubled as " gear truck" so between the trailer and the Tundra's long bed, I had plenty of room to pile up stuff, even ladders and what nots. but I was never more than 10 feet away from the rig.


Oh here, I'll share a few behind the scenes shots:

Here I am directing the flashback scene

Copyright%20internet%20images3.jpg




This is my mini caddy, which produced lovely smooth traveling shots that day (better than nothing and fits in your back pocket hehe -
You can see the trailer behind us. It is the smallest fully contained trailer I have ever seen :) and I can park it in front of my garage.

Copyright%20internet%20images%203.jpg


Women and kids hide from the brutal deadly mohave desert July SUN:

DSCN0836.JPG



Meanwhile, the hotrodders get their cars ready, painting race numbers on them: the black 1932 roadster in the foreground, which is the star car of the film, is mine.

website%20SCTA%20flashback%20scene%201.jpg



now we are ready to film:

Copyright%20internet%20images%202.jpg






PS: I am looking for others interested in getting involved in this film, if anyone in L.A is interested, PM me. I need to put a crew together to begin serious filming in Jan. This is going to end up being a cult film, more than likely. It would be well worth your time.

Thanks for checking it out.




.
 
I can actually manage pan and tilt dolly shots without a seat with the microdolly. However, I do need to do some rehearsals first. Its not the easiest of shots, but doable. It works without the seat, as long as you have a person that can control his strengh pushing it...

As for owning your own gear... I'm in a very different place than you guys. Simply put, here, there are no rental houses. This is like the Wild West of production. If I need to rent gear, it has to come from Hong-Kong, which, while being only 30 Kilometres away, its however a whole different "country". Different state of law, different passports, etc. What this means is that I'm hardly a business rental house's target business target. And only the price of insurance and the legal stuff+ the international rates make everything just not economically viable.

Which leaves me no choice but to buy my own gear. me and the other few around here.

Deuce, very interesting subject/ theme for your movie! Looking at those shots reminds me of Mad Max immediately :)

I look forward to seeing it. Keep it up!

EDIT- However, if I was renting (there in the States), I could afford to shoot a feature in a HPX3000 with decent lens, as long as I wrote my script with few locations and had everything well organized to shoot in 4 to 5 days. This would obvioulsy look miles better than a DVX feature. However, nowadays, with the low end HD cameras like the HVX performing so well, and the appearance of 35mm adapters, that basically took out one ofthe biggest disadvantages of these low budget cameras for narratrive filmmaking (the DOF), as long as you have good support gear, like good lighting, sound, and, of course, good talent both in front and behind the camera, you can actually achieve a technically Big Screen acceptable film, very close to a Varicam or even 16mm/ 35mm result.

But, beating on the dead horse for the $^%& time, its all about the story. If its crap, the movie is crap. Simple as that! :)
 
Last edited:
Deuce, very interesting subject/ theme for your movie! Looking at those shots reminds me of Mad Max immediately :)

I look forward to seeing it. Keep it up!

Actually this is a flashback scene of a 1954 dry lake racing. This has been a tradition in the States since the 30's. It is at the heart of hotrodding and one of the most majestic location anyone could hope for in my area. I am very fortunate that I have such beautiful things to film for my story. I also have world's best lindyhop and swing dancers and awesome swing and rockabilly bands. I have rare cars donated by museums, car owners etc.. In fact I have classic cars coming out of my nostrils right now (and a few other places I am not at liberty to mention on this respectable board HAHA!)
 
MICRO DOLLY is anotehr dolly I am going to test next week. they are right here in Burbank.

However, from a first glance at the product and short conversation with salesrep, i can alredy tell I like indiedolly better.

A few reasons:

1. Price (GOOD reason LOL). This one is $2,700, sobasically $1,000 MORE than indie dolly.

2. Seat. There is no way for the camera operator to be ON the dolly. Only the camera can be moved from A to B, and moving a camera PLUS pan & tilt is pretty hard to do smoothly. heck, even when sitting on the dolly I ofund that panning and tilting was challenging.

3. Looking at the base itself, it looks much more flimzy than that of indiedolly. Microdlly wheels just sit on top of the tracks. One wheel per contact point (3 wheels altogether) Indie dolly's wheels wrap around, so basically you have six wheels for each contact point, two that sit on top of track and 4 more that holds the track from the sides (see photos). Seems a lot better to me.

microdolly wheel system: 1 wheel per contact point

des_cmbo.jpg



Indie dolly wheel system: 6 wheels per contact point

dollyonStrack.jpg


All in all seems Indiedolly has the advantage, but I will be a good girl and do my homework and try the competitor anyways, what the heck. I will do test shots and when I get my puter back I will post both shots filmed with the two systems. let's see how they compare.
 
PS: if you are thinking about getting an Indiedolly system do it NOW cause as or Jan 2008 they are raising their prices.

I know what I'm stuffing MY Christmas stockin' with this year hehehehe...

Oh an I forgot to say: My crazy A.D, who is a hardcore hotrodder looked at it and said: let's put an electric motor to it to make it move at set speed evenly across the rails...

Funny thing is: I think he was SERIOUS

Funnier thing is: I think he might have a good idea there... LOL
 
PS: if you are thinking about getting an Indiedolly system do it NOW cause as or Jan 2008 they are raising their prices.

I know what I'm stuffing MY Christmas stockin' with this year hehehehe...

Oh an I forgot to say: My crazy A.D, who is a hardcore hotrodder looked at it and said: let's put an electric motor to it to make it move at set speed evenly across the rails...

Funny thing is: I think he was SERIOUS

Funnier thing is: I think he might have a good idea there... LOL

Since I haven't tried the indie dolly, I'm awaiting your review on this to make my personal purrchase decision!

