What features would you like to see in a field mixer?

In simpler terms.

Does each input need a level control which is exclusively assigned to it at all times?

or

Can there be a control (either rotary or push button) that can be assigned to any channel to update its settings?

In practical terms, how often do you "ride gain" on a channel where you need the ability to change its level quickly and without having to select which channel you are updating.

The analogy would be linear faders more commonly used in larger mixers (some times these are really faders and some times these are encoders updating the actual gain stages).
 
yes , you need ability for individual level control for preamp stage and it better would be in place you can do it momentary , this is very critical if you work with linear mikrophones wile you recording dialog or working in not predictable environment , less critical for wireless , since the gain structure doesn't change on receiver output , mostly you do it with tx setting and ride the levels with fader .
 
I think I see where your going, switchable pot would make it smaller and more mobile. However you'd still need to monitor all the channels at the same time, and a single switchable pot could increase the chance of moving the wrong channel at a critical time. I yhink a singl knob would be too prone to operator error.
 
Oleg,

I have to disagree with you.

Being in the position that I am in, I have the unique advantage of seeing what really sells and what doesn't, and I know what people want because they tell me all the time. If you want a mixer/recorder, then get a Deva/Portadrive/Cantar/PD-6. If you want a mixer, then get a mixer. To come out with another all in one box at this point is really not necessary. If someone is going to manufactiure a product, the idea is to make it as versatile as possible while still keeping the cost low. You just simply can't do that with high quality components, and having everying you would want. That's why Devas/Cantars/Portadrives/PD-6's cost what they do.

Every end use has the ultimate machine for them that they would want, but what you don't realize is that there are very few people that would actually want the same thing you would want, and the manufacturer will lose money in the long run. Talk to anyone...digidesign, zaxcom, fostex...they'll all tell you the same thing. If you get too specialized, you won't sell enough product to cover your cost. To make a mixer with timecode and recording functionality just doesn't make sense to me when there are already recorders out there and timecode products out there. In the world of manufacturing, the idea is to make something different from everyone else. If you take my 6 channel mixer idea, and mix it with your timecode/recorder idea, you pretty much have a pd-6/deva/cantar/portadrive. Why would someone want to make a product to compete in that market that is already dominated by those manufacturers?


-Dave
 
You so wrong - there is no even one normal mixer with recording capability which is light and cheap , and sorry the Beverly hills is very small part of the world - you see what you want to see , i see what is good for me and hundreds if not thousands like me people who work video and sometimes work film and sometimes need recording capability. these who hate the idiotic 100 kilo carts which so popular in your ariea . you see Hollywood Reality guys i see the day to day work .

but you have a good line in what you did write
"
In the world of manufacturing, the idea is to make something different from everyone else. "

and very wrong one

"If you take my 6 channel mixer idea, and mix it with your timecode/recorder idea, you pretty much have a pd-6/deva/cantar/portadrive. Why would someone want to make a product to compete in that market that is already dominated by those manufacturers?"

you cant mix with deva - sory it sucks as normal mixer , you cant work with cantar , its hippopotamus which brake your neck ,, portadrive , the same fatness problem , the pd -6 - who wont 4 kilo with dvd only capability
not to mention that all of them cost 8-20$, Are you joking or what - this is not for my idea clients :-)


Sorry to say but the only who did try to do it and eventually did not was the Deva Fution channel which staid on the drawing table

Since i dont know whats good for Hollywood - i want to ask you what is the best seller case for mixer you sell:-)

and who is Oleg
 
You are Oleg, and you know it, and don't try to hide it...and I know it's you because of the mixer case question you asked. As you know, I'm a big fan of Petrol bags, and I know you are a a very big reason for that.

Anyway, the Deva actually has quite a good mixer, if you've ever actually used it.

Just because I'm in Hollywood doesn't mean I don't deal with people all over the world. I do.

What I'm trying to say is that whatever this guy is working on should be a mixer, and just that. If you want a recorder, then get a recorder. If you want timecode, then get a recorder with timecode. It's that simple. If you build a box that's a mixer/recorder with timecode, it's going to cost at least 6 to 8 grand.

