Best Western Film...

WANTED!
Dead or Alive
​

The greatest Westerns in cinematic history...​


This was one of the harder lists outta my series to edit all the way down to ten picks! Many had to be taken down...but when the smoke cleared, these were the gunslingers left standing.

I did not include such masterpieces as The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (which, though one of my favorite films overall, I just can't swallow as a Western.) For me, a true-blue Western is set (in whole or in part) in the American West...

Anyway, on with the lists.

Now, "Skin that smoke wagon!"


The Callaghan Top Ten:


#1 The Searchers (1956)
searchers400.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0049730/

#2 The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)
liberty_valance_1.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0056217/

#3 The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966)
good_bad366x156.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0060196/

#4 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)
Butch_Cassidy_and_the_Sundance_Kid.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0064115/

#5 Rio Bravo (1959)
Rio%20Bravo%20x01%20(1959).jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0053221/​
 
#6 Tombstone (1993)
611capture_tombstone04.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0108358/

#7 High Noon (1952)
sjff_01_img0221.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0044706/

#8 Tie: Unforgiven (1992) -and- Silverado (1985)
unforgiven.jpg
...
nmfilm03_.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0105695/
http://imdb.com/title/tt0090022/

#9 Bandolero! (1968)
bandolero003.jpg

http://imdb.com/title/tt0062708/

#10 Stagecoach (1939)
stagecoach.GIF

http://imdb.com/title/tt0031971/​


Honorable Mentions

-The Magnificent Seven (1960)
http://imdb.com/title/tt0054047/

-Once Upon a Time in the West (1968)
http://imdb.com/title/tt0064116/

-Winchester ‘73 (1950)
http://imdb.com/title/tt0043137/

-Dances With Wolves (1990)
http://imdb.com/title/tt0099348/

-The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)
http://imdb.com/title/tt0075029/
 
01 Tombstone
02 The Outlaw Josie Wales
03 Tom Horn
04 Jeremiah Johnson
05 Once Upon a Time in the West
06 High Plains Drifter
07 Unforgiven
08 Open Range
09 The Great Silence
10 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

Honorable Mention:
The Good the Bad and the Ugly
Quigley Down Under
Django
 
Sure to get some flack for my list. I realized a few things:

1. There aren't that many good westerns
2. I havent seen that many westerns
3. The old school films (Beyond the 70's) I find hard to like due the rudimentary approach to filmmaking

Hopefully my first selection will pass muster (filmsite.org recognizes it in the western genere; if not, Ill revise)

01. Tombstone
02. Open Range
03. Dances with Wolves
04. The Magnificent Seven
05. Westworld
06. Young Guns II
07. Young Guns
08. Unforgiven
09. Blazing Saddles
10.Wyatt Earp

Honorable Mention

DEADWOOD !
 
John,

That's your call, my man...but I personally couldn't saddle Mohicans as a Western. (Epic, War, Period Drama...yes, yes & yes IMO.)

The only flak that I can really shell in your direction is in response to
John_Hudson said:
...The old school films (Beyond the 70's) I find hard to like due the rudimentary approach to filmmaking...
:shocked: OUCH! :shocked:
rudimentary approach? rudimentary approach?
Oh! My heart!

"Dis is the big one!"
redfoxx.jpg
 
Last edited:
I love westerns.

Here is my top ten:

1. Shane
2. The Outlaw Josey Wales
3. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
4. The Searchers
5. Unforgiven
6. The Magnificent Seven
7. Dances with Wolves
8. Once Upon a Time in the West
9. Little Big Man
10. The Cowboys

Honorable Mention:

High Noon
Silverado
Red River

Chris
 
Hey John, Last of the Mohicans was originally on my list. It's a very borderline call with me as to whether it's a western or not. On my personal list, I still keep it there...at number 5! but for this list I decided to go a little more "cowboy" western...:)

Callaghan, couldn't you say the same things about Dances With Wolves, though? (Epic, War, Period Drama...yes, yes & yes IMO.) I think the biggest difference between the two is the time period and perhaps that's what defines the western, the time it took place. After all, I don't see any "modern" westerns on our lists. :)
 
How could anyone put Tombstone above OTIW? And Last of the Mochicans? That's before there was a "west."

Howabout:

1. One Upon a Time in the West
2. The Wild Bunch
3. The Good The Bad and the Ugly
4. Unforgiven
5. High Plains Drifter
6. Deadwood (to me it's one really long movie!)
7. Hombre
8. Silverado
9. 310 to Yuma
10. Quigly Down Under (Don't laugh! It counts)


As for rudementary approach. Hmmm. I'm sure you're far more talented than Sam Pekinpah, John Ford, and Sergeo Leone Combined. I mean, how can we forget that age makeup in Young Guns 2? No to mention Bon Jovi's brilliant and sophisticated sound track.

