So, who does everyone like so far?

VersuS said:
I will be suprised to see a top 5 that doesnt include:

Rekindled
ID
Bloody Mary
Dear Jane
Broken Circle

especially Rekindled and Bloody Mary must be in a close fight!!!!!
Click to expand...
Oooooh! I like this Top 5!!!

Thanks John! (I wouldn't it if you were correct! :) )
 
Ok. I think i've about viewed reviewd everyone, if your missing PM me.

My top 11. In no particular order are...

Sneak
Dear Jane
Rekindled
Halfway ('The Sack')
Reunion
Welcome
Bloody Mary
R.E.M
I.D.
Cure for writer's block No.9
5b

And I struggled with eleven. I've mixed them up you you can't guess how I voted. :)

Stricken and a few of the other NC films would have also been up there.

J.P.
 
Last edited:
jpbankesmercer said:
Ok. I think i've about viewed reviewd everyone, if your missing PM me.

My top 11. In no particular order are...

Sneak
Dear Jane
Rekindled
Halfway ('The Sack')
Reunion
Welcome
Bloody Mary
R.E.M
I.D.
Cure for writer's block No.9
5b

And I struggled with eleven. I've mixed them up you you can't guess how I voted. :)

Stricken and a few of the other NC films would have also been up there.

J.P.
Click to expand...

Why isn't yours in the list? It should be...
 
jpbankesmercer said:
Ok. I think i've about viewed reviewd everyone, if your missing PM me.

My top 11. In no particular order are...

Sneak
Dear Jane
Rekindled
Halfway ('The Sack')
Reunion
Welcome
Bloody Mary
R.E.M
I.D.
Cure for writer's block No.9
5b

And I struggled with eleven. I've mixed them up you you can't guess how I voted. :)

Stricken and a few of the other NC films would have also been up there.

J.P.
Click to expand...

:crybaby:
 
hahaha :) thanks buddy... BTW: In case I didn't say this before.... BROKEN CIRCLE rocked my socks!

I seriously haven't watched it again, in fear it might make me feel sick again... whoa!
 
I also wanted to say thanks to these fabulous films.

"Help! My movies not there but I uploaded in on Saturday"
By a few.

"The Quicktime Nightmare!"
By many.

"My adaptors bigger than yours!"
By a few.

"Anyone know of a file program to upload with for the MAC?"
By The Macc Lad's.

"Quicktime pro II The nightmare returns"
By the many.

"How do you get a good compression out of Premier 1.5?"
By the premierdonners. (me included)

"How do you get a good compression out of Avid?"
By the few.

"Hey I got a great compression out of Final Cut Pro!"
By the blessed.

“How do you upload to the server?”
By the many.

“FileZilla!”
By the P.C Boyz.

“Quicktime Pro III The P.C. version - No escape alive”
By the P.C Boyz.

J.P.
 
Last edited:
jpbankesmercer said:
Ok. I think i've about viewed reviewd everyone, if your missing PM me.

My top 11. In no particular order are...

Sneak
Dear Jane
Rekindled
Halfway ('The Sack')
Reunion
Welcome
Bloody Mary
R.E.M
I.D.
Cure for writer's block No.9
5b

And I struggled with eleven. I've mixed them up you you can't guess how I voted. :)

Stricken and a few of the other NC films would have also been up there.

J.P.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the acknowledgement JP, I've got you covered on my list!!!!!

Best to all!!!
 
Unfortunately, haven't watched them all, but have just enjoyed 'Bloody Mary' :o)
Like the ending to Buffalo :o)
 
Last edited:
I liked Broken Circle for the sheer simplicity of the concept. The delivery, as far as technique/technical of it was mixed, but the single shot concept is so demanding and it's pulled off well enough that I really enjoyed it.

But the film that I can watch multiple times is Bloody Mary. The foley/location sound is honestly its only weak point and the strengths outpace this minor nit by such a wide margin that it's almost not worth mentioning.

As with the short The Process in a prior contest, this feels like the most complete package -- great acting, great cinematography, love the soundtrack, on point editing and pace, and the best part is that the ending gives a sense of the story being larger than the alotted length of the film, rather than a lazy sudden drop-off that many shorts resort to.

I hope Bloody Mary wins -- they deserve it.

- jim
 
Finally got to them all.

My top three are:
Girl Next Door
Meat
Dear Jane

I still haven't figured out which order they'll be in though.
 
Welp, here's my top 9 in no particular order except alphabetical:

Broken Circle
The Commitment
Dear Jane
Halfway
Meat
Memories
The Morning After
Rekindled
Urine Trouble

I enjoyed watching them all. Good luck to everybody.


John G.
 
cinealma said:
Welp, here's my top 9 in no particular order except alphabetical:

Broken Circle
The Commitment
Dear Jane
Halfway
Meat
Memories
The Morning After
Rekindled
Urine Trouble

I enjoyed watching them all. Good luck to everybody.


John G.
Click to expand...

thats odd you chose 9. out of curiosity whats #10?
 
TimurCivan said:
thats odd you chose 9. out of curiosity whats #10?
Click to expand...

Top 10's are fascist. Top 9 is avant garde! :)

I actually have a 4-way tie after 9, so 9 is good for a summary on my end.


John G.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top