I'll agree with you about the cantar, portadrive, and pd-6. They are cool on the cart, but not all that great over the shoulder.

Now, if you could make a 6 channel mixer, with a 6+2 recorder built in, WITH timecode for under $5000, then you'd have a winner, but I really don't think that will happen with high quality components, not to mention the R&D involved...and ultimately there will be some glaring oversight that every manufacturer seems to make. Every single box out there has a "man, if it just did this" klind of a thing.

-Dave
 
Dave_Fisk said:
Every single box out there has a "man, if it just did this" klind of a thing.

-Dave

And hence the reason that I started this thread to begin with. It is true that no product can be everything to everyone, there are just too many different applications and too many different needs.

What we intend to produce is a field mixer, with perhaps the ability to add on board A->D conversion, but not storage (at least I don't think that this would be a consideration). Based upon the lack of a consensus (not that I REALLY expected one) our modularity concept seems valid.

The issues surrounding user interfaces (controls and how the user interacts with them) is very important to me because this is where users decide if they really like or dislike something. Any product can be a great performer (well only if well designed) but someone may still not like how they must work with it. A good user interface can help to set apart a good from a great product. So this is an area that I would really like to get more feedback on.

Thanks again to everyone who has contributed to this thread. I really do appreciate everyones input.
 
khmuse. thanks for clearing that up.

When it comes to knobs, go with something like what the Wendt or Sound Devices mixers use. The idea is to be able to turn a knob with just one finger and know where it is.

Have you seen the Sony DMX-P01? It's their 4 channel digital mixer. There are a lot of really cool features in it, but there are enough "what were they thinking" things in it to prevent it from really taking off. One thing I really really liked about it was it's DSP. That thing is powerful. If you could incorperate that sort of DSP into your mixer, that would really be cool.

-Dave
 
User interface so very important, but to tell you the truth we try to steer away from field mixers in favor of sound carts. I can't remeber the last ime I was in a place we couldn't get a sound cart to. Maybe if your doing documentaries and on the run all the time, but as far as films If I can get all the grip I need there I'm pretty sure I can get a sound cart there. So what I'd like is quality equipment made for a cart. The venue is certainly a step in the right direction and a great sound cart mixer rather then having to adapt something to fit would be more interesting to me. Our vision is that video village turns into a production center, where we're recording sound and video straight to HD's and with a internet link goes straight to the editor. So we really are looking for components that take us in that direction.
 
Whether it goes to actual pots or straight to digital I think most people will want individual knobs. I like these:

AD261 Fake.jpg


If you have trim pots then they should be the big knobs with primary gain being smaller. Then add 302 metering with digital number peak hold function (that has variable peak hold time).

Anything else I can think of has already been covered.

Just so you know where I'm coming from I'll be buying a 302 later this year or next spring... so my input may be less valuable because I'm in that price-range.
 
Dave_Fisk said:
You are Oleg, and you know it, and don't try to hide it...and I know it's you because of the mixer case question you asked. As you know, I'm a big fan of Petrol bags, and I know you are a a very big reason for that.

Anyway, the Deva actually has quite a good mixer, if you've ever actually used it.

Just because I'm in Hollywood doesn't mean I don't deal with people all over the world. I do.

What I'm trying to say is that whatever this guy is working on should be a mixer, and just that. If you want a recorder, then get a recorder. If you want timecode, then get a recorder with timecode. It's that simple. If you build a box that's a mixer/recorder with timecode, it's going to cost at least 6 to 8 grand.

I'll agree with you about the cantar, portadrive, and pd-6. They are cool on the cart, but not all that great over the shoulder.

Now, if you could make a 6 channel mixer, with a 6+2 recorder built in, WITH timecode for under $5000, then you'd have a winner, but I really don't think that will happen with high quality components, not to mention the R&D involved...and ultimately there will be some glaring oversight that every manufacturer seems to make. Every single box out there has a "man, if it just did this" klind of a thing.

