When client says your rate is too high

It is all relative. 21k for a concert is fine if the client is going to make 100k on the event. If they just want to document and try to sell copies no way will 21k work for them. But, it is all about how it works for you. If Arnie's overhead demands that rate for his company to operate then that is his rate this is not his client. There is no right or wrong. This client would have to settle for less production in order to match their 2-3k budget.
 
Really great thread, guys. Thanks for the comments. Also, what would you say if the client replied with, "But company X said they'll do this job for 10% cheaper than your rate." What's a diplomatic response to that? Same as some the answers as before?
 
Many ways to approach this. If the client liked the other company more they would just go with them, but for some reason they are still talking to you... If you want to business structure it as a one time discount rather than a lower rate. And mark it on an invoice as 10% first time customer discount so they know this is not going to happen all of the time. If it does then at least you will have one job to get to know the client and see if it is worth it to keep doing business with them.
 
He later sent me a link to what is probably the worst live concert clip I've ever seen. It looked to me a little bit like someone had a seizure and collapsed with their face on the switcher panel of the in house camera system.

Haha, brilliant description!
 
didnt we decide that the discount thing never works cause folks dont "see" all the discount stuff and just see the bottom line (i mean they may see it in the most literal sense but their minds are like "yeah yeah yeah whatever dude"), and want it again next time, and then you have the argument all over again?

I would think if you do X work for Y amount for Z client you have to be willing to do that perpetually or be willing to lose them upon trying to raise your price.
 
Yes, I agree. It is a slippery slope but the itemized discount gives you ammunition to cut them loose if they want to think the lower price is your usual rate. It may be smoke and mirrors but what else are you going to do? Saying "No" is a great skill but when you want to say yes you need some cloud cover from time to time. But in the end, learning how to avoid getting drawn into other peoples' dramas and false realities is very important for small business survival. "No" can be a great asset.
 
Great thread! Always interested to hear perspectives on this.

In my opinion, it's not cut and dry. My approach is this:

-Does this job pay me a profit above my CODB that is sustainable? If yes, great. If no?
-Does this job provide me with a learning experience that I'll be able to leverage in my favor moving forward? If no?
-Does this job provide me with contacts and relationships that ill benefit from moving forward? If no then I just thank them for thinking of me and try to connect them with other folks that might be better suited for the project.

Ideally it's all three. But I'll consider a job if I think it hits even one of those points in a potentially major way. Of course, the latter two are always a gamble and so there is always a level of risk when working for the less tangible benefits. But in my opinion, they can sometimes be more valuable in the long run. I just try to approach everything as an investment in my career and think of value not solely in terms of money or an immediate rate. And I have a mortgage and car payments and student loans and such...so I'm not just saying all this without knowing the value of a dollar. :)

Also, I think everyone should try to stick as close as possible to union rates in their given market. Not doing so only devalues our industry. In addition, that should also be accompanied by knowing you can deliver that standard of work. (I know, I know...pipe dreams)

Lastly, I think discounts are always something to consider. They can have negative effects, but also good effects depending on how the business relationship is structured. Not to mention that if you invoice for said discounts you can write it off on your taxes as a loss (USA). Of course, you shouldn't abuse it because that eats into your income...but if you use that as a bargaining chip to make an investment that can pay dividends later on, then all the better. All that said, it's important to value our work and it's important to work with people who also value our work. And also value other things in life so that a day without working a $200 full day isnt a loss, but instead a gain because that is a day that you can spend time with your valuable family...or gardening, or investing your friendships by grabbing a beer with your buddies.
 
Last edited:
I haven't read every post in this thread but I've dropped in from time to time.

It's a hard topic and everyone will have their own views - I think it comes down to what you are personally comfortable with.

Personally, if it is a one-day shoot-only job I won't budge my rate. The people who low-ball are usually the ones who don't understand production value because they don't do much production. If they don't do much production, there's not much chance for repeat business, so why bother pampering to their needs? I'd rather take that day off and relax.

On longer jobs or with returning clients, it's a lot easier to justify it. This is why many people have weekly/monthly rates too - because most people base their day rate on not working every day, so if you are working every day, you suddenly end up with plenty of room to move your rates. If I know a client is good for another 30 days throughout the year, then I know they'll already cover my living and business expenses for the year so I can be a bit more flexible with them.

Don't worry if you turn down a client or two because they tried to talk your rate down. 99.9% of the time if they don't have the budget now, they won't have it in 6 months either, so you've likely not missed any future work. Instead focus on keeping the good clients happy.

Of course you can also measure up what else you get out of any project other than money - whether that be unique experience, connections, product exchange, personal satisfaction, etc.
 
