Darkline
Veteran
Posting feedback is not always easy.
Im not here to make people feel better, but Im equally not going to say 'That was a load of old....'. We're a community of film-makers who need advice and encouragement. So you dont want to put people off making films forever by reviewing these films as you would Hollywood films - but equally Im not going to say 'This was Fantastic'... then give it a 4 in the voting process.
There were things i liked about most films, but that doesnt mean I thought the overall film was perhaps brilliant.
When I vote, I think I take the best film, give it a 9 or 10 then judge everything else down from that. That's just my way and everyone can vote however they like. As long as you're consistent and fair in your voting (i.e you're not trying to swing the competition by giving the films which you think are contenders 1-2).
If you're consistent and fair in you're voting approach, then it should not affect the placing of the final movies.
Im not here to make people feel better, but Im equally not going to say 'That was a load of old....'. We're a community of film-makers who need advice and encouragement. So you dont want to put people off making films forever by reviewing these films as you would Hollywood films - but equally Im not going to say 'This was Fantastic'... then give it a 4 in the voting process.
There were things i liked about most films, but that doesnt mean I thought the overall film was perhaps brilliant.
When I vote, I think I take the best film, give it a 9 or 10 then judge everything else down from that. That's just my way and everyone can vote however they like. As long as you're consistent and fair in your voting (i.e you're not trying to swing the competition by giving the films which you think are contenders 1-2).
If you're consistent and fair in you're voting approach, then it should not affect the placing of the final movies.