-Dave

The deva doesn't build as mixer it wasnt desighn for that , it had aluck of normal outputs , fast preamp change , it have luck of extra faders , it doesnt have multyply camera solution in normal way , it soesnt even have output limiters , it doesn't have the facilities which make it friendly on over the shoulder regullar work its good as recorder, that it was desighn for .
i dont see any problem to make dissent mixer for half of the pd-6 price with 4 track recording capability,the fusion was advertise for 5 k with hard disk - who need hard disk ? i dont , idont need mirroring and i sertanly dont need more the 24/48 capability.without some isoteric futures it could be in the same price with less weight and another 2 inputs .
i am very sad that i had to go to other root and by stupid recorder from other company, now i have to strugle with 3 devices in my bag and not with one :-)

flash recorder only with 2 slots and tc is sold now for less the 2k) fostex fr-2 )
2 sd 302 are less then 2.5 k

so how much it would do in one body with ability go from 3 input minimum to 7 input maximum with recorder - think about that and as a modular product you will be able to choose how much you wont go forward .not to mention that the side kick could come as preamp stand alon 2 channels for studio use ( the same extention can work with powering module in your studio when you dont need it in your bag)

for company which starting from scratch to build one good mixerwhich can grow with the customer will be less painful then build 2-3 different sizes or build one and be in battle with another 4 manufacturers who do the same , and since they already did some money it would be very painful to recognize that the other can go lower in price and kick you out the business .
when you do uniq unit and if its good you will be able survive and put you in the right place and make the othere run after you .
to make 6 input as only mixer wouldn't give any advantage since the market share of these who really need it is extremely small , to make it comfortable for daily work would bring its size to the size of pd-6 - and in the regullar days while you wouldn't need all that size you will curse the day you bought it and get something smaller .
the psc build bad , the size and how close the pots each to other make it not user friendly , this is the same mistake as the 442 which tried to be the smallest mixer for it size but became as the worst to work with ( the sqn ,ad 261 , wendt or filmteck are much better in this section)
the 6 inputs is nice - but sorry i dont need it in 85% of my work

and you are mistake me with someone else even i know that Oleg did the first drawings of that product :-)i just wonted to show some points about outside Hollywood approach :-)
 
Uh, just to add my opinion: Im a pretty low budget filmmaker in South Africa - to me, A sound devices 302/442 hybrid device with a built in recorder (i like flash technology) would be the coolest thing in the universe.

I would want:

3/4 channel - i know you know a lot dave, but for all the times I wish I had more channels, there are 30 times I wont need them... I think its just too much cash for those channels. thats why Im buying a 302 over a 442 - its SO much cheaper for that one channel you lose (although I know the 442 has a much better interface and features)
LED meters, but maybe switch on/switch off LCD screen somewhere for settings (I think thats a bit of a cr@p thing of SD mixers).
MUST be hardware level controls for riding gain (ie must be instant level controls on channels)
2 headphone channels, maybe setup up so you can use com/slate mic (DISCRETELY) only on one channel to communicate with a boom op..
Strong battery life - maybe a camera type battery setup that you can charge? I know if its going to have a screen, AAs arent gonna hold up

Hardcore available gain to cleanly amp up soft spoken talent or sounds.

good options on the casing side: there are too many badly/third party designed cases out there...


I dont think TC is neccesary really, but an LCD screen would make upgrades an option I guess...
I dont even think multi outputs are very important (above a primary and a backup, that is)..


Uh, so now I joined the research group, Ill be waiting for my mixer in the mail when it comes out... ha ha! :)


yeah, um , i wish.
 
Again, I thank everyone for their input. I will be complying ideas through the end of this week and will begin the conceptual design early next week.

I really do appreciate everyones comments and ideas.
 
I think to build a mixer to compete with sound devices is a waste of money. You need to come out with something different, and believe me, you would sell a ton of 6 channel mixers. I talk with people every single day that want them. I could probably sell 10 within the next 15 minutes if I had them. Every single reality show out there would use them. Every one. They are going straight to camera, so they don't need TC or recording capability, nor do they want to pay for it.

-Dave
 
I think it would be cool if your product could be designed to input four channels into the HVX200 over firewire.

Your emphasis on quality is impressive. Keep it lightweight, that's the trend these days.
 
Why P2 when compactflash is so much cheaper per byte?

This "mixer" is quickly turning into what the Platypus is to the animal kingdom...design by committee. :happy:
 
Back
Top