Most of the replies here seem to reflect the work of those folks that produce amazingly great videos. You might also want to add some additional salesmanship to your arsenal. Go to any car dealer if you need lessons in salesmanship. Look at the top-of-the-line luxury vehicle, then tell him you want to buy it for the cost of a low-end econobox. What follows is a lesson in letting a customer's budget define what he can buy.

I usually discuss any request for lowering cost with the customer. Let him come up with a dollar quote, then I tell him what we can do for that amount of money. That puts him in the position of better defining his needs and often results in a sale. Sometimes that job is a lower-dollar/less work job, and sometimes the client finds himself stating that he wants the same work for less money. In either case, it makes HIS position very clear to him and that might be a good situation for both of us.
 
Most of the replies here seem to reflect the work of those folks that produce amazingly great videos. You might also want to add some additional salesmanship to your arsenal. Go to any car dealer if you need lessons in salesmanship. Look at the top-of-the-line luxury vehicle, then tell him you want to buy it for the cost of a low-end econobox. What follows is a lesson in letting a customer's budget define what he can buy.

I usually discuss any request for lowering cost with the customer. Let him come up with a dollar quote, then I tell him what we can do for that amount of money. That puts him in the position of better defining his needs and often results in a sale. Sometimes that job is a lower-dollar/less work job, and sometimes the client finds himself stating that he wants the same work for less money. In either case, it makes HIS position very clear to him and that might be a good situation for both of us.

+1 This a good strategy in many cases.
 
I deal with a lot of folks who find me through one of my profiles online or who I have applied to through a Mandy/CL ad or similar. They're not going to meet in person. It's a simple job involving shooting, maybe editing. This brief online exchange is all there is every going to be. I have not had much luck getting people to JUST TELL ME WHAT THEY WANT TO SPEND so I can even see if I can take the job at all let alone at the scope they want. What usually happens (if we don't stop talking, period) is that we will go through a battery of questions/answers and I'll say "based on what you've told me, I would quote X" and then I never hear back. I don't know if there's some magic set of words that works on folks to get their budget up front without making them think I'm going to take every penny of it ("Oh, you only have $1500? WHAT A COINKYDINK! My services for everything come to EXACTLY $1500! LUCKY YOU!!!!"), which is why I assume they're reluctant to simply state that up front, but if there, I need those magic words. I have some beans I will exchange for them.
 
I deal with a lot of folks who find me through one of my profiles online or who I have applied to through a Mandy/CL ad or similar.

I've always thought that most people on places like CL seem to be looking to pay nothing or "good experience you can use to get other jobs" in lieu of cash, or if you're really lucky enough to pay for the gas and lunch. So I'm curious.... do you ever actually get any work that actually pays through CL?

I've got a 2-day shoot coming up and am in need of a 3 person crew. I can pay you with some magic water that will help your beans grow in a very special way. Interested? :laugh:
 
Oh yes. Don't get me wrong it's probably been fewer than 10 gigs in 14 years but it does occasionally happen. Strangely, sometimes sort of legit entities (ever heard of ManWithACam?) or projects/productions post ads on there without saying who they are until they respond to you. But yes, I have. It's worth looking at, to me. It is the BOTTOM of the sites that are worth looking at, but hey. . .
 
Without getting into too many details, I shot a V/R project for a defense contractor last year. The lighting was tricky and had to stitch together seamlessly in a challenging environment. Based on the work-load I adjusted my usual rate. The client replied it was higher than they had budgeted for. My reply was, "You're a defense contractor... shooting VR. That's the rate", said with humor but they saw my point, which is, sometimes you just have to know your value and have the confidence to project that.
 
Without getting into too many details, I shot a V/R project for a defense contractor last year. The lighting was tricky and had to stitch together seamlessly in a challenging environment. Based on the work-load I adjusted my usual rate. The client replied it was higher than they had budgeted for. My reply was, "You're a defense contractor... shooting VR. That's the rate", said with humor but they saw my point, which is, sometimes you just have to know your value and have the confidence to project that.


There is a lot to be said for delivery and other things like that. I have a friend that I've been shooting with over half my life that is "one of those guys" that can get away with saying the damnedest things. He could tell you to go F yourself and you'd just laugh and buy him a beer.
 
How do you guys feel out there who fit the role as a filmmaker, more so than just a Camera Op, Dp, Director. In this "Filmmaker Role" You are there for the pre productiopn, production and post and are usually wearing maybe 8 different hats for that project.

Do you guys seem to differ in your process of creating rates for yourself? Does self taught/ formal education play a role in this for you?

Just curious!
 
Sorry you find our rates out of line. Here are the numbers of some other shooters that may be able to help you out. Feel free to call us if we can be of further help.

Give them the names of 3 people way more expensive than you.

Haha, that is an evil genius approach! Love it.

(although those three other people might hate getting calls from people wasting their time as they'd never have the budget for them.... & they might then end up both hating you, making this a very foolish path to take indeed)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top