I also hate all art pre-photography, as it is too rudementary for me. I mean, Van Gogh couldn't even paint a straight line well.
 
Blaine said:
Callaghan, couldn't you say the same things about Dances With Wolves, though? (Epic, War, Period Drama...yes, yes & yes IMO.) I think the biggest difference between the two is the time period and perhaps that's what defines the western, the time it took place. After all, I don't see any "modern" westerns on our lists. :)
As with all genres, it is tricky business classifying films and setting up guidelines.

Personally I think westerns need 2 main ingredients:
-They are set (at least partly) in the American Frontier
-They are set during a span between the Civil War and the turn of the century

Mohicans is set during the French-Indian War, and takes place in the American Colonies. Like I said, though, that's just my criteria.

:beer:
 
Maybe greatness in a western should also be measured by how quotable the movie is...
"Are you going to do something? Or Stand there and Bleed?" Tombstone
"We got us a warrant too Sheriff, ... its writ by us and we mean to enforce it!"- Open Range
"Hey Where all the white women at?" Blazing Saddles
"My Little Buttercup...." Three Amigos
Etc.

JD
 
#1 The Searchers (1956)

#2 The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)

#3 The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966)

#4 Rio Bravo (1959)

#5 Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)

#6 Silverado (1985)

#7 Tombstone (1993)

#8 High Noon (1952)

#9 Stagecoach (1939)

#10 The Magnificent Seven (1960)


Honorable Mentions

-Unforgiven (1992)

-Once Upon a Time in the West (1968)
 
Jdaniels said:
Maybe greatness in a western should also be measured by how quotable the movie is...
"Are you going to do something? Or Stand there and Bleed?" Tombstone
"We got us a warrant too Sheriff, ... its writ by us and we mean to enforce it!"- Open Range
"Hey Where all the white women at?" Blazing Saddles
"My Little Buttercup...." Three Amigos
Etc.

JD
That's the thing The Outlaw Josie Wales wasn't short on. A sampling:

"There's another old saying, Senator: Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining"

"I didn't surrender, but they took my horse and made him surrender. They have him pulling a wagon up in Kansas I bet. "

"Dyin' ain't much of a livin', boy."

Lone Watie: I'm gettin' better at sneaking up on you like this. Only an Indian can do something like this.
Josey Wales: That's what I figured.
Lone Watie: You figured?
Josey Wales: Only an Indian could do something like that.
[Lone Watie hears a gun cock behind him; turns and sees Moonlight]
Lone Watie: It's not right; this damn woman doing something like this to me. I used to have power. Now old age is creeping up on me.
Josey Wales: More like old habits than old age.

"Not a hard man to track. Leaves dead men wherever he goes."

Lone Watie: [realizes Josey has snuck up behind and pulled a gun on him] They said a man could get rich on reward money if he could kill you.
Josey Wales: Seems like you was looking to gain some money here.
Lone Watie: Actually, I was looking to gain an edge. I thought you might be someone who would sneak up behind me with a gun.
Josey Wales: Where'd you ever get an idea like that? Besides it ain't supposed to be easy to sneak up behind an Indian
Lone Watie: I'm an Indian, all right; but here in the nation they call us the "civilized tribe". They call us "civilized" because we're easy to sneak up on. White men have been sneaking up on us for years.

There are so many more it's just not possible to include them all. If you've never seen The Outlaw Josie Wales, do yourself a favor and watch Clint Eastwood at the top of his form. :thumbsup:

For a full listing of some great quotes:
http://yoursay.imdb.com/title/tt0075029/quotes

The second best, quote-wise, would probably be Tombstone.
 
CallaghanFilms said:
As with all genres, it is tricky business classifying films and setting up guidelines.

Personally I think westerns need 2 main ingredients:
-They are set (at least partly) in the American Frontier
-They are set during a span between the Civil War and the turn of the century

Mohicans is set during the French-Indian War, and takes place in the American Colonies. Like I said, though, that's just my criteria.

:beer:
I hear you, Chad. I think you've got a great handle on the definition of a Western. I may not agree with your choices, as I'm sure some of mine won't hit the mark with you, but I can certainly agree with you on the criteria.
 
I think SHANE and HIGH NOON is the some of the most overrated 2 western movies...(Side note: They are marketed as ADULT WESTERNS with all the conventions of a classic Hollywood movie.) There are some great western B-movies in this category:
-JOHNNY GUITAR
-SEVEN MEN FROM NOW (Basically any Boettchier-Randalph Scot movie will do)
MAN OF THE WEST (Anthonhy Mann western B-movies)

May i suggest some spagetthi(Italian westerns) masterpieces for pure fun:
-A BULLET FOR THE GENERAL
-KEOMA
Remember Once Upon a time in the West is the ultimate spagetthi, which is one of the greatest westerns...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top