Do post what you think about setup time. This is important for me, and the main plus I found using the microdolly system-that and its portability and lightweight.

Have fun! :)
 
I have the Indie-dolly (straight and curved track) and I'm very happy with it. My DP does wish that the platform was a little bigger to accomodate his 1st AC, but it works fine just pushing it along. I have footage from the dolly on my website:

www.drawingchalkpictures.com/previews.html

Clips Scene 16 (part 3) and Scene 47 have the dolly. Scene 47 used the straight and curved track.

I really liked how easy it is to setup, even on grass and the results are very good (definitely ups the production quality at a reasonable price).

Todd
 
I have the Indie-dolly (straight and curved track) and I'm very happy with it. My DP does wish that the platform was a little bigger to accomodate his 1st AC, but it works fine just pushing it along. I have footage from the dolly on my website:

www.drawingchalkpictures.com/previews.html

Clips Scene 16 (part 3) and Scene 47 have the dolly. Scene 47 used the straight and curved track.

I really liked how easy it is to setup, even on grass and the results are very good (definitely ups the production quality at a reasonable price).

Todd

Very nice looking clips, Todd!
 
Thanks Ted.

We're in production until May and then I have all the audio production to work on (including recording 16 new songs for the film). It's all worth it in the end.

Todd
 
Not sure why this thread is in the HVX section, but...

I've used the indie dolly twice now, so I can assure you it is a piece of crap.

*It is the most confusing thing to build. Without a manual, it will take two intelligent people no less than 45 minutes to assemble.

*The track sections come apart. Unless I am missing something, there really is next to nothing to prevent the tracks from separating.

*Forget about riding it. It is not built to withstand a human operator. The only stable way I have found to operate it is by having the camera operator walk along side of the dolly and push the dolly with the tripod head.

To be fair, I am used to using real dollies. I understand that the Indie Dolly inexpensive, and meant for low-budget productions, but that in itself doesn't make it any good.
 
*It is the most confusing thing to build. Without a manual, it will take two intelligent people no less than 45 minutes to assemble.
I had the same problem at first, then I looked online at a picture then got it. After setting it up once I could set it up and be able to shoot in less than 10 minutes, and I sucessfully did that on 3 occasions. Always do a test run before you shoot to make sure you can be able to set up and run equipment effectively.

*The track sections come apart. Unless I am missing something, there really is next to nothing to prevent the tracks from separating.
There's velcro straps to secure each section together via the metal supports running perpendicular to the tracks. Once you have those in you can pretty much bet on them never coming apart.[/quote]

*Forget about riding it. It is not built to withstand a human operator. The only stable way I have found to operate it is by having the camera operator walk along side of the dolly and push the dolly with the tripod head.
I agree with you here, I am just an average size guy and the dolly struggles with me on the dolly. You really need someone petite to man the camera if you want to ride the dolly[/quote]

To be fair, I am used to using real dollies. I understand that the Indie Dolly inexpensive, and meant for low-budget productions, but that in itself doesn't make it any good.
Given what it is it's pretty darn impressive. The indie dolly I used has been at Towson University for 2 years now and it STILL functions perfectly, even after being manhandled by dozens of film students who don't necessarily know what they're doing. I really think it stands the test of time, but that's just my opinion.
 
Not sure why this thread is in the HVX section, but...

I've used the indie dolly twice now, so I can assure you it is a piece of crap.

*It is the most confusing thing to build. Without a manual, it will take two intelligent people no less than 45 minutes to assemble.

*The track sections come apart. Unless I am missing something, there really is next to nothing to prevent the tracks from separating.

*Forget about riding it. It is not built to withstand a human operator. The only stable way I have found to operate it is by having the camera operator walk along side of the dolly and push the dolly with the tripod head.

To be fair, I am used to using real dollies. I understand that the Indie Dolly inexpensive, and meant for low-budget productions, but that in itself doesn't make it any good.

Well I completely disagree with everything you said.

1. I did not have a manual and put it together the first time without any problems. the next day I broke it down and took it to the DVX user LA meet. I put it back together in 1/2 the time it took the first time. 4 hours later I broke it down and took it home. the next day I was asked to bring it to a fellow dvxuser shoot who needed it. So I put it together again, and it took no time at all. So, no, you do not need a high IQ to figure it out quick.

2. the tracks are kept together with the straps, which are very solid velcro. So far no problem there on my end. I have not tried it on rought terrain yet, but on carpet or even patio relatively uneven cement saturday it stayed together solid.

3. At the dvx user meet severtal people rode it. "Uslatincontent" is probably 6 feet tall, he is lean though but he is certainly a lot heavier than I am and the dolly performed beautifully. At the shoot yesterday, david rode it and had no problem. I would not put a 300 lbs man on it though. The dolly is very stable, if you have the $175 additional platform (I got it).

Now I am sure that compared to high end $$$$$$$ dollies like the ones you use, this lower end dolly could be labelled as a "piece of junk" but to us indie filmmakers who do not have a bank attached to our hip, let me just say that this will make beautiful shots for the money.

Note that I have nothing to do with indie dolly and I am speaking my mind freely, saying what I think. I'll say it like it is.

So far the only drawback I have found is that the operator is not seated behind the camera when doing a straight forward push. So if the camera is aiming the same direction as where the tracks are pointed, you are sitting on the side and it becomes more difficult to do the shots. So reframing, panning that way is difficult. I might try to rig up one more seat location for me to sit in the center of the tracks behind the camera. Since I only weigh 115lbs, I can add hardware and probably be A-OK. With the help of my hotrodder friends, who customize and weld for a living, i am sure we can rig up something so I have better access for those shots. I'll let you know if we are able to come up with a solution.

In closing, for those who do not have a big budget, this dolly is well worth looking